Humeral fracture fixation with a plate?
Due to a sports injury, I sustained a fracture of the left humerus and underwent surgery on September 26, 2019, during which a titanium alloy plate and nine screws were implanted.
The doctor initially mentioned that the hardware could remain in place post-surgery.
However, after rehabilitation, I found that the plate is affecting my elbow's range of motion.
Currently, I can only flex my left elbow between 90 to 95 degrees, and I am unable to increase this angle through rehabilitation, which is impacting my daily life.
I have consulted two doctors; one suggested removal of the hardware, while the other advised against it.
The risk remains the same, particularly concerning the radial nerve.
Given the impact on my daily life, how should I weigh my options? Thank you, doctor.
Zhang, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2020/09/23
Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
After the removal of the bone plate, the range of motion in the elbow joint may not significantly increase.
Therefore, the physician recommends that there is no need to remove the screws and bone plate.
Removing the bone plate may potentially damage the radial nerve.
If there are no specific issues, it is advised not to remove the bone plate and screws.
Reply Date: 2020/09/23
More Info
Managing elbow mobility after surgery involving the insertion of a titanium plate and screws for a humerus fracture can be a challenging process, especially when the range of motion is limited and impacts daily activities. Here are some considerations and recommendations based on your situation.
Understanding the Impact of Titanium Plates
The insertion of a titanium plate is a common procedure for stabilizing fractures, particularly in the humerus. While these plates are designed to provide strong support during the healing process, they can sometimes lead to complications such as limited range of motion, discomfort, or even pain due to the hardware itself. In your case, the inability to fully flex your elbow beyond 90 to 95 degrees is a significant concern, especially if it affects your quality of life.
Evaluating the Need for Plate Removal
When considering whether to remove the titanium plate, several factors must be weighed:
1. Current Symptoms: If the plate is causing persistent pain, discomfort, or significantly limiting your range of motion, removal may be warranted. However, if the discomfort is manageable and the plate is not causing any other complications, it might be advisable to leave it in place.
2. Risk of Nerve Injury: As you mentioned, one of the risks associated with plate removal is potential injury to the radial nerve. This is a critical consideration, as nerve injuries can lead to long-term functional deficits. Discuss with your surgeon the specific risks involved in your case, including the likelihood of nerve injury during removal.
3. Rehabilitation Potential: If your current rehabilitation efforts are not yielding results, it may be worth exploring other rehabilitation strategies before considering surgery. This could include physical therapy techniques focused on improving flexibility and strength, modalities such as ultrasound or electrical stimulation, or even consulting a specialist in hand and upper extremity rehabilitation.
4. Second Opinions: Since you have already consulted two doctors with differing opinions, it may be beneficial to seek a third opinion, preferably from a surgeon who specializes in upper extremity surgeries. They can provide insights based on your specific anatomy and the nature of your fracture.
Rehabilitation Strategies
In the meantime, consider the following rehabilitation strategies to improve your elbow mobility:
- Physical Therapy: Engage in a structured physical therapy program that focuses on gentle stretching and strengthening exercises. A physical therapist can tailor a program to your specific needs and monitor your progress.
- Range of Motion Exercises: Incorporate passive and active range of motion exercises into your routine. This can help maintain joint flexibility and prevent stiffness.
- Heat and Cold Therapy: Use heat before exercises to relax the muscles and cold therapy afterward to reduce inflammation and pain.
- Gradual Progression: Be patient with your recovery. Gradually increase the intensity and duration of your exercises as tolerated.
Conclusion
Ultimately, the decision to remove the titanium plate should be made collaboratively with your healthcare team, considering the potential benefits and risks involved. If the plate is significantly impacting your quality of life and rehabilitation efforts are not effective, removal may be a viable option. However, if you can manage your symptoms and improve your range of motion through therapy, it may be worth continuing with non-surgical management. Always prioritize open communication with your healthcare providers to ensure the best possible outcome for your elbow mobility and overall function.
Similar Q&A
Understanding Humerus Fractures: Recovery, Rehabilitation, and Plate Removal
Hello, Doctor. In early June of this year, I suffered a left humeral fracture due to a fall. Currently, I can raise my arm to a certain height and angle, but I am unable to lift it beyond that. I visited an orthopedic clinic, and they mentioned that I have joint stiffness and adh...
Dr. Wang Shouji reply Orthopedics
Hello, if it is a mid-shaft humeral fracture, it should have a temporary impact on the shoulder joint, and the plate is unlikely to affect shoulder joint mobility. However, if it is a proximal humeral fracture, there may be some impact on shoulder joint function, and removal of t...[Read More] Understanding Humerus Fractures: Recovery, Rehabilitation, and Plate Removal
Understanding Elbow Flexion Issues After Fracture Surgery
Hello doctor, I fell at work on August 26 and sustained a fracture of the right radius. Following the doctor's advice, I underwent an MRI, which revealed small fragments near the ulnar area at the elbow. The doctor informed me that a tendon was torn and that I would need sur...
Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
A 90-degree flexion of the elbow joint is insufficient; continued rehabilitation therapy for two more months is necessary for improvement. The plate may not need to be removed.[Read More] Understanding Elbow Flexion Issues After Fracture Surgery
Post-Surgery Challenges After Distal Humerus Fracture: Recovery Insights
Hello Doctor, I am here to inquire again about my car accident on June 2nd of this year, which resulted in a distal humeral fracture in my left arm. On June 3rd, I underwent surgery where two metal plates and eight screws were inserted to stabilize my upper arm, and two long bone...
Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
1. Apply heat or use pain relievers. 2. Surgical implantation of a steel plate for distal humeral fracture, as it is very close to the radial nerve, should not be removed unless absolutely necessary. 3. Activities can be resumed after bone healing. 4. Weight should be gradually i...[Read More] Post-Surgery Challenges After Distal Humerus Fracture: Recovery Insights
Post-Operative Recovery After Steel Plate Removal: Key Questions Answered
Hello, doctor. I have a few questions regarding the recovery after the removal of the internal fixation plate and screws for a proximal humeral fracture. 1. Can I start moving my arm immediately after the surgery? 2. I am experiencing limited range of motion, especially when tr...
Dr. Li Yanheng reply Rehabilitation
If there is no significant pain or specific instructions from the orthopedic physician, you may engage in activities. If there is pain or limited range of motion, it is recommended to seek an evaluation from a rehabilitation specialist.[Read More] Post-Operative Recovery After Steel Plate Removal: Key Questions Answered
Related FAQ
(Orthopedics)
Humeral Fracture(Orthopedics)
Elbow Dislocation(Orthopedics)
Humerus(Orthopedics)
Humeral Fracture(Rehabilitation)
Post-Tibial Fracture Surgery(Orthopedics)
Distal Humeral Fracture(Orthopedics)
Elbow(Rehabilitation)
Radial And Ulnar Fracture(Orthopedics)
Rehabilitation(Orthopedics)