Is drinking water that has been soaked in copper or copper rust toxic?
Hello Doctor, several years ago I used the "Kappa Water Purifier" for about four months.
It claims to utilize 30-micron copper fibers soaked in water to achieve chlorine removal and disinfection.
I recently recalled this and am concerned whether the water that has been in contact with copper (and possibly copper rust) could pose health risks.
Generally, it seems that copper patina is considered toxic, but I found conflicting information online stating that copper patina is actually non-toxic.
I would appreciate your clarification on this matter.
If there are health risks, given my usage as mentioned, should I be worried? What kind of tests should I undergo, what symptoms should I be aware of, and how can I mitigate any potential issues? I did some online research, but the information is quite varied, so I feel more at ease consulting you.
P.S.
I had a health check-up about a year ago, and aside from abnormal findings of protein, bilirubin, and white blood cells in my urine, everything else was normal.
Recently recalling this situation has made me quite anxious.
Thank you very much for your help! :)
Niming, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2018/12/18
Dr. Xiao Yongxun reply Family Medicine
Dear Ms.
Anonymous:
1.
Is water that has been in contact with copper toxic? It is important to consider the type of "copper" in the product, what compounds it is in, its oxidation state, whether it is alloyed with other metals, and if any additional elements have been introduced.
If you wish to know more, it may be necessary to consult the manufacturer.
2.
Foods naturally contain trace amounts of copper, typically in the form of compounds or bound to specific proteins.
Aside from physiological needs, excess copper can be eliminated through the liver or related enzymes and proteins in the body.
However, certain rare genetic disorders (such as Wilson's disease) can lead to an inability to metabolize copper due to a deficiency of specific substances, resulting in disease.
3.
If you suspect poisoning, it is advisable to visit a medical center's toxicology or occupational medicine department.
They may consider testing for copper levels in your blood or urine as a reference for diagnosing any potential illness.
Reply Date: 2018/12/18
More Info
Drinking water treated with copper, particularly through the use of copper fibers as described in your experience with the "河童君淨水器," raises important health considerations. Copper is an essential trace mineral that plays a vital role in various bodily functions, including iron metabolism, the formation of connective tissue, and the functioning of the immune system. However, excessive copper intake can lead to toxicity, which can manifest in various health issues.
Safety of Copper-Treated Water
1. Copper Compounds and Their Effects: The safety of drinking water treated with copper largely depends on the form of copper present in the water. Copper can exist in different oxidation states, primarily cuprous (Cu+) and cupric (Cu2+). The specific treatment process and the duration of exposure to copper can influence the concentration of these compounds in the water. If the copper fibers are releasing significant amounts of copper into the water, it could potentially lead to elevated copper levels.
2. Copper Toxicity: Acute copper toxicity can occur with high levels of exposure, leading to symptoms such as nausea, vomiting, abdominal pain, and diarrhea. Chronic exposure, even at lower levels, can result in liver and kidney damage, and in severe cases, conditions like Wilson's disease, where the body cannot properly eliminate copper, leading to its accumulation.
3. Copper Patina (Copper Green): The green patina that forms on copper surfaces, known as verdigris, is primarily composed of copper carbonate and copper acetate. While it is often considered toxic if ingested in large amounts, the actual risk from small amounts in drinking water is less clear. It is generally advisable to avoid consuming any form of copper corrosion products.
Health Monitoring and Symptoms
Given your previous use of the copper water treatment system and your current health concerns, it is prudent to monitor for any symptoms of copper toxicity. These may include:
- Gastrointestinal distress (nausea, vomiting, diarrhea)
- Abdominal pain
- Fatigue or weakness
- Jaundice (yellowing of the skin or eyes)
- Changes in urine color or consistency
Recommended Actions
1. Consult a Healthcare Professional: If you are concerned about potential copper exposure, it is advisable to consult a healthcare provider. They may recommend blood tests to measure copper levels or urine tests to assess copper excretion. This can help determine if you have been exposed to harmful levels of copper.
