Chronic wet cough
Hello Doctor, I have suffered from colds since childhood and have frequently visited clinics for respiratory diseases.
For the past five years, after catching a cold, I have experienced a persistent wet cough (clear mucus with slight foaming) that lasts from one to four months.
During this time, due to the recurrent nature of my condition, I have tried various medications and antihistamines (for nasal allergies), but none have effectively alleviated my symptoms of coughing upon waking, nighttime cough, bronchial itching, and slight chest pressure.
An ENT specialist diagnosed me with chronic bronchitis/allergic bronchitis, and I have undergone chest X-rays and gastroscopy, which showed no abnormalities.
Later, when I consulted a pulmonologist, I brought my previous ENT medication records.
The doctor suggested trying "SABAs" (short-acting beta-agonists) for treatment, as my symptoms worsen with significant temperature changes, exposure to cold air, and damp weather, raising suspicion of "variant asthma." A bronchial provocation test was arranged.
After using the SABA, my symptoms improved immediately, and even my daily morning and evening cough ceased.
However, the results of the bronchial provocation test showed some variability, but the differences did not support a definitive diagnosis of asthma (I had previously undergone a lung function test that also did not confirm asthma).
My question is, if the test results do not support a diagnosis of asthma, can asthma be ruled out? If the tests consistently do not support a diagnosis of asthma, will I be unable to obtain a prescription for SABAs? Thank you! Note: I do not smoke.
Norah, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2022/04/14
Dr. Lu Mingzhi reply Pulmonology
Hello: The typical symptoms of asthma include prolonged intermittent cough with phlegm, shortness of breath, wheezing, and chest tightness (especially worsening at night or in the early morning).
However, not every asthma patient exhibits these typical symptoms.
Although pulmonary function tests are an important diagnostic tool, not all asthma patients will demonstrate typical pulmonary function results.
This may be due to insufficient technique when performing the tests or because the tests are conducted during asymptomatic periods.
Therefore, diagnosing asthma can be challenging for some individuals.
In clinical practice, if a patient is suspected of having asthma, even if their symptoms and pulmonary function tests do not meet the typical diagnostic criteria, physicians may still prescribe asthma medications.
If the patient's symptoms or pulmonary function show significant improvement after treatment, they may still be managed as asthma cases.
It is advisable to discuss the subsequent treatment plan with your physician.
Reply Date: 2022/04/14
More Info
Chronic wet cough can be a frustrating and debilitating condition, particularly when it persists for months and interferes with daily activities and sleep. Based on your description, it appears that you have been dealing with this issue for an extended period, and you have undergone various evaluations and treatments without definitive resolution.
Chronic cough can be classified into several categories, including postnasal drip, asthma, chronic bronchitis, and gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD). In your case, the symptoms of a persistent wet cough with clear, viscous sputum, along with the history of respiratory issues, suggest that you may be experiencing a combination of factors, including potential airway hyperreactivity or chronic bronchitis.
The fact that you have undergone imaging studies (like chest X-rays) and endoscopic evaluations (like gastroscopy) without significant findings is reassuring, as it helps rule out serious underlying conditions such as lung infections or malignancies. However, the absence of findings does not necessarily eliminate the possibility of asthma or other chronic respiratory conditions.
The use of bronchodilators, such as "吸必擴" (a common brand name for albuterol), can provide symptomatic relief by relaxing the muscles around the airways, making it easier to breathe. The immediate improvement you experienced after using this medication suggests that there may be some degree of bronchospasm or airway reactivity involved in your symptoms. However, the results of your bronchial provocation tests and lung function tests not supporting a diagnosis of asthma complicate the picture.
It is important to note that asthma can sometimes be difficult to diagnose, especially if the symptoms are not consistently present or if they are triggered by specific environmental factors. In some cases, individuals may exhibit asthma-like symptoms without meeting all the criteria for a formal diagnosis. This is often referred to as "variant asthma" or "exercise-induced bronchoconstriction."
If your bronchial provocation tests did not yield results that support a diagnosis of asthma, it does not necessarily mean that you cannot benefit from bronchodilator therapy. Many clinicians will consider the clinical picture, including symptom relief with bronchodilators, when making treatment decisions. It may be worthwhile to discuss with your healthcare provider the possibility of continuing the use of bronchodilators, even if asthma is not definitively diagnosed.
