Is Surgery Necessary for an 83-Year-Old with Hip Dislocation?

Is it necessary for an 83-year-old elderly person to undergo surgery again for a hip dislocation?

Hello, an 83-year-old elderly person has moderate dementia and has undergone hip joint surgery on both legs a total of three times.
This time, she fell while trying to get out of bed and dislocated her left leg again.
She claims that it doesn't hurt.
Now, there is a dilemma about whether it is necessary to perform surgery again, as there is a concern that her mental condition may deteriorate further after the operation.
She has a tendency to pull out tubes, remove her diaper, and walk independently, often taking these actions when caregivers are momentarily absent.
There is genuine concern that if she undergoes surgery again, her situation may worsen, so we are seeking multiple opinions and advice...
Thank you.

Janet, 40~49 year old female. Ask Date: 2021/07/26

Dr. Cai Dongqi reply Family Medicine

Hello Janet! I'm sorry, but your question is outside my area of expertise.
I recommend that you consult an orthopedic specialist.

Reply Date: 2021/07/26

More Info

When considering whether surgery is necessary for an 83-year-old patient with a hip dislocation, particularly one who has a history of multiple surgeries and moderate dementia, several factors must be taken into account. The decision to proceed with surgery is complex and should involve a thorough assessment of the patient's overall health, the severity of the dislocation, the potential benefits of surgery, and the associated risks.

Firstly, it is essential to evaluate the current condition of the hip joint. If the dislocation is causing significant instability or if there is a risk of further injury, surgical intervention may be warranted. However, if the patient is not experiencing pain and the dislocation does not pose an immediate threat to her mobility or quality of life, conservative management may be a viable option. This could include physical therapy, pain management, and close monitoring.

The patient's cognitive status is another critical consideration. Moderate dementia can complicate recovery from surgery, as patients may have difficulty following post-operative instructions, which can lead to complications. Additionally, the stress of surgery and hospitalization may exacerbate cognitive decline. If the patient has a strong desire to maintain her independence, as indicated by her attempts to walk unassisted, this should also be factored into the decision-making process.

Moreover, the history of multiple surgeries raises concerns about the cumulative risks associated with anesthesia and surgical recovery. Older adults, particularly those with pre-existing conditions, may face increased risks of complications such as infections, blood clots, and prolonged recovery times. The potential for a decline in mental status post-surgery is also a valid concern, especially in patients with cognitive impairments.

In terms of assessing the necessity of surgery, it is crucial to have a multidisciplinary approach involving orthopedic surgeons, geriatricians, and possibly neurologists. They can provide insights into the risks and benefits of surgical intervention tailored to the patient's specific health profile.
If surgery is deemed necessary, pre-operative optimization is vital. This may include addressing any nutritional deficiencies, managing existing medical conditions, and ensuring that the patient is in the best possible health before undergoing the procedure. Post-operative care should also be carefully planned, with a focus on rehabilitation and support to help the patient regain mobility safely.

In conclusion, the decision to proceed with surgery for an 83-year-old with a hip dislocation should be made collaboratively, considering the patient's overall health, cognitive status, and personal wishes. If surgery is not pursued, alternative management strategies should be explored to ensure the patient's safety and quality of life. Ultimately, the goal should be to balance the risks of surgery against the potential benefits, keeping the patient's best interests at heart.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Hip Fracture Surgery Options for Elderly Patients

Hello, my grandfather has suffered a fracture between the left hip and the acetabulum due to a fall. The doctor has recommended surgery, but my grandmother had a similar situation where she underwent surgery and the internal fixation screws caused rejection and inflammation, lead...

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
Fractures near the hip joint are usually best treated with surgery. Sometimes, internal fixation with screws is required, while in other cases, a total hip arthroplasty may be necessary, depending on the situation. Age is not a concern, and prompt surgical intervention leads to f...

Should Surgery Be Urgent for a Humerus Fracture in Elderly Patients?

Hello, Doctor: My mother is 64 years old and has Parkinson's disease. She underwent surgery on her left elbow due to an injury from a fall two years ago, but because of an infection, she had to undergo a debridement surgery. Then, in July of last year, she had a total elbow ...

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
Because there are no visible changes in the imaging, it is difficult to make a judgment. However, after receiving a joint replacement, if the fracture is unstable, surgery is usually required. If it is a stable fracture, conservative treatment may be an option. You may consider c...

Knee Pain in Seniors: Alternatives to Surgery for Joint Issues

I would like to ask a question for my grandmother. She says that her knees are very painful, especially when standing, walking, or going up and down stairs. Previously, she saw a doctor who indicated that it was due to joint degeneration. Surgery was initially an option, but my g...

Dr. Shi Qiming reply Orthopedics
Hello: We recommend that you visit our orthopedic outpatient clinic for further examination and evaluation. It is not that an 80-year-old cannot undergo surgery, but rather that the patient's individual health condition needs to be assessed before making a decision. Thank yo...

Is Hip Replacement Surgery Safe for My 90-Year-Old Mother?

My mother is 90 years old and has hip joint degeneration. She visited the Songshan Air Force Hospital, where the doctor recommended a hip replacement. I would like to know if it is suitable for her at such an advanced age. Is there a risk that she might not be able to walk after ...

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
1. Age is not a problem. 2. Health status must be good, such as having mobility. 3. Cardiopulmonary function should be adequate to withstand such surgery. 4. After a successful surgery, normal walking ability can usually be restored. 5. It is preferable to use minimally invasive ...