Anal Abscesses and Fistulas: Do They Always Require Surgery? - Surgery

Share to:

Anal abscess?? Anal fistula??


I found a lump near my anus after using the restroom.
Later, the doctor said it was a fistula and that I needed surgery.
However, after researching online, it seems like it could be an anal abscess, and I haven't developed any small openings (which would indicate a fistula).
The health insurance app also shows the diagnosis as an anal abscess, but the doctors keep insisting it’s a fistula that requires surgery.
I switched to another hospital, and the doctor there also said it was a fistula that needed surgery, but the health insurance app clearly indicates the diagnosis is hemorrhoids.
I would like to know if an anal abscess always requires surgery to heal? I don't understand why the doctors keep saying it's a fistula.
Thank you.

Ting, 40~49 year old female. Ask Date: 2023/03/10

Dr. Ke Fangxu reply Surgery


The National Health Insurance Quick Access is not a doctor; it can only provide general information for reference.
Accurate diagnosis still relies on a physician.
I understand that you may not comprehend why the doctor diagnosed you with a fistula.
I can appreciate your reluctance to undergo surgery and your concerns about the potential consequences of not having the procedure.
The doctor should have explained this to you.
If it is an anal fistula, surgery is still necessary for a complete cure.

Reply Date: 2023/03/10

More Info


Anal abscesses and fistulas are common conditions that can cause significant discomfort and concern. Understanding these conditions is crucial for determining the appropriate treatment, which often involves surgical intervention.

An anal abscess is a collection of pus that forms near the anus, typically due to an infection. This infection can arise from blocked anal glands, trauma, or other underlying conditions. Symptoms of an anal abscess may include severe pain, swelling, redness, and sometimes fever. If left untreated, an abscess can lead to the formation of a fistula, which is an abnormal connection between the anal canal and the skin surrounding the anus.

A fistula often develops when an abscess drains spontaneously or is surgically drained. The resulting tract can become chronic and may require surgical intervention to fully resolve. It's important to note that while not all anal abscesses lead to fistulas, many do, and the presence of a fistula often necessitates surgery for complete healing.

Regarding your specific situation, it seems there is some confusion between the terms "anal abscess" and "fistula." While both conditions can be related, they are not the same. An abscess is an acute condition that can often be treated with drainage, while a fistula is a chronic condition that typically requires surgical repair. The fact that your doctors are suggesting surgery indicates they believe there is a fistula present, even if you do not see an external opening (the "small hole" you mentioned).

In terms of treatment, surgery is often the most effective way to address both anal abscesses and fistulas. For an abscess, the primary treatment is usually incision and drainage to remove the pus and relieve pressure. If a fistula is present, surgical options may include fistulotomy, where the fistula tract is opened and allowed to heal from the inside out, or more complex procedures if the fistula is complicated or involves multiple tracts.

It's also worth noting that while some conditions like hemorrhoids (痔瘡) can cause similar symptoms, they are distinct from abscesses and fistulas. Hemorrhoids are swollen veins in the rectal area and typically do not require the same surgical approach as abscesses or fistulas.

In summary, if you have been diagnosed with an anal abscess or a fistula, surgical intervention is often necessary for complete resolution. It's important to follow your healthcare provider's recommendations and discuss any concerns you have about the diagnosis or treatment plan. If you feel uncertain about the diagnosis, seeking a second opinion from a colorectal surgeon may provide additional clarity and reassurance. Remember, timely treatment can prevent complications and promote better outcomes.

Similar Q&A

Do I Really Need Surgery for an Anal Fistula?

Hello Doctor: A few days ago, I had diarrhea for a whole day and experienced some pain in my anus, but it didn't affect my daily activities. I ate seafood and drank beer the day before, and the next day I was in unbearable pain. After work, I went to the pharmacy to buy anti...


Dr. Ke Fangxu reply Surgery
An anal abscess refers to an acute bacterial infection of the anus that leads to pus formation. Half of the individuals will completely recover after medical treatment or incision and drainage, while the other half may develop a fistula due to incomplete healing. An anal fistula ...

[Read More] Do I Really Need Surgery for an Anal Fistula?


Understanding Anal Fistulas: Do They Always Require Surgery?

Hello, Doctor: Sometimes when I have a bowel movement, I notice blood when I wipe with toilet paper, and sometimes there isn't any. I thought it was hemorrhoids, and I also experience itching at times. I previously saw a doctor who diagnosed me with hemorrhoids, but recently...


Dr. Ke Fangxu reply Surgery
Hello: In response to your question, anal fistulas indeed require surgical treatment for a definitive cure. If not addressed in a timely manner, there is a possibility of progression from a simple to a complex type. If surgery is temporarily inconvenient, it is essential to monit...

[Read More] Understanding Anal Fistulas: Do They Always Require Surgery?


Understanding Anal Abscess: When Is Surgery Necessary?

Hello, Dr. Ke! I would like to ask you about my anal abscess, which has been present for about 8 days. I have seen a doctor at the hospital (I have had three follow-up visits), and the area around my anus is still swollen. The doctor prescribed antibiotics, and I have been taking...


Dr. Ke Fangxu reply Surgery
Anal abscesses are generally recommended to be treated surgically. If the symptoms are mild, the procedure can be performed under local anesthesia in an outpatient setting. In more severe cases, hospitalization may be required. If surgery is not performed, even if recovery occurs...

[Read More] Understanding Anal Abscess: When Is Surgery Necessary?


Do You Still Need Surgery for a Pain-Free Anal Abscess and Fistula?

Hello Doctor: Recently, I developed an abscess near my anus, for which I visited a clinic, received antibiotics, and had the pus drained. Currently, I no longer feel any foreign body sensation or pain. The clinic has advised me to go to the hospital for fistula surgery. Given tha...


Dr. Zhang Shuhao reply Surgery
If it is the first occurrence of an anal abscess and it is incised and drained, a fistula may not necessarily form. The clinic may discover this through palpation, or if there is recurrent swelling and pain, surgery may be recommended. If there is no pain, it indicates that the i...

[Read More] Do You Still Need Surgery for a Pain-Free Anal Abscess and Fistula?


Related FAQ

Anal Abscess

(Surgery)

Anal Fistula

(Surgery)

Post-Anal Abscess Surgery

(Surgery)

Post-Anal Fistula Surgery

(Surgery)

Fistula

(Surgery)

Anal Prolapse

(Surgery)

Chronic Anal Fissure

(Surgery)

Anal Sex

(Surgery)

Anal Lump

(Surgery)

Anal Bleeding

(Surgery)