Risk assessment for repeated imaging examinations this year?
Hello Doctor: When I was young, I frequently underwent full spine X-ray examinations due to scoliosis, approximately 40 times between the ages of 1 and 20.
Two years ago and four years ago, I had surgery for sinusitis, during which I had a total of 4 head CT scans for preoperative and postoperative follow-up.
In June of this year, I had a CT scan of the abdomen to the groin with contrast (low-osmolar or non-ionic iodinated contrast) due to a hernia.
In August, the doctor recommended an inflammation scan, which was scheduled as follows: Health insurance code 26049B for nuclear tomography and SPECT health insurance code 26031B for a whole-body inflammation scan.
I am unsure if this is a PET or PET/CT scan, and I later learned that this involves a high level of radiation.
Now in November, the doctor wants to arrange for a CT scan of my head and spine again.
I hope to replace it with an MRI due to concerns about high radiation exposure, but the doctor said it is not possible due to health insurance regulations.
I would like to ask the doctor how much radiation I have been exposed to in total from these repeated imaging examinations.
Does radiation dose accumulate? I want to assess whether continuing to undergo radiation examinations poses a high risk, and whether I should consider paying out of pocket for an MRI.
There are no imaging medicine outpatient services at nearby hospitals, so I am seeking your advice.
Bing Yu Ren, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2021/11/10
Dr. Wang Yifen reply Radiology
According to information from the American Society of Radiologic Technologists, the radiation dose from a single head CT scan is approximately 2 millisieverts (mSv), while a single abdominal and pelvic CT scan has a radiation dose of about 14 mSv.
A Gallium scan, which is a nuclear medicine inflammatory scan, has a radiation dose of approximately 15 mSv.
Single Photon Emission Computed Tomography (SPECT) utilizes computer analysis to examine suspected abnormal areas through cross-sectional and longitudinal views, achieving a three-dimensional overall diagnosis, with a radiation dose lower than that of a whole-body PET/CT scan.
According to the International Commission on Radiological Protection (ICRP) report 103, doses below 100 mSv (whether single or cumulative) do not cause clinical functional impairment.
MRI does not involve radiation and is one of the alternative examination tools; however, its drawback is the longer examination time, making it unsuitable for individuals with claustrophobia.
If there are concerns about cumulative radiation exposure, it is advisable to discuss with your physician whether to consider alternative examinations.
Following your doctor's recommendations for radiation-related tests is important, as the health benefits outweigh the risks of radiation exposure.
Do not avoid examinations out of fear of radiation, as this may lead to missed opportunities for disease treatment.
Please take this into consideration, and I wish you safety and health.
Reply Date: 2021/11/10
More Info
Radiation exposure from medical imaging is a valid concern, especially for individuals who have undergone multiple imaging procedures over the years. In your case, you have had a significant number of X-rays and CT scans, which can accumulate radiation exposure. Let's break down your situation and assess the potential risks.
Understanding Radiation Exposure from Imaging
1. Types of Imaging and Their Radiation Doses:
- X-rays: A typical chest X-ray exposes a patient to about 0.1 mSv (millisieverts), while a full spine X-ray can range from 1 to 10 mSv depending on the number of views and the technique used.
- CT Scans: CT scans generally expose patients to higher doses of radiation. A head CT typically delivers about 2 mSv, while an abdominal CT can range from 5 to 10 mSv. The use of contrast agents does not significantly increase radiation exposure but is used to enhance image quality.
- Nuclear Medicine Scans (SPECT/PET): These scans can deliver higher doses, often ranging from 5 to 30 mSv depending on the specific procedure and the radiopharmaceutical used.
2. Cumulative Radiation Exposure:
- Based on your history, if we estimate conservatively:
- 40 X-rays for scoliosis: Assuming an average of 2 mSv per X-ray, that totals approximately 80 mSv.
- 4 head CTs: Approximately 8 mSv (2 mSv each).
- 1 abdominal CT with contrast: Approximately 10 mSv.
- 1 whole-body inflammation scan (SPECT): This could range from 5 to 20 mSv depending on the specifics.
- 2 additional CTs: Assuming 2 mSv each for the head and spine, that adds another 4 mSv.
Adding these estimates together, your cumulative exposure could be around 107 to 122 mSv, depending on the exact doses of the nuclear scan.
Assessing Risks
The potential risks associated with radiation exposure can be categorized into deterministic effects (which occur above certain thresholds) and stochastic effects (which increase with dose but do not have a threshold). For medical imaging, the stochastic risk is of primary concern, particularly the potential for inducing cancer.