2. Dietary Considerations: If you are found to have elevated copper levels, dietary modifications may be necessary. Foods high in zinc, such as meat, shellfish, legumes, and nuts, can help reduce copper absorption. Staying hydrated and maintaining a balanced diet can also support overall health.
3. Regular Health Check-ups: Since you mentioned previous abnormalities in your urine tests, it would be wise to continue regular health check-ups. Monitoring kidney function and liver enzymes can provide insight into your overall health and help detect any potential issues early.
4. Avoid Further Exposure: If you have concerns about the safety of the water you are consuming, consider switching to a different water purification method that does not involve copper. Boiling water or using activated carbon filters can be effective alternatives for removing contaminants without introducing copper.
Conclusion
In summary, while copper is an essential nutrient, excessive exposure through treated water can pose health risks. Monitoring your health and consulting with a healthcare professional will provide clarity and peace of mind. It is essential to stay informed about the sources of your drinking water and to take proactive steps to ensure its safety.
Similar Q&A
Understanding Hard Water: Health Effects and Filtration Solutions
I use spring water at home for drinking, and while cleaning the hot water kettle, I noticed scaling from hard water. All drinking water is filtered and boiled. I would like to know if long-term consumption of hard water can have adverse effects on health. Should I install a rever...
Dr. Shi Guimei reply Nutrition
Hello! The biggest issue with using spring water as drinking water is whether its source is contaminated with pathogens or heavy metals, raising concerns about the safety of drinking water. Currently, there are many different types of water dispensers or purifiers on the market, ...[Read More] Understanding Hard Water: Health Effects and Filtration Solutions
Is Electrolyzed Water Beneficial for Health? Long-term Use and Suitability for Gout and Ulcers
Hello: Is drinking electrolyte water beneficial for the human body? Is it safe for long-term consumption? Is it suitable for individuals suffering from gout and gastric ulcers?
Dr. Shi Guimei reply Nutrition
Hello! First, we need to understand that electrolyzed water is essentially still water, not a medication. If there are health issues, it is advisable to seek conventional treatment. Electrolyzed water emphasizes its redox properties that may eliminate free radicals, but the effec...[Read More] Is Electrolyzed Water Beneficial for Health? Long-term Use and Suitability for Gout and Ulcers
Is Boiled Tap Water Safe? Understanding Cancer Risks and Health Concerns
Is drinking boiled tap water carcinogenic? Is the risk high?
Dr. Cai Ruiyuan reply Family Medicine
Hello, sir: I am not a toxicology expert, but I have made an effort to find some information from the Taiwan Water Company and the Environmental Protection Administration website. Please refer to the section on trihalomethanes in Chapter 1 at the Environmental Protection Administ...[Read More] Is Boiled Tap Water Safe? Understanding Cancer Risks and Health Concerns
Are White Residues in Your Kettle Harmful to Health?
Hello, I would like to ask if the white floating substance that appears after boiling water in an electric kettle is harmful to health when consumed? Additionally, there is a large amount of white residue attached to the inner wall of the kettle. Can I remove it by boiling a mixt...
Dr. Liao Yaopan reply Family Medicine
Hello, regarding your question, the water may contain trace amounts of metals or other residues that cause sedimentation. It is indeed difficult to specify the exact composition, as it falls under the realm of professional analysis. Whether these so-called "sediments" h...[Read More] Are White Residues in Your Kettle Harmful to Health?
Related FAQ
(Family Medicine)
Disinfection(Family Medicine)
Accidental Ingestion(Family Medicine)
Urine Report(Family Medicine)
Alcohol Consumption(Family Medicine)
Mercury Poisoning(Internal Medicine)
Drug Side Effects(Family Medicine)
Anemia(Family Medicine)
Hypokalemia(Family Medicine)
Throat(Family Medicine)