The Safety and Alternatives of Silver Fillings in Dentistry - Dentistry

Share to:

Regarding silver amalgam dental fillings?


Dear Dr.
Zhu,
I have several teeth that were filled with dental amalgam in the early stages, and now the amalgam has mostly oxidized and turned black.
Recently, I came across information indicating that some countries have banned the use of dental amalgam due to the mercury it contains, which can release mercury vapor and have adverse effects on human health.
Some scholars and experts in our country also support this view, and there are dental clinics offering services to remove amalgam and replace it with other materials (such as composite resin).
However, it appears that dental amalgam has not yet been banned in our country, and there is no definitive evidence regarding its effects on human health.
Based on my recent research, I would like to ask Dr.
Zhu the following questions:
1.
In your opinion, do you believe that dental amalgam fillings have a positive (no impact) or negative (harmful) effect on human health? Please provide me with accurate information.
2.
Since I have several early dental amalgam fillings that have oxidized and turned black, do you think it is necessary for me to visit a healthcare facility to have the amalgam removed and replaced with other materials (such as composite resin)?
Thank you for your guidance, Dr.
Zhu.

Axiang, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2018/09/16

Dr. Zhu Guanyu reply Dentistry


Hello: The use of dental amalgam as a filling material for cavities has a history of several hundred years, and there is currently insufficient evidence to prove it is harmful.
For more information, please refer to the website of the National Dental Association.
If there are no other considerations, there is no need to replace old filling materials with new ones.
However, regardless of the material used for filling cavities, it is best to have an annual check-up.
Prevention is better than treatment.
Wishing you a pleasant dental cleaning! Best wishes for your health, Dr.
Kuan-Yu Chu, Attending Dentist, Taoyuan Hospital, Ministry of Health and Welfare.

Reply Date: 2018/09/16

More Info


The use of silver fillings, also known as dental amalgam, has been a common practice in dentistry for many years. However, concerns regarding the safety and potential health risks associated with the mercury content in these fillings have led to debates and changes in dental practices worldwide. Here, I will address your questions regarding the safety of silver fillings and the alternatives available.

1. Impact of Silver Fillings on Health: The primary concern with silver fillings is the mercury they contain. Mercury is a heavy metal that can be toxic in high amounts. However, the mercury in dental amalgam is bound with other metals (such as silver, tin, and copper), which stabilizes it and minimizes the release of mercury vapor. The American Dental Association (ADA) and the World Health Organization (WHO) have stated that dental amalgam is safe for use in most patients, including children and pregnant women. The risk of mercury exposure from amalgam fillings is considered low, especially when compared to other sources of mercury exposure, such as fish consumption or environmental pollution.

That said, some individuals may have specific sensitivities or allergies to mercury or other components of dental amalgam. In such cases, it may be advisable to consider alternatives. The ongoing debate about the safety of amalgam has led some countries to restrict its use, particularly in vulnerable populations. However, in the United States, amalgam remains a widely accepted and used material.

2. Need for Replacement of Silver Fillings: If your silver fillings have oxidized and appear black, this is a common occurrence as amalgam can tarnish over time. The discoloration itself does not necessarily indicate a health risk or that the filling is failing. However, if you are experiencing symptoms such as pain, sensitivity, or if the filling is structurally compromised (e.g., cracking or breaking), it may be time to consult with your dentist about replacement options.

The decision to replace silver fillings with alternative materials, such as composite resins or glass ionomer cements, should be based on several factors, including the size and location of the filling, your dental health, and personal preferences. Composite resins are tooth-colored and can provide a more aesthetic result, but they may not be as durable as amalgam in certain situations, particularly in areas subject to heavy chewing forces.

If you are considering having your amalgam fillings removed, it is crucial to have this procedure done by a qualified dentist who follows safety protocols to minimize mercury exposure during the removal process. This often includes using rubber dams to isolate the tooth and suction devices to capture any mercury vapor or particles.

In conclusion, while silver fillings have been deemed safe for most individuals, it is essential to stay informed about your dental health and any potential risks associated with dental materials. If you have concerns about your silver fillings or are experiencing any symptoms, it is advisable to consult with your dentist for a thorough evaluation and to discuss the best course of action tailored to your specific needs. Regular dental check-ups and good oral hygiene practices will also help maintain your dental health and the longevity of any fillings you may have.

Similar Q&A

Understanding the Safety and Alternatives of Silver Amalgam Fillings

Dear Dr. Tseng, I would like to ask you some questions regarding "silver amalgam fillings": 1. Some medical information and dentists indicate that the composition of silver amalgam is mercury alloy (amalgam), which can release mercury vapor (or metal toxins) that may ...


Dr. Zeng Guanghui reply Dentistry
Hello, Ah-Hsiang: 1. Silver amalgam does release trace amounts of mercury vapor during the initial setting phase, but once the amalgam is fully hardened, it no longer releases mercury. The potential adverse effects of these trace mercury vapors are still debated, with differing ...

[Read More] Understanding the Safety and Alternatives of Silver Amalgam Fillings


Is Silver Filling Safe? Debunking Myths About Dental Mercury

Hello, doctor: I heard that silver fillings contain heavy metals and mercury, and it is best to remove them and replace them with composite resin to avoid poisoning or dementia. Is this statement correct?


Dr. Huang Zhicheng reply Dentistry
Dear Uof: Hello, silver amalgam is a relatively stable dental filling material, and some negative reports are based on individual cases or coincidences. However, due to its mercury content, dentists now avoid using it out of caution. If it needs to be removed and replaced, it sho...

[Read More] Is Silver Filling Safe? Debunking Myths About Dental Mercury


Alternative Solutions for Covering Silver Fillings in Molars

Doctor: May I ask, in the past, silver amalgam was used to fill molars, but now I find the appearance too noticeable. Are there other options available for covering it? Thank you!


Dr. Qiu Qiongyao reply Dentistry
Hello David: The silver filling can be removed and replaced with a resin filling. If the silver filling is too large, it is recommended to protect it with a crown. It is advisable to visit a qualified dental facility for a more accurate assessment.

[Read More] Alternative Solutions for Covering Silver Fillings in Molars


Understanding Dental Fillings: Risks, Materials, and Best Practices

(1) Is it really dangerous to use silver powder for dental fillings? (2) The resin filling I had before fell out, and some of the resin remains, but there is secondary decay inside. Is this due to the material or the technique? Would going to a larger hospital provide more assura...


Dr. Lin Qingye reply Dentistry
Hello Miss Chen, (1) The materials used for dental treatments must be non-toxic and harmless as a primary requirement. The use of "silver powder" for dental fillings has been established in dental practice for many years, and its safety and stability are well recognize...

[Read More] Understanding Dental Fillings: Risks, Materials, and Best Practices


Related FAQ

Silver Filling

(Dentistry)

Dental Filling

(Dentistry)

Bruxism

(Dentistry)

Halitosis

(Dentistry)

Gum

(Dentistry)

Dental Pulp

(Dentistry)

Lost Filling

(Dentistry)

Enamel

(Dentistry)

Porcelain Crown

(Dentistry)

Tooth Staining

(Dentistry)