Do I Need Surgery for My External Hemorrhoids? - Surgery

Share to:

Do external hemorrhoids require surgery?


I have had external hemorrhoids for many years.
Occasionally, I experience swelling and pain during bowel movements (about once a year).
Generally, I do not feel any discomfort, and I wash with water after each bowel movement.
It does not significantly affect my daily life, but I feel that it is gradually getting larger, approximately 1 centimeter in size.
Do I need surgery for this? Last year, I visited a clinic for an examination, and the doctor said it does not affect my daily life, so I should not worry about it.
Will the shape of my stools affect this condition? How often should I have regular check-ups? Should I only get checked if I experience pain again?

Ting, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2020/03/11

Dr. Yu Mingchang reply Surgery


Hello: Please take some time to have a colorectal assessment at Changhua Hospital, Ministry of Health and Welfare, as they care about you.

Reply Date: 2020/03/11

More Info


When it comes to external hemorrhoids, the decision to undergo surgery largely depends on the severity of symptoms and the impact on your quality of life. Based on your description, it seems that your external hemorrhoids have been manageable, with occasional pain during bowel movements and a feeling of swelling. Since you mentioned that the pain occurs about once a year and does not significantly affect your daily activities, it may not be necessary to pursue surgical intervention at this time.

External hemorrhoids are swollen veins located around the anus and can cause discomfort, especially during bowel movements. They can become painful if they are thrombosed (develop a blood clot) or if there is significant irritation. In your case, since the pain is infrequent and manageable, conservative treatment options may be sufficient. These can include dietary modifications, such as increasing fiber intake to soften stools and reduce straining during bowel movements, as well as maintaining proper hydration. Over-the-counter topical treatments can also help alleviate discomfort.

Regarding the size of your hemorrhoids, a 1 cm external hemorrhoid is relatively small, and while it may feel like it is getting larger, this does not necessarily indicate that surgery is required. Surgical options, such as hemorrhoidectomy, are typically reserved for cases where there is persistent pain, significant bleeding, or if the hemorrhoids are causing complications that affect quality of life.

As for the frequency of check-ups, it is generally advisable to have a follow-up with your healthcare provider if you notice any changes in symptoms, such as increased pain, bleeding, or changes in bowel habits. If your symptoms remain stable, annual check-ups may be sufficient. However, if you experience any new symptoms or if the pain becomes more frequent, it would be wise to consult with a healthcare professional sooner.

In terms of bowel habits, the type of stool can indeed affect hemorrhoids. Hard stools can lead to straining, which exacerbates hemorrhoid symptoms. Therefore, focusing on a high-fiber diet, regular exercise, and adequate fluid intake can help maintain softer stools and reduce the risk of aggravating your hemorrhoids.

In summary, based on your current situation, surgery for your external hemorrhoids does not seem necessary at this time. Instead, focus on conservative management strategies and monitor your symptoms. If you have any concerns or if your condition changes, do not hesitate to reach out to your healthcare provider for further evaluation and guidance. Regular monitoring and proactive management can help you maintain a good quality of life while managing your external hemorrhoids effectively.

Similar Q&A

Do You Need Surgery for External Hemorrhoids? Alternatives Explored

Is surgery the only option for external hemorrhoids? Are there no other methods? Mine is between grade three and four.


Dr. Ke Fangxu reply Surgery
If external hemorrhoids are not accompanied by bleeding or pain, surgery is not necessarily required. What are the alternative treatment outcomes we hope to achieve? If the goal is for the external hemorrhoids to disappear, then surgery may be the only option. However, if the foc...

[Read More] Do You Need Surgery for External Hemorrhoids? Alternatives Explored


Do You Need Surgery for Painless External Hemorrhoids?

If a physician determines that the excess granulation tissue around the anus is due to external hemorrhoids, and there is no pain or bleeding, is surgery necessary?


Dr. Ke Fangxu reply Surgery
Hello: In response to your question, if external hemorrhoids are not causing pain or bleeding, surgery is generally not recommended unless they cause significant discomfort in daily life or for cosmetic reasons.

[Read More] Do You Need Surgery for Painless External Hemorrhoids?


Understanding External Hemorrhoid Surgery: Risks and Recovery Insights

Hello Doctor, I have an external hemorrhoid about 2 cm long located between the perineum and the anus. The doctor performed a complete excision of both internal and external hemorrhoids. After the surgery, I noticed that my perineum has split into several pieces, with one piece h...


Dr. Ke Fangxu reply Surgery
Without a personal examination, I cannot provide you with a definitive answer. I recommend discussing this thoroughly with your surgeon. Personally, I do not advise performing a ligation for external hemorrhoids, as this issue is unlikely to be addressed by a general surgeon.

[Read More] Understanding External Hemorrhoid Surgery: Risks and Recovery Insights


Is It Safe to Remove External Hemorrhoids in a Clinic?

Hello doctor, I have an issue with external hemorrhoids. I visited a clinic, and the doctor suggested that it can be excised in an outpatient setting since the external hemorrhoid is quite small. I would like to know if it is safe to have it handled at the clinic, or if it would ...


Dr. Ke Fangxu reply Surgery
If external hemorrhoids are not causing pain, bleeding, or affecting daily life, surgery is generally not recommended. If the hemorrhoids are small, there is even less reason to consider surgery. Please carefully evaluate the necessity of the procedure and discuss it with your ph...

[Read More] Is It Safe to Remove External Hemorrhoids in a Clinic?


Related FAQ