In addition to bronchodilator therapy, it may be beneficial to explore other treatment options. These could include inhaled corticosteroids, which can help reduce inflammation in the airways, or other medications that target specific underlying causes of your cough, such as antihistamines for allergic components or proton pump inhibitors if GERD is suspected.
Lifestyle modifications can also play a significant role in managing chronic cough. Avoiding known triggers, such as cold air, allergens, and irritants (like smoke or strong odors), can help minimize symptoms. Additionally, maintaining good hydration and using a humidifier may alleviate some of the discomfort associated with a wet cough.
Given your history of respiratory issues and the complexity of your symptoms, it may be beneficial to seek a second opinion from a pulmonologist who specializes in chronic cough or asthma. They may offer additional insights or alternative diagnostic approaches that could lead to a more effective management plan.
In summary, while the results of your bronchial provocation tests may not support a diagnosis of asthma, the symptomatic relief you experienced with bronchodilators suggests that there may still be a role for these medications in your treatment. A comprehensive approach that includes medication management, lifestyle modifications, and possibly further evaluation by a specialist could help you achieve better control of your chronic wet cough.
Similar Q&A
Chronic Cough: Seeking Effective Treatment Solutions
Since January, I have been experiencing a persistent cough that hasn't improved. Sometimes I cough, and sometimes I don't, but tests have shown no significant issues. I have received treatment at both Luodong Saint Mary’s Hospital and Boai Hospital, yet I still haven...
Dr. Cai Zhenggu reply Otolaryngology
Hello, Miss Chang: Coughing is a "symptom" rather than a "disease." Many diseases can cause coughing, and treating the cough must focus on the "disease" rather than just the "symptom" for effective results; otherwise, it may frequently recu...[Read More] Chronic Cough: Seeking Effective Treatment Solutions
Chronic Pharyngitis and Coughing: Effective Treatment Options
Hello Doctor, I have confirmed that I have chronic pharyngitis (for about six years), gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD), and post-nasal drip, with the latter being more severe. Both of these issues are difficult to manage, and it seems that no doctor has mentioned a cure for...
Dr. Zheng Jueyi reply Otolaryngology
1. For long-term postnasal drip, it is recommended to seek medical evaluation to check for issues such as allergic rhinitis or sinusitis. Most cases can be managed with medication to control symptoms, but a complete cure may not be possible. Some patients may also need to use sal...[Read More] Chronic Pharyngitis and Coughing: Effective Treatment Options
Understanding Chronic Intermittent Cough: Causes and Treatment Options
Hello, Dr. Zhou. I have been experiencing intermittent coughing for a year. I always feel like I can't clear my left lung, and my left throat is itchy. Whenever it itches, I feel the urge to cough. Occasionally, I have some clear phlegm, which is slightly more at night. I ha...
Dr. Zhou Ziguang reply Pulmonology
Hello: 1. There are many causes of chronic cough. In addition to issues related to the lungs and bronchitis, it may also be due to post-nasal drip, gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD), asthma, and other possibilities that require further differential diagnosis. 2. For the pulm...[Read More] Understanding Chronic Intermittent Cough: Causes and Treatment Options
Chronic Cough: Understanding Symptoms and Seeking Effective Treatment
Hello Dr. Yang, I've been very busy with school lately, and my persistent cough has severely affected my daily routine and academic performance. It took me a while to find time to read your response. My chest X-ray in previous years was normal, but I haven't had one th...
Dr. Yang Wenda reply Pulmonology
Hello: I understand your current concerns, and here is a brief response: 1. Please consider having another chest X-ray. If the physician agrees, arrange for pulmonary function tests to clarify the causes of any lung parenchymal disease and ventilation impairment. 2. A regular ...[Read More] Chronic Cough: Understanding Symptoms and Seeking Effective Treatment
Related FAQ
(Pulmonology)
Cough(Pulmonology)
Wheezing, Coughing(Pulmonology)
Cough(Otolaryngology)
Cough(Internal Medicine)
Cold Medicine(Pulmonology)
Throat Itching(Pulmonology)
Aspiration Pneumonia(Pulmonology)
Bronchiectasis(Pulmonology)
Phlegm(Otolaryngology)