Food mixing
Hello doctor, I ate a banana around 3 PM, but at 8 PM I had about half a persimmon.
Later, I learned that these two shouldn't be eaten together as they can form a hard mass.
I would like to ask if eating persimmons and bananas really causes poisoning, or if it’s actually fine since there was a 3-4 hour gap.
The only thing I can think of doing now is drinking water, but I’m unsure if I should drink milk as I’ve heard it can protect the stomach.
Hu, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2020/11/07
Dr. Hong Yuanbin reply Internal Medicine
Hello, poisoning refers to the reaction of certain substances within the body.
However, if it involves consuming fruit itself, the content of any harmful substances is usually low and spaced out, so there is no risk of poisoning.
Please don't worry, and thank you for your question.
Reply Date: 2020/11/07
More Info
Eating bananas and persimmons together has been a topic of discussion in various cultures, particularly in traditional medicine. However, the concern about toxicity or adverse reactions from consuming these two fruits together is largely based on anecdotal evidence rather than scientific research.
To address your question directly: eating a banana and then a persimmon several hours later is generally considered safe and should not lead to any toxic reactions. The idea that these two fruits can cause a "hard mass" or toxicity is a myth that has circulated in some communities. The digestive system is quite capable of handling a variety of foods consumed at different times, and the human body has mechanisms to process and break down these foods effectively.
Bananas are rich in potassium, fiber, and vitamins, while persimmons are high in vitamins A and C, as well as dietary fiber. Both fruits offer health benefits and can be part of a balanced diet. The concern about them causing a hard mass likely stems from the fact that persimmons, particularly when unripe, contain tannins that can lead to gastrointestinal issues if consumed in large quantities or if the digestive system is sensitive. However, this is not a concern when they are eaten in moderation and especially not when consumed hours apart from other foods.
As for your question about drinking water or milk after consuming these fruits, staying hydrated is always a good practice, especially if you have any concerns about digestion. Drinking water can help facilitate digestion and prevent any potential discomfort. Milk is often thought to have a soothing effect on the stomach, but it may not be necessary in this case unless you have a specific sensitivity or discomfort that you believe milk could alleviate.
If you experience any unusual symptoms after eating these fruits, such as severe abdominal pain, nausea, or vomiting, it is essential to consult a healthcare professional. However, in the absence of such symptoms, there is no need to worry about the combination of bananas and persimmons.
In summary, eating a banana and then a persimmon several hours later is safe and should not cause any toxic reactions. The digestive system is well-equipped to handle various foods, and the myth surrounding the combination of these two fruits is not supported by scientific evidence. If you have any ongoing concerns about your diet or digestive health, it would be beneficial to speak with a healthcare provider or a registered dietitian for personalized advice.
Similar Q&A
Understanding Hypertension: The Impact of Bananas and Vitamin C
Hello: 1. Why should patients with hypertension avoid eating bananas? What is the reason? 2. Why should individuals with uric acid crystals avoid consuming large amounts of vitamin C? 3. Is it safe to take traditional Chinese medicine and Western medicine together? If not, ...
Dr. Zheng Shuwen reply Pharmacology
Question 1: Why should patients with hypertension avoid eating bananas? What is the reason? Answer: Not all patients with hypertension need to avoid bananas; it depends on the medications you are taking. If you are on angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitors (ACEIs), such as Enal...[Read More] Understanding Hypertension: The Impact of Bananas and Vitamin C
Does Eating Too Many Bananas Cause Muscle and Joint Pain?
Hello, Dietitian Tsai Hsiu-Wen: I heard that eating too many bananas can cause muscle and joint pain. Is that true?
Dr. Cai Xiuwen reply Nutrition
Hello! Many elderly people often mention that eggplants are toxic and that eating too many bananas can cause soreness. From a nutritional standpoint, a diverse diet can provide balanced nutrition. Some individuals may have allergies to certain nutrients, which can lead to discomf...[Read More] Does Eating Too Many Bananas Cause Muscle and Joint Pain?
Banana and Soybean Juice: Benefits, Risks, and Nutritional Insights
Hello: Blending bananas with boiled and mashed yellow soybeans and some water into a juice is said by colleagues who have tried it to help with removing spots and promoting bowel movements when consumed regularly. Is this true? Can it be consumed on an empty stomach in the mornin...
Dr. Cai Xiuwen reply Nutrition
Hello! Both bananas and soybeans are high in fiber content, and consuming them regularly can help with bowel movements, maintaining smooth digestion, and reducing the retention of feces in the intestines, which in turn decreases the absorption of ammonia and harmful substances. A...[Read More] Banana and Soybean Juice: Benefits, Risks, and Nutritional Insights
How to Prevent Stomach Stones After Eating Too Many Persimmons
I just finished lunch, where I had a plate of fried rice, and then I ate six soft persimmons, each about the size of half a fist, including the skin. Later, I read online that eating too many persimmons can lead to gastric persimmon stones, which can be quite troublesome to deal ...
Dr. Chen Shidian reply Gastroenterology and Hepatology
Hello Leo, your peristalsis seems normal, so there shouldn't be any issues. You will be able to pass it. Gastric stones are mostly a condition found in the elderly with motility disorders. Changhua Hospital cares about your health. Dr. Chen Shidian.[Read More] How to Prevent Stomach Stones After Eating Too Many Persimmons
Related FAQ
(Internal Medicine)
Medication Side Effects(Gastroenterology and Hepatology)
Health Report(Internal Medicine)
Poisoning(Family Medicine)
Digestion(Internal Medicine)
Vomiting(Gastroenterology and Hepatology)
Uric Acid(Internal Medicine)
Hepatitis B(Internal Medicine)
Dietary Consultation(Internal Medicine)
Accidental Ingestion(Otolaryngology)