Infection Transmission: Clarifying Myths for Kids - Family Medicine

Share to:

Transmission routes of diseases?


Hello Dr.
Hsiao, my son is in junior high school and I don't know why he told his classmates that if someone has a wound, they can spread pneumonia and HIV.
He scared his sister with these strange rumors while my husband and I were busy.
This afternoon, after washing her glasses, my daughter said she might have scratched herself while wiping them...
My son used this to trick her into thinking something bad would happen.
Although he later apologized, I usually get home around 8 PM, and today I saw my daughter running to me crying, saying she was scared of what her brother said.
I could only explain to both of them that tissues don't have needles, and that my daughter was just scratched by the sharp edge of her glasses without bleeding, so there’s no way to transmit HIV.
My understanding is that HIV is transmitted through unprotected sexual intercourse or sharing needles, but I really can't believe my son tricked his sister into thinking tissues have needles.
As for pneumonia, that seems even more unlikely.
I'm not sure if my understanding is correct, doctor.
Since my daughter still seems to be worried because of her brother's influence, I would like to ask if you could explain the correct information to them, and reassure my daughter that she is safe.
I really can't think of how to make her feel secure, so I had to seek help online.
I'm sorry to disturb you so late.

Fang, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2020/04/19

Dr. Xiao Yongxun reply Family Medicine


Dear Ms.
Fang:
1.
The pathogens that can attack humans primarily include bacteria, viruses, fungi, protozoa, parasites, rickettsiae, and prions, among others.
Their modes of transmission vary, including droplet transmission, airborne transmission, fecal-oral transmission, foodborne transmission, contact transmission, vector-borne transmission, transplacental transmission, and iatrogenic infection.
Despite being in such a complex environment, the vast majority of people remain unharmed, mainly due to each individual's robust immune system and good hygiene practices.
Furthermore, the human immune system gradually matures after leaving the maternal environment for six months, and with regular vaccinations, most children in our country can grow up to adulthood.
Interestingly, some bacteria are essential for human survival, with probiotics being the best example.
2.
Various types of pneumonia are mostly transmitted through droplets or airborne routes, and very rarely through wound transmission.
HIV is primarily transmitted through blood contact with wounds; in practice, this occurs through accidental needle sticks, sharing needles or razors, blood transfusions, or sexual contact.
3.
For one to contract HIV from a cut caused by their own eyeglasses, several conditions must be met: a.
The eyeglasses must be deliberately contaminated with HIV, and the virus must be very fresh and viable (generally, HIV does not survive long in the air and is easily destroyed by disinfectants, soap, or alcohol).
b.
The wound must be deep, and there must be a significant amount of HIV present.
c.
The host's skin, macrophages, and specific immune responses must all be compromised.
It is highly unlikely for someone to contract HIV from their own eyeglasses, especially since they are the ones wearing them.
Moreover, due to the recent COVID-19 pandemic, the entire population is wearing masks and practicing hand hygiene; various pathogens are blocked by masks and eliminated by soap or alcohol, leading to a significant reduction in upper respiratory infections, enterovirus infections, various types of pneumonia, acute gastroenteritis, and other infectious diseases, resulting in a noticeable decrease in patient numbers at healthcare facilities.
4.
During the growth process of children, there are often interesting rumors or misconceptions among peers; parents may need to guide them through education and rational thinking on how to apply the knowledge and experiences taught in school to determine whether peer rumors are accurate.
This can be beneficial for their development.
5.
If you have further questions, please discuss them in more depth with your family physician.

Reply Date: 2020/04/19

More Info


Dear Fang,
Thank you for reaching out with your concerns about your children's understanding of infection transmission. It’s important to address these misconceptions, especially when they can cause unnecessary fear and anxiety in children.

First, let’s clarify some key points about how infections are transmitted. Infections can be caused by various pathogens, including bacteria, viruses, fungi, and parasites. The transmission routes for these pathogens can vary significantly. Common methods include:
1. Droplet Transmission: This occurs when an infected person coughs or sneezes, releasing droplets that can be inhaled by someone nearby. This is a common way for respiratory infections, including pneumonia, to spread.

2. Contact Transmission: This involves direct contact with an infected person or contaminated surfaces. For example, touching a surface that has been contaminated with a virus and then touching your face can lead to infection.

3. Airborne Transmission: Some infections can be spread through tiny droplets that remain suspended in the air for extended periods.

4. Bloodborne Transmission: This is how HIV is primarily transmitted, through direct contact with infected blood, typically via unprotected sexual contact, sharing needles, or from mother to child during childbirth.

