Numbness in the hand after surgery for a fracture of the metacarpal bones?
Hello Dr.
Shen! My family member suffered a fracture in the left hand and wrist last October.
The doctor recommended surgery for a quicker recovery, so we decided to proceed with the operation and used self-paid bone screws.
The doctor indicated that the screws do not need to be removed.
Since the surgery, my family member has been experiencing continuous numbness in the left hand 24 hours a day, even while sleeping.
If the fingers are touched, they experience sharp pain, making self-massage ineffective.
I would like to ask Dr.
Shen if this situation is normal and how it can be improved.
Is it possible that the bone screws are compressing a nerve, and would removing them help? My family member is concerned about having to undergo anesthesia again and the need for wound care if the screws are removed.
They are hesitant about whether to return for a follow-up appointment.
If a follow-up is necessary, should we go back to the original orthopedic hospital for an evaluation, or should we consider consulting a neurologist or neurosurgeon? Thank you!
Lü Shiying, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2021/04/18
Dr. Shen Boquan reply Orthopedics
Hello, it seems you may have a metacarpal fracture.
Metacarpal fractures are typically treated with surgery on the dorsal side, where a steel plate is implanted.
Generally, this procedure does not significantly damage the digital nerves, although it may affect the superficial nerves.
If the fracture has healed but numbness persists, you might consider having the plate removed.
Regarding anesthesia options, this can be discussed further; if the procedure is more superficial, local anesthesia may be considered.
I recommend consulting with an orthopedic surgeon for further management.
Wishing you good health.
Sincerely, Shen Baiquan.
Reply Date: 2021/04/18
More Info
Persistent hand numbness after surgery can be a concerning issue, especially when it affects daily activities and quality of life. In your case, the numbness and tingling sensations in your family member's left hand following surgery for a wrist fracture could be attributed to several factors, including nerve compression, scar tissue formation, or even issues related to the hardware used during the surgery, such as the bone screws.
Understanding the Causes
1. Nerve Compression: After a fracture and subsequent surgery, the surrounding tissues, including muscles and tendons, can swell or develop scar tissue. This can lead to compression of the nerves that run through the wrist and hand, resulting in symptoms like numbness, tingling, and pain. The median nerve, in particular, is susceptible to compression, especially in the context of wrist injuries.
2. Hardware Issues: The bone screws used in the surgery are intended to stabilize the fracture. However, in some cases, these screws can irritate or compress nearby nerves, leading to persistent symptoms. If the screws are indeed causing nerve compression, removing them may alleviate the symptoms.
3. Scar Tissue Formation: Post-surgical healing often involves the formation of scar tissue, which can sometimes entrap nerves or restrict movement, contributing to numbness and discomfort.
4. Complex Regional Pain Syndrome (CRPS): Although less common, CRPS can develop after an injury or surgery, leading to chronic pain, swelling, and changes in skin color and temperature. This condition may also present with numbness.
Recommendations for Improvement
1. Medical Evaluation: It is crucial to have a thorough evaluation by a healthcare professional. Since the symptoms have persisted for an extended period, returning to the original orthopedic surgeon is advisable. They can assess whether the hardware is causing the symptoms and determine if further imaging (like an MRI or ultrasound) is necessary to evaluate nerve status and the surrounding tissues.
2. Referral to Specialists: If the orthopedic evaluation does not provide a clear answer or if nerve damage is suspected, a referral to a neurologist or a neurosurgeon may be warranted. These specialists can conduct nerve conduction studies or electromyography (EMG) to assess nerve function and identify any underlying issues.
3. Physical Therapy: Engaging in physical therapy can help improve hand function and reduce symptoms. A physical therapist can provide exercises to strengthen the hand and wrist, improve flexibility, and promote circulation, which may alleviate some of the numbness.
4. Pain Management: If pain is significant, discussing pain management options with the healthcare provider is essential. This may include medications, nerve blocks, or other interventions to help manage symptoms.
5. Monitoring Symptoms: Keeping a detailed record of symptoms, including when they occur, their intensity, and any activities that exacerbate or relieve them, can be helpful for the healthcare provider in diagnosing the issue.
Conclusion
In summary, persistent numbness after surgery is not uncommon, but it should not be ignored, especially when it affects daily life. A comprehensive evaluation by the original orthopedic surgeon, followed by possible referrals to specialists, is the best course of action. Addressing the issue early can help prevent further complications and improve your family member's quality of life. If the screws are indeed the source of the problem, discussing the risks and benefits of removal with the surgeon will be crucial in making an informed decision.
Similar Q&A
Post-Surgery Numbness in Fingers: Understanding Recovery After Carpal Tunnel Surgery
I have had carpal tunnel syndrome and underwent surgery on my wrist a month ago. My fingers are still experiencing numbness, and I'm unsure if the surgery was unsuccessful or if there is another issue.
Dr. Chen Xianchang reply Rehabilitation
Hello, Miss: I would like to respond to your question and provide the following suggestions: 1. You should first undergo nerve conduction studies and electromyography to determine the location and extent of nerve compression. 2. Sometimes, a. edema during surgery can cause tem...[Read More] Post-Surgery Numbness in Fingers: Understanding Recovery After Carpal Tunnel Surgery
Persistent Hand Numbness After Ulnar Nerve Surgery: Causes and Solutions
Why is there still numbness and tightness in my hand after undergoing ulnar nerve anterior transposition on January 6th? Is there a problem, or did the doctor not perform the procedure correctly?
Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
Typically, it takes two to three months after surgery for symptoms to gradually improve. If the condition was severe before the surgery, the recovery period may be longer. It is advisable to consult a physician for evaluation and treatment.[Read More] Persistent Hand Numbness After Ulnar Nerve Surgery: Causes and Solutions
Post-Surgery Numbness: Understanding Nerve Issues and Rehabilitation Needs
Hello Doctor: My father (currently 59 years old) had his index finger severed by a machine a few years ago and underwent a surgical repair. Now, he experiences numbness and tightness in his hand when the weather changes or after riding a motorcycle for too long, sometimes to the ...
Dr. Yin Xinbei reply Rehabilitation
When nerves that have been severed and reconnected are severely damaged, it is often impossible to fully repair them, and residual numbness is a normal phenomenon. Additionally, blood and lymphatic circulation may also be impaired, so maintaining the same position for too long ca...[Read More] Post-Surgery Numbness: Understanding Nerve Issues and Rehabilitation Needs
Persistent Hand Numbness: Seeking Answers After 4 Months of Symptoms
Hello doctor, I have been experiencing numbness in my hands since the beginning of September. Initially, it was only in my right hand, but within a week, my left hand started to feel numb as well. The numbness has not ceased, causing significant inconvenience in my daily life. I ...
Dr. Gao Chunde reply Neurology
When experiencing hand numbness, it is important to determine whether the distribution of symptoms falls within the peripheral nerve range, nerve roots, or central nervous system. Particularly, if nerve conduction studies are normal, carpal tunnel syndrome is almost ruled out. Sy...[Read More] Persistent Hand Numbness: Seeking Answers After 4 Months of Symptoms
Related FAQ
(Orthopedics)
Hand Numbness(Neurology)
Finger Numbness(Neurosurgery)
Hand Numbness(Rehabilitation)
Facial And Hand Numbness(Neurology)
Left Foot Numbness(Neurosurgery)
Numbness In Hands(Family Medicine)
Carpal Tunnel Syndrome(Neurosurgery)
Tingling In Hands And Feet(Neurology)
Palmar Hyperhidrosis(Neurosurgery)