Is there a difference between orthopedic and thoracic X-rays?
Hello, my son is currently 12 years old.
One side of his sternum is flat while the other side is elevated, and the elevated side's nipple is also larger.
We visited an orthopedic doctor and had an X-ray taken, but the doctor said there is no issue with the bones; it might be related to the cartilage, which cannot be seen on an X-ray.
Some people suggested that I might have consulted the wrong specialty and recommended that I see a pulmonologist for another X-ray.
I would like to know if there is a difference in the X-rays.
Mooby, 40~49 year old female. Ask Date: 2018/03/30
Dr. Wang Yifen reply Radiology
I apologize for the late response as I just saw your question.
A chest X-ray will not differ based on the requesting unit.
An orthopedic physician focuses on the evaluation of bones, while a pulmonologist concentrates on lung diseases.
If a child has developmental abnormalities, they can be assessed by a pediatric endocrinologist and metabolism specialist or a general pediatrician.
Sincerely, Yi-Fen Wang.
Reply Date: 2018/03/30
More Info
When it comes to understanding the differences between orthopedic and thoracic X-rays, it is essential to recognize that these two types of imaging serve distinct purposes and focus on different anatomical structures.
Orthopedic X-rays primarily concentrate on the bones and joints. They are used to diagnose fractures, dislocations, arthritis, and other musculoskeletal conditions. In your son's case, the orthopedic evaluation was appropriate given the concern about his chest bone (sternum) and the asymmetry in his chest. The orthopedic doctor assessed the bony structures and concluded that there were no issues with the bones themselves, which is a crucial first step in understanding the underlying cause of the asymmetry.
On the other hand, thoracic X-rays focus on the structures within the thoracic cavity, including the lungs, heart, major blood vessels, and the mediastinum (the area between the lungs). They are particularly useful for evaluating respiratory conditions, detecting fluid in the lungs, and assessing the heart's size and shape. In your son's situation, if there is a concern about the soft tissue structures, such as cartilage or the surrounding soft tissues, a thoracic X-ray may provide additional information that an orthopedic X-ray might not capture.
The concern regarding the asymmetry of your son's chest, particularly the higher side and larger nipple, could be related to several factors, including developmental variations, pectus deformities (such as pectus excavatum or pectus carinatum), or even conditions affecting the soft tissues. While orthopedic X-rays can effectively visualize bony structures, they may not adequately assess soft tissue abnormalities, which is why a referral to a thoracic specialist or a repeat X-ray focusing on the thoracic region could be beneficial.
In summary, the distinction between orthopedic and thoracic X-rays lies in their focus: orthopedic X-rays are designed to evaluate bones and joints, while thoracic X-rays assess the thoracic cavity's contents. Given your son's symptoms and the findings from the orthopedic evaluation, it may be prudent to follow up with a thoracic specialist. They can determine if further imaging or evaluation is necessary to investigate the soft tissue components contributing to the asymmetry in his chest.
If your son is experiencing any discomfort or if there are concerns about his development, it is essential to communicate these to the healthcare provider. They may recommend additional imaging, such as an MRI or CT scan, which can provide more detailed information about soft tissues and cartilage, helping to clarify the diagnosis and guide any necessary treatment.
In conclusion, while the initial orthopedic evaluation was appropriate, considering a thoracic evaluation may provide a more comprehensive understanding of your son's condition, especially if there are concerns about soft tissue structures. Always ensure that any further evaluations are discussed with a healthcare professional who can guide you based on your son's specific situation.
Similar Q&A
Understanding the Differences Between Chest X-rays and Lumbar X-rays
Hello, Dr. Yang. When I went for a lateral chest X-ray, I asked the radiologic technologist if the exposure was significantly higher than the frontal view, and the technologist confirmed that it was indeed much higher. After the procedure, I noticed that the technologist spent a ...
Dr. Yang Jinghua reply Radiology
Dear Xiao Kai: According to survey data, the radiation dose from a standard chest X-ray is approximately 0.1 to 0.2 millisieverts, while a lateral chest X-ray is about twice that amount. For a thoracic spine X-ray, the dose is around 1.5 millisieverts. Therefore, the lifetime can...[Read More] Understanding the Differences Between Chest X-rays and Lumbar X-rays
Understanding Discrepancies in Chest X-Ray Reports: A Patient's Guide
Hello, Doctor: In September 2022, I underwent chest X-ray examinations at two government-approved hospitals, and the reports were inconsistent, which has left me quite confused. The reports indicate scoliosis, but I do not have any noticeable asymmetry or feelings of lower back p...
Dr. Wang Zhaomin reply Rehabilitation
The imaging report indicates scoliosis; however, there may not be any noticeable changes or related symptoms in the clinical appearance. Please seek medical attention and discuss your actual condition in person with a healthcare provider.[Read More] Understanding Discrepancies in Chest X-Ray Reports: A Patient's Guide
Understanding X-Ray Safety: Why Some Areas Are Shielded and Others Aren't
Hello, doctor. The day before yesterday, I had an X-ray of my shoulder and upper arm joint. The radiologic technologist used a lead apron to shield my lower body. This made me recall my previous experiences, where often there was no specific shielding for the unexposed areas. Wha...
Dr. Wang Yifen reply Radiology
Hello, the area you photographed is on the shoulder and upper arm. There is no significant difference between using lead shielding to cover the lower body and not using it. Literature suggests that lead shielding can reduce the dose of scattered radiation, but the radiation dose ...[Read More] Understanding X-Ray Safety: Why Some Areas Are Shielded and Others Aren't
Understanding Whole Body Pain: X-rays vs. PET Scans for Diagnosis
1. I haven't seen an orthopedic doctor yet. Is it possible to get a full-body X-ray, or are there regulations that limit the number of images taken? 2. I want to undergo a full-body PET scan for a health check-up. Will it provide clearer images than an X-ray, or is X-ray be...
Dr. Chen Bochen reply Orthopedics
1. There is no set limit on the number of scans, but the doctor will determine if they are necessary. 2. You can undergo a PET scan, but it may not necessarily identify your issue. The human body is complex, so it's important to find a good doctor to help you investigate t...[Read More] Understanding Whole Body Pain: X-rays vs. PET Scans for Diagnosis
Related FAQ
(Orthopedics)
X-Ray Radiation(Radiology)
Rib(Orthopedics)
Vertebral Arch(Orthopedics)
Coccyx(Orthopedics)
X-Ray(Obstetrics and Gynecology)
X-Ray Report(Pulmonology)
Chest Contusion(Orthopedics)
Clavicle(Orthopedics)
Back Pain(Orthopedics)