Now, regarding your son’s claims about infections being transmitted through minor injuries or cuts, it’s crucial to clarify that while certain infections can be transmitted through open wounds, the scenarios he described are highly exaggerated. For instance, the likelihood of contracting HIV from a minor scratch caused by a pair of glasses is virtually nonexistent. HIV does not survive long outside the human body, and it requires specific conditions to be transmitted, such as through direct blood-to-blood contact or sexual activity.

As for pneumonia, it is primarily spread through respiratory droplets and is not transmitted through minor cuts or scrapes. Your daughter’s minor injury from her glasses poses no risk of these infections, especially since there was no bleeding involved.

To help alleviate your daughter’s fears, it would be beneficial to have an open conversation with both children about how infections are actually transmitted. You can explain that while it’s good to be cautious and maintain hygiene, many of the fears they have are based on misunderstandings. Here are some points you might want to cover:
- Infections and Cuts: Explain that while some infections can enter the body through cuts, the specific infections mentioned (like HIV and pneumonia) are not transmitted this way. Reassure her that her minor scratch is not a cause for concern.

- Hygiene Practices: Emphasize the importance of good hygiene practices, such as washing hands regularly, not sharing personal items like razors or needles, and being cautious around sick individuals.

- Encouraging Questions: Encourage your children to ask questions about health and infections. This can help them feel more informed and less anxious. You might even consider reading age-appropriate books or watching educational videos together that explain how germs and infections work.

- Reassurance: Let your daughter know that she is safe and that you are there to protect her. Sometimes, just knowing that a parent is there to listen and provide comfort can significantly reduce anxiety.

In conclusion, it’s essential to foster an environment where your children feel safe to express their fears and ask questions. By providing them with accurate information and reassurance, you can help dispel the myths that are causing them distress. If their fears persist or if you notice any significant changes in their behavior, it may be helpful to consult with a pediatrician or a child psychologist for further guidance.

Best wishes for your family's health and well-being!
Sincerely,
Doctor Q&A Teams
Medical Expert

Similar Q&A

Understanding Infection Transmission: Clarifying Myths for Kids

Hello, Dr. Hsiao. My son, who is in middle school, has been spreading strange rumors among his classmates, claiming that if someone has a wound, they can get infected with pneumonia or HIV. He scared his younger sister with these false claims while my husband and I were busy. Thi...


Dr. Xiao Yongxun reply Family Medicine
Dear Ms. Fang: 1. The pathogens that can attack humans primarily include bacteria, viruses, fungi, protozoa, parasites, rickettsiae, and prions. Their modes of transmission vary, including droplet transmission, airborne transmission, fecal-oral transmission, foodborne transmissi...

[Read More] Understanding Infection Transmission: Clarifying Myths for Kids


Concerns About Hygiene: Protecting Your Child from Illness

Hello, doctor. I have a question. My child might have been frightened, and a friend of a family elder came over and kindly offered to help calm him down. He used his hands, which were extremely dirty, and then dipped his hands in water and let my son drink it. Could this lead to ...


Dr. Xiao Kaiwen reply Pediatrics
Infections can enter through the mouth, and if pathogenic bacteria that affect humans are introduced, children who lack immunity to these pathogens may become ill. The symptoms of various pathogens can differ, but generally, one should observe for common signs of illness such as ...

[Read More] Concerns About Hygiene: Protecting Your Child from Illness


Assessing Infection Risks for Children After Exposure to Spit

Hello, Dr. Hong: Today, my husband took a day off, and we went out to eat clay pot chicken with our baby. Although it seems that the pandemic is less talked about domestically now, I still wear a mask as much as possible and ask my husband to do the same to protect our child, sin...


Dr. Hong Yuanbin reply Internal Medicine
Based on your description, it seems that you were approximately one meter away from a potential droplet exposure outdoors. Since it is a more open space, the risk of transmission should be very low, especially since you and your family were wearing masks. Therefore, the likelihoo...

[Read More] Assessing Infection Risks for Children After Exposure to Spit


Can Genital Warts Be Transmitted to Children? Common Concerns Explained

1. If a cauliflower patient’s pubic hair sticks to a pacifier and a one-and-a-half-year-old child sucks on it for an hour, is there a risk of transmission? 2. Is there a risk of transmission if a child comes into contact with the bathwater of a patient? 3. Is there a risk of ...


Dr. Chen Jiansheng reply Urology
Opportunity

[Read More] Can Genital Warts Be Transmitted to Children? Common Concerns Explained


Related FAQ

Infection

(Family Medicine)

Contagion

(Family Medicine)

Family Medicine

(Pediatrics)

Tetanus

(Family Medicine)

Monkeypox

(Family Medicine)

Lymphadenitis

(Family Medicine)

Antibiotics

(Pediatrics)

Parasites

(Family Medicine)

Purpura

(Pediatrics)

Vibrio Parahaemolyticus

(Family Medicine)