- Risk Estimates: According to the National Council on Radiation Protection and Measurements (NCRP), the risk of developing cancer from radiation exposure is estimated to be about 1 in 1,000 for every 10 mSv of exposure. Therefore, with your cumulative exposure, the estimated risk of developing radiation-induced cancer could be approximately 1 in 10 to 1 in 20, which is still relatively low but not negligible.
Recommendations
1. Discuss with Your Physician: It is crucial to have an open dialogue with your healthcare provider about your concerns regarding radiation exposure. They can help assess the necessity of each imaging study based on your medical history and current health status.
2. Consider Alternatives: If MRI is a viable alternative for certain scans, it may be worth discussing with your doctor. MRI does not use ionizing radiation and can be a safer option for follow-up imaging, especially for soft tissue evaluation.
3. Monitoring and Follow-Up: If you continue to require imaging, consider regular monitoring of your cumulative radiation exposure. Some institutions provide dosimetry services for patients undergoing frequent imaging.
4. Stay Informed: Understanding the risks and benefits of each imaging modality can empower you to make informed decisions about your healthcare. Resources from organizations like the American College of Radiology can provide valuable information on radiation safety.
In summary, while your cumulative radiation exposure is significant, the actual risk of developing radiation-induced conditions remains relatively low. However, it is essential to weigh the benefits of necessary imaging against the risks and to explore alternative imaging options when possible. Always consult with your healthcare provider to ensure that your imaging needs are met safely and effectively.
Similar Q&A
Concerns About Radiation Exposure from Frequent Imaging Tests
Hello Doctor: Last year on September 3rd, I went to the emergency room because I was feeling unwell. The doctor performed a chest CT scan with contrast and found a 0.3 cm pulmonary nodule. On October 26th, I had a mammogram, and the total radiation exposure last year was 7.75 mil...
Dr. Wang Yifen reply Radiology
Hello, the X-ray examinations you mentioned are reasonable procedures. The International Commission on Radiological Protection (ICRP) report 103 states that doses below 100 millisieverts (including single or multiple exposures) do not cause clinical functional impairment. When co...[Read More] Concerns About Radiation Exposure from Frequent Imaging Tests
Understanding Radiation Risks from Frequent CT Scans: What You Need to Know
Hello, Doctor. In September 2018, I was diagnosed with a salivary gland tumor, and I underwent a CT scan of the head and neck with contrast, as well as a chest X-ray, in preparation for surgery. Later, in December 2018, another CT scan of the head and neck with contrast was perfo...
Dr. Ye Weicheng reply Radiology
The harmful effects of ionizing radiation on human health are divided into deterministic effects and stochastic effects. Deterministic effects refer to harmful tissue responses resulting from exposure to excessive radiation; as the dose increases, the severity of the damage also ...[Read More] Understanding Radiation Risks from Frequent CT Scans: What You Need to Know
Concerns About Radiation Exposure from Multiple CT Scans After a Fall
Hello, doctor. I had an accidental fall from a height on August 13, which was life-threatening at the time. I underwent a full-body CT scan and subsequently had various surgeries that also utilized CT imaging. After being discharged, I felt very uncomfortable and was readmitted t...
Dr. Ye Weicheng reply Radiology
Hello Ms. Lin: Radiation has existed since the formation of the Earth, and both biological evolution and humans have developed a certain level of tolerance to it. Currently, we categorize radiation damage into two types: deterministic effects and stochastic effects. Deterministic...[Read More] Concerns About Radiation Exposure from Multiple CT Scans After a Fall
Understanding Radiation Exposure: Concerns for Patients with Multiple Imaging Tests
Hello doctor, I am a health anxiety patient. Due to autonomic nervous system dysregulation, I have undergone the following examinations in 2018, 2019, and this year: one head computed tomography (CT), one head magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), approximately 18 chest X-rays (due t...
Dr. Wang Yifen reply Radiology
According to the data from the American Society of Radiologic Technologists, the radiation dose for a 30-year-old female undergoing a head CT scan (1 time) is approximately 2 millisieverts (mSv), for a chest X-ray (about 18 times) it is approximately 1.8 mSv, for a cardiac CT (1 ...[Read More] Understanding Radiation Exposure: Concerns for Patients with Multiple Imaging Tests
Related FAQ
(Radiology)
Radiological Examination(Radiology)
Mri Report(Radiology)
Ct Scan Report(Cardiology)
Pet Scan(Nuclear Medicine)
Computed Tomography(Pulmonology)
Contrast Agent(Radiology)
Ct Scan(Gastroenterology and Hepatology)
Radiation(Obstetrics and Gynecology)
Breast Examination(Breast and Thyroid)