Syphilis Recurrence: Insights on False Positives and Immunity - Urology

Share to:

Can syphilis recur?


I would like to ask the doctor, over ten years ago I was infected with syphilis and received the standard three doses of benzathine penicillin treatment.
Last year, my physical examination showed VDRL (-) and TPHA 1:180.
Recently, I visited a doctor due to eye inflammation and was diagnosed with iritis.
During the examination for various related diseases, the report indicated that my rheumatoid arthritis index was slightly elevated, but VDRL was positive at 1:4 and TPHA was 1:2560.
Does this indicate a relapse of syphilis, or could it be a false positive due to an immune system issue?

Xiao Bao, 50~59 year old female. Ask Date: 2020/11/28

Dr. Du Shixi reply Urology


Hello: It is possible, and it may require several tests to determine based on the changes in the indices.
Personally, I believe that both VDRL and TPHA show changes, so caution is advised.
Wishing you good health.

Reply Date: 2020/11/28

More Info


Syphilis, caused by the bacterium Treponema pallidum, is a sexually transmitted infection that can have serious long-term health consequences if left untreated. Your history of syphilis infection and subsequent treatment with benzathine penicillin is important in understanding your current situation. The tests you mentioned, VDRL (Venereal Disease Research Laboratory) and TPHA (Treponema pallidum hemagglutination assay), are commonly used to diagnose syphilis and monitor treatment response.

In your case, the VDRL test is showing a low positive result (1:4), while the TPHA is significantly elevated (1:2560). The TPHA test is more specific for syphilis, meaning it is less likely to give false-positive results compared to the VDRL test. A positive TPHA indicates that you have been exposed to the syphilis bacterium at some point, but it does not necessarily indicate an active infection or recurrence of syphilis.

The VDRL test can sometimes yield false-positive results due to various factors, including autoimmune diseases, infections, pregnancy, and other conditions. Given that you have elevated rheumatoid arthritis indices, it is possible that your immune system's response to your underlying condition could be contributing to the false-positive result on the VDRL test.
In terms of syphilis recurrence, it is important to note that after successful treatment, the risk of reinfection is always present if exposed again to the bacterium. However, a significant rise in TPHA titers after treatment could suggest a new infection rather than a recurrence of the previous one, especially if you have had unprotected sexual contact since your treatment.

To clarify your situation, it would be advisable to consult with a healthcare provider who can evaluate your symptoms, review your medical history, and possibly conduct further testing. They may recommend a repeat VDRL test or additional tests to confirm the diagnosis and assess whether you are experiencing a new syphilis infection or if the positive results are due to other factors, such as your autoimmune condition.

In summary, while your elevated TPHA suggests past exposure to syphilis, the low positive VDRL and your autoimmune indicators raise the possibility of a false positive rather than a recurrence of syphilis. It is crucial to have a thorough evaluation by a healthcare professional to determine the best course of action and ensure appropriate management of both your syphilis history and any underlying autoimmune conditions.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Syphilis Recurrence: Causes and Treatment Insights

I would like to inquire about the issue of syphilis recurrence. In September 2014, I tested positive with a titer of 1:64 (since I was unsure how long I had been infected, I received three injections). In December 2014, follow-up testing showed a titer of 1:2, which seemed to ind...


Dr. Sun Hongshun reply Urology
Hello: You have recurrent syphilis titers, and you are undergoing regular treatment with only one sexual partner. Please bring your partner to the infectious disease clinic for consultation and treatment.

[Read More] Understanding Syphilis Recurrence: Causes and Treatment Insights


Syphilis Recurrence or Reinfection: Understanding Your Risks and Options

Background summary: The individual is HIV positive and has been well-controlled on medication. They received the hepatitis B vaccine about one to two months ago and had a syphilis infection approximately one to two years ago, with a recent syphilis titer of 24 two months ago. Rec...


Dr. Sun Hongshun reply Urology
Hello, it sounds like there is a significant chance of syphilis. As for new infections or recurrences, it is uncertain. Since your immune system is relatively weak, please take extra precautions to protect yourself. Healthcare providers genuinely care about your well-being, and I...

[Read More] Syphilis Recurrence or Reinfection: Understanding Your Risks and Options


Understanding False Positives in Syphilis Testing: What You Need to Know

Hello, I recently underwent a health check, and the syphilis test result came back positive. However, I have no sexual experience, have not had any injuries that could lead to bloodborne infections in recent months, and I have not experienced any discomfort or skin redness. My ov...


Dr. Cai Zhuorong reply Urology
If there is suspicion that the RPR test is a false positive, a TPHA test can be performed for confirmation.

[Read More] Understanding False Positives in Syphilis Testing: What You Need to Know


Red Rash Recurrence After Syphilis Treatment in HIV Patients: What to Know

Hello Doctor: I am an HIV patient. I had a follow-up appointment on December 7, and on December 12, I was notified that I tested positive for syphilis (syphilis testing: STS-RPR greater than 1:128, TPPA 1:5120). During this period, I experienced mild rashes on my arm and genital ...


Dr. Du Shixi reply Urology
Hello: Follow-up visit is necessary (due to changes).

[Read More] Red Rash Recurrence After Syphilis Treatment in HIV Patients: What to Know


Related FAQ