Visual Field Tests: Why Results May Vary Over Time - Ophthalmology

Share to:

I'm sorry, but I cannot assist with that?


Hello Doctor: I would like to ask about the visual field test.
If the reports from last year and this year are similar, why did the machine indicate a borderline result this time while last year it was considered within the normal range? Is it possible that the machine's interpretation is just a reference and not entirely accurate? Additionally, regarding my optic nerves, both of my eyes have a slight cupping that is about 0.4-0.5 larger than normal, but it has not changed over the past few years.
One doctor mentioned that it might be congenital, while another suggested it could be due to myopia or astigmatism.
Given this, should I continue to have visual field tests approximately once a year? Thank you, Doctor!

Wei, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2022/01/26

Dr. Gao Pilin reply Ophthalmology


Hello Wei: There are no changes in the optic nerve, and the visual field changes are similar, indicating stability.
An annual check-up is sufficient.
Typically, the physician's interpretation is the standard, and the machine report is for reference only.
If you still have concerns, you can visit a hospital with a glaucoma specialty for another examination.

Reply Date: 2022/01/26

More Info


Understanding visual field tests and their variability over time can be quite complex, and it's essential to consider several factors that may influence the results. Visual field tests are designed to assess the peripheral vision and detect any abnormalities that may indicate underlying conditions affecting the optic nerve or the visual pathways in the brain.

Firstly, the variability in results from one year to the next can be attributed to several factors, including the testing equipment, the testing conditions, and the individual’s state during the test. Different machines may have slight variations in calibration, which can affect the results. Additionally, the environment in which the test is conducted—such as lighting conditions and the presence of distractions—can also impact the outcome. It’s crucial to ensure that the testing conditions are as consistent as possible for accurate comparisons over time.

Moreover, the interpretation of the results can vary between different healthcare providers. Some may consider a result at the threshold of normal to be clinically significant, while others may view it as acceptable. This subjectivity can lead to differences in how results are reported and understood. Therefore, it is essential to discuss any concerns with your healthcare provider to clarify what the results mean in your specific context.

Regarding the size of the optic nerve head (the area where the optic nerve enters the eye), a slight increase in the size of the cup-to-disc ratio (the ratio of the diameter of the cup to the diameter of the disc) can be normal for some individuals. A ratio of 0.4-0.5 is often considered within the range of normal, but it is essential to monitor any changes over time. Factors such as myopia (nearsightedness) and astigmatism can indeed influence the appearance of the optic nerve head, but they do not typically cause significant changes in the cup-to-disc ratio.
If your optic nerve head has remained stable over the years, this is a positive sign. Stability suggests that there may not be any significant underlying pathology affecting your optic nerve. However, regular monitoring is crucial, especially if there are any risk factors for glaucoma or other optic nerve diseases.
In terms of the frequency of visual field testing, if your results have been stable and there are no concerning symptoms, annual testing is generally appropriate. However, if there are any changes in your vision, new symptoms, or if your healthcare provider recommends more frequent monitoring, it’s essential to follow their advice.

In conclusion, while visual field tests are valuable tools for assessing peripheral vision and detecting potential issues, variability in results can occur due to multiple factors. Regular monitoring and open communication with your healthcare provider are key to understanding your eye health and ensuring any necessary interventions are made promptly. If you have any further concerns or if your vision changes, do not hesitate to seek further evaluation.

Similar Q&A

Understanding the Discrepancy Between OCT and Visual Field Tests in Glaucoma

I have just been diagnosed with glaucoma. The OCT data indicates early-stage glaucoma, but the visual field test shows significant defects. Is it possible to have a large discrepancy between the OCT data and the visual field test results?


Dr. Gao Pilin reply Ophthalmology
Hello Jimmy: OCT is a type of structural assessment of the optic nerve, while visual field testing is a functional assessment. There is a certain correlation between the two, but they are not always completely consistent. The condition of the optic nerve is primarily assessed thr...

[Read More] Understanding the Discrepancy Between OCT and Visual Field Tests in Glaucoma


Understanding Suspected Early Glaucoma and Vision Loss: Key Insights

Hello, Director. Recently, during a routine eye examination (which included intraocular pressure, fundus examination, OCT, and visual field tests), the physician determined that there was some visual field loss and indicated a "suspected" early stage of glaucoma (howeve...


Dr. Gao Pilin reply Ophthalmology
Hello: Since I have not examined you in person, my response is for reference only. Please consult your ophthalmologist for specific treatment recommendations. 1. It appears that your fundus examination results show some changes, including the structure of the optic nerve head. ...

[Read More] Understanding Suspected Early Glaucoma and Vision Loss: Key Insights


Understanding Visual Field Loss After Stroke: Disability Certification Insights

Hello, my father has experienced a stroke, resulting in a 50% loss of vision (measured using the eight-point visual field test). I would like to help him apply for a disability certificate, but the doctor mentioned that he must undergo a different assessment (the automated perime...


Dr. Wang Zhangji reply Ophthalmology
Hello: I apologize, but it is not possible to infer or calculate the results. In fact, to apply for a disability certificate, it is necessary to determine whether it also meets the criteria in the field of neurology. Sincerely, Dr. Wang Zhang-ji, Ophthalmology.

[Read More] Understanding Visual Field Loss After Stroke: Disability Certification Insights


Understanding Visual Field Loss After Brain Tumor Surgery: Eligibility Criteria

Hello doctor, I underwent surgery for a right brain tumor, which has resulted in homonymous hemianopia in both eyes on the left side. I have confirmed this condition through examination. Could you please let me know if I meet the following criteria? Severe: Visual acuity in the ...


Dr. Ke Meilan reply Ophthalmology
Hello, may I ask what your best corrected vision is? How much vision loss do you have? Knowing these two results will help determine if you meet the criteria, so please visit a major hospital for an examination. Thank you for your message. Sincerely, Dr. Mei-Lan Ke, Ophthalmology...

[Read More] Understanding Visual Field Loss After Brain Tumor Surgery: Eligibility Criteria


Related FAQ

Visual Field Test

(Ophthalmology)

Visual Field

(Ophthalmology)

Visual Acuity Test

(Ophthalmology)

Vision Discrepancy

(Ophthalmology)

Refraction Test

(Ophthalmology)

Visual Persistence

(Ophthalmology)

Visual Disturbance

(Ophthalmology)

Fundus Examination

(Ophthalmology)

Macular Pucker

(Ophthalmology)

Pediatric Vision Screening

(Ophthalmology)