Do I Really Need Surgery for an Anal Fistula?

Anal abscess

Hello Doctor: A few days ago, I had diarrhea for a whole day and experienced some pain in my anus, but it didn't affect my daily activities.
I ate seafood and drank beer the day before, and the next day I was in unbearable pain.
After work, I went to the pharmacy to buy anti-inflammatory medication, which helped a bit the next day.
However, I still went to see a doctor.
The doctor diagnosed me with an anal abscess.
After treating the abscess, the doctor mentioned that I need to consider undergoing anal fistula surgery.
Is it necessary to have the anal fistula surgery? Mine is located outside the anus, about one centimeter.
Thank you.

BOLEX, 40~49 year old female. Ask Date: 2018/03/27

Dr. Ke Fangxu reply Surgery

An anal abscess refers to an acute bacterial infection of the anus that leads to pus formation.
Half of the individuals will completely recover after medical treatment or incision and drainage, while the other half may develop a fistula due to incomplete healing.
An anal fistula has the potential to cause recurrent inflammation, so surgical treatment is generally recommended.
Therefore, these are two related but distinct conditions.
For the former, antibiotic treatment should be initiated first.
For the latter, observation may be appropriate, and if recurrent inflammation occurs, surgery can be performed.
Direct fistula excision is also an option.

Reply Date: 2018/03/27

More Info

When it comes to anal fistulas, the decision to undergo surgery is often a complex one that depends on various factors, including the severity of the condition, the symptoms you are experiencing, and the potential for complications if left untreated. An anal fistula is an abnormal connection between the anal canal and the skin surrounding the anus, often resulting from an infection or abscess.
In your case, it seems that you have already experienced some discomfort and pain, which led to a diagnosis of an anal abscess that was treated. However, the presence of a fistula suggests that there may be an underlying issue that needs to be addressed to prevent further complications.
Here are some key points to consider regarding the necessity of surgery for an anal fistula:
1. Symptoms and Quality of Life: If the fistula is causing significant discomfort, pain, or affecting your daily activities, surgery may be warranted. Even if the pain is currently manageable, anal fistulas can lead to recurrent infections or abscesses, which can be quite painful and disruptive.

2. Risk of Complications: Untreated anal fistulas can lead to complications such as recurrent abscesses, chronic pain, and even more severe infections. Surgery aims to eliminate the fistula and prevent these complications from arising.

3. Surgical Options: The standard treatment for anal fistulas is surgical intervention. The most common procedure is a fistulotomy, where the fistula tract is opened and allowed to heal from the inside out. This procedure is generally effective, but the specific approach may vary based on the complexity of the fistula and its location.

4. Non-Surgical Alternatives: In some cases, non-surgical treatments may be considered, especially if the fistula is not causing significant symptoms. However, these options are often less effective and may not provide a long-term solution.

5. Consultation with a Specialist: It is crucial to have a thorough discussion with a colorectal surgeon or a specialist in gastrointestinal disorders. They can provide insights into the specifics of your condition, the potential risks and benefits of surgery, and what you can expect during recovery.

6. Personal Factors: Your overall health, age, and lifestyle will also play a role in the decision-making process. If you have other underlying health conditions, these may influence the timing and type of surgery recommended.

In conclusion, while surgery for an anal fistula is not always mandatory, it is often the most effective way to address the issue and prevent future complications. Given that your fistula is located externally and has already caused pain and discomfort, it would be wise to consider surgical intervention seriously. Discuss your concerns and options thoroughly with your healthcare provider to make an informed decision that aligns with your health needs and lifestyle. Remember, addressing the issue now may save you from more significant problems in the future.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Anal Fistulas: Do They Always Require Surgery?

Hello, Doctor: Sometimes when I have a bowel movement, I notice blood when I wipe with toilet paper, and sometimes there isn't any. I thought it was hemorrhoids, and I also experience itching at times. I previously saw a doctor who diagnosed me with hemorrhoids, but recently...

Dr. Ke Fangxu reply Surgery
Hello: In response to your question, anal fistulas indeed require surgical treatment for a definitive cure. If not addressed in a timely manner, there is a possibility of progression from a simple to a complex type. If surgery is temporarily inconvenient, it is essential to monit...

Understanding Anal Abscesses and Fistulas: Do They Always Require Surgery?

I found a lump near my anus after using the restroom. Later, the doctor said it was a fistula and that I needed surgery. However, after researching online, it seems like it could be an anal abscess, and I haven't developed any small openings (which would indicate a fistula)....

Dr. Ke Fangxu reply Surgery
The National Health Insurance Quick Access is not a doctor; it can only provide general information for reference. Accurate diagnosis still relies on a physician. I understand that you may not comprehend why the doctor diagnosed you with a fistula. I can appreciate your reluctanc...

Do You Still Need Surgery for a Pain-Free Anal Abscess and Fistula?

Hello Doctor: Recently, I developed an abscess near my anus, for which I visited a clinic, received antibiotics, and had the pus drained. Currently, I no longer feel any foreign body sensation or pain. The clinic has advised me to go to the hospital for fistula surgery. Given tha...

Dr. Zhang Shuhao reply Surgery
If it is the first occurrence of an anal abscess and it is incised and drained, a fistula may not necessarily form. The clinic may discover this through palpation, or if there is recurrent swelling and pain, surgery may be recommended. If there is no pain, it indicates that the i...

Understanding Anal Fistulas: Surgical Options and Treatment Insights

Hello, Dr. Ke. I previously consulted with you regarding discomfort in my anal area since mid-August. During this time, I visited five different hospitals or clinics specializing in colorectal surgery. Some diagnosed me with a fistula, while others did not. Last week, I went to a...

Dr. Ke Fangxu reply Surgery
The anal fistula indeed requires surgery for a complete cure; however, if there are no symptoms and it is not continuously expanding, surgery may not be necessary. An anal fistula can potentially stabilize after fibrosis and may not worsen, in which case it functions similarly to...