COVID-19 Booster Shot Options for Mixed Vaccine Recipients in Taiwan - Family Medicine

Share to:

Third dose of the COVID-19 vaccine?


Hello: My mother is 74 years old.
She received the first dose of AstraZeneca, the second dose of BioNTech, and she wants to get the third dose of BioNTech, but the hospitals and clinics no longer provide it.
I would like to ask: 1.
Can my mother receive the Moderna vaccine for her third dose? 2.
Some doctors and researchers from the National Health Research Institutes suggest that for those who received mixed doses for the first two shots, it is best for the third dose to be the same brand as the second dose.
Are there any studies, either domestically or internationally, regarding the third dose for individuals who received mixed vaccines for the first two doses? 3.
Will Taiwan be receiving more BioNTech vaccines soon? Thank you for your clarification.

Xiao Zhang, 40~49 year old female. Ask Date: 2022/03/29

Dr. Chen Bozhang reply Family Medicine


Hello! Before receiving the COVID-19 vaccine, it is important to have a physician assess whether your individual health condition is suitable for vaccination.
For information regarding vaccine availability, it is recommended to contact your local health department.
Thank you!

Reply Date: 2022/03/29

More Info


In Taiwan, the COVID-19 vaccination strategy has evolved significantly since the onset of the pandemic, particularly concerning the administration of booster shots for individuals who have received mixed vaccine regimens. Your mother's vaccination history, having received the first dose of AstraZeneca (AZ) and the second dose of BioNTech (BNT), places her in a category where considerations for the third dose are crucial.

1. Can your mother receive Moderna for her third dose? Yes, your mother can receive the Moderna vaccine as her third dose. Current guidelines from health authorities, including the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) in Taiwan, indicate that individuals who have received mixed vaccines can receive a different vaccine for their booster shot. Studies have shown that mixing vaccine types can enhance immune responses, and receiving a different brand for the booster may provide broader protection against variants of the virus.

2. Is it recommended to have the same brand for the third dose as the second dose? While some experts suggest that receiving the same brand for the third dose as the second dose may optimize the immune response, research indicates that mixed vaccination regimens can still be effective. Studies from various countries have demonstrated that individuals who received mixed doses (e.g., AZ followed by BNT) exhibited robust immune responses, often comparable to or even exceeding those who received three doses of the same vaccine. Therefore, while it is ideal to follow the same brand for consistency, it is not a strict requirement, and receiving Moderna as a third dose is a viable option.

3. Will there be a supply of BNT vaccines in Taiwan soon? Vaccine availability can fluctuate based on supply chains and procurement agreements. The Taiwanese government has been actively working to ensure that vaccines are available to the population, including BNT. It is advisable to stay updated through official announcements from the Ministry of Health and Welfare or local health authorities regarding the availability of specific vaccines, including BNT.


Additional Considerations
When considering booster shots, it is essential to understand the rationale behind vaccination strategies. The primary goal is to enhance immunity, especially against emerging variants of the virus. Research has shown that the immune response can be significantly improved with booster doses, regardless of whether they are from the same manufacturer or a different one.
Moreover, the safety profile of mixed vaccination regimens has been reassuring. Clinical trials and real-world studies have indicated that adverse effects are generally mild and similar to those experienced after the initial doses. Common side effects may include soreness at the injection site, fatigue, headache, and mild fever, which typically resolve within a few days.

For older adults, such as your mother, receiving a booster is particularly important due to the increased risk of severe illness from COVID-19. The immune response tends to wane over time, and booster shots help to reinvigorate the immune system's ability to fight off infections.

In conclusion, your mother has the option to receive the Moderna vaccine as her third dose, and while consistency in vaccine brands is often recommended, it is not mandatory. The mixed vaccination strategy is supported by emerging evidence, and staying informed about vaccine availability will help ensure she receives her booster in a timely manner. Always consult with healthcare providers for personalized medical advice and to discuss any concerns regarding vaccination.

Similar Q&A

COVID-19 Vaccine Recommendations for Individuals with Asthma

Hello Doctor: Eight months ago, I experienced chronic allergic inflammation of the airways, and my asthma flares up during cold weather. I have been undergoing asthma treatment for the past six months (ongoing), using a bronchodilator twice daily and taking a dose of SINGULAIR be...


Dr. Yang Wenda reply Pulmonology
Hello: Any vaccine has a clear protective effect against severe illness and death. The current situation in Taiwan may not offer many options. There are currently not many literature reports available, but if you have the choice, you might want to search online for more informati...

[Read More] COVID-19 Vaccine Recommendations for Individuals with Asthma


COVID-19 Vaccine Injection Concerns: Tetanus and Allergy Considerations

Hello, doctor. I am inquiring on behalf of a friend regarding COVID-19 vaccination questions. The questions are as follows: 1. If they recently received a tetanus shot (about 2 weeks ago), is it safe to receive the vaccine? 2. They had an allergic reaction to a contrast agent due...


Dr. Hong Yuanbin reply Internal Medicine
Hello, 1. There are currently no relevant international recommendations regarding this matter; however, expert consensus generally suggests that different types of vaccines should be administered at least one month apart for optimal results. 2. It is true that the Moderna vac...

[Read More] COVID-19 Vaccine Injection Concerns: Tetanus and Allergy Considerations


Can You Get the COVID-19 Vaccine with High ALT Levels?

Currently, Taiwan is gradually opening up vaccine administration. Based on the literature and data reviewed, I have not found any recommendations or prohibitions regarding vaccination when ALT levels are elevated. I would like to inquire whether it is still possible to schedule v...


Dr. Cai Anshun reply Gastroenterology and Hepatology
Hello: A slightly elevated level will not affect vaccination, unless the liver enzymes are more than twice the normal level, or if there is jaundice, or if there are other health conditions. In such cases, it is advisable to consult a hepatobiliary specialist to determine the cau...

[Read More] Can You Get the COVID-19 Vaccine with High ALT Levels?


COVID-19 Vaccination for Toddlers: Insights on Moderna and China Vaccines

Hello, doctor. My child is currently two years and seven months old and is in mainland China. Would you recommend getting vaccinated there before returning to Taiwan, or should we get the Moderna vaccine in Taiwan, or not vaccinate at all? My child has been hospitalized for pneum...


Dr. Xiao Kaiwen reply Pediatrics
The COVID-19 vaccines from mainland China have not been legally granted emergency authorization in Taiwan, and the assessment of their efficacy is not very clear. Therefore, we do not have a thorough understanding of the COVID-19 vaccines produced in mainland China. However, the ...

[Read More] COVID-19 Vaccination for Toddlers: Insights on Moderna and China Vaccines


Related FAQ

Covid-19 Vaccine

(Family Medicine)

After Covid-19 Vaccination

(Family Medicine)

Covid-19 Vaccination

(Internal Medicine)

Covid-19 Vaccine

(Pulmonology)

Covid-19 Vaccine

(Obstetrics and Gynecology)

Covid-19 Vaccine

(Pediatrics)

After Covid-19 Vaccination

(Cardiology)

Vaccine Injection

(Family Medicine)

Hepatitis B Vaccine

(Family Medicine)

Covid-19

(Otolaryngology)