Second Metatarsal Fractures and Treatment Options - Orthopedics

Share to:

Second metatarsal fracture


Hello Doctor, I am a male who loves strength training.
On April 22, I had an accident on my way to practice, where my left foot was trapped under the front wheel of a car for over 20 seconds before I was able to pull it out.
After an emergency examination, the X-ray showed that I have a fracture of the second metatarsal.
I was placed in a long leg cast at that time.
Subsequently, I visited three orthopedic clinics.

The first clinic reviewed the X-ray taken in the emergency room and said it was not serious, indicating only a metatarsal fracture without displacement, and that I could follow up in two weeks.
The second clinic examined the appearance of my foot and the X-ray and advised me to be cautious of a Lisfranc injury.
After researching, I realized it could be serious, and they referred me to a larger hospital for a CT scan.
The third clinic mentioned that there was only a small fracture and that the likelihood of a Lisfranc injury was low.
They provided me with two options: Case 1, surgery to place a plate (which would allow me to walk normally in 2 weeks), or Case 2, non-surgical treatment with a cast but requiring shockwave therapy (which would allow me to walk normally in 2-3 months).
Regarding the X-ray, I would like to ask:
1.
What is your diagnosis of the X-ray and your opinion on the possibility of a Lisfranc injury?
2.
If I choose not to have surgery, what is the likelihood of long-term complications if I return to training after six months?
3.
If I prefer not to have surgery, can I start shockwave therapy now?
I look forward to your response.
Thank you.

Jiao Ge, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2022/05/06

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics


Based on the assessment of several physicians, it appears that there is no serious fracture as you described.
A cast immobilization is sufficient, and currently, there is no need for shockwave therapy.
The fracture is expected to heal in approximately six to eight weeks.
Typically, metatarsal fractures do not result in significant long-term complications.

Reply Date: 2022/05/06

More Info


Understanding second metatarsal fractures, particularly in the context of a Lisfranc injury, is crucial for effective treatment and recovery, especially for someone who is active in strength training like yourself.
1. Diagnosis and Lisfranc Injury: The X-ray findings you mentioned indicate a fracture of the second metatarsal. While it’s reassuring that the initial assessment suggested it was just a fracture and not a complete break, the concern for a Lisfranc injury is valid. A Lisfranc injury involves damage to the tarsometatarsal joints, which can occur with significant trauma, such as being run over by a vehicle. The fact that you were under pressure for an extended period raises the risk of such an injury. It’s essential to have a thorough evaluation, possibly including a CT scan, to assess the alignment of the bones and the integrity of the ligaments in that area. If there is any displacement or instability, surgical intervention may be necessary to prevent long-term complications.

2. Long-term Consequences of Non-surgical Treatment: If you opt for conservative management with a cast and do not undergo surgery, there is a risk of complications. These can include chronic pain, instability, or even arthritis in the affected joint due to improper healing or misalignment. The likelihood of these issues increases if the fracture does not heal correctly or if there is an undiagnosed Lisfranc injury. Returning to strength training after six months without surgical intervention may lead to limitations in performance or persistent discomfort, particularly if the fracture has not healed optimally.

3. Shockwave Therapy: Shockwave therapy can be beneficial for promoting healing in certain types of fractures and may be initiated as soon as the fracture is stable and the cast is in place. However, it is essential to consult with your orthopedic specialist before starting this treatment. They can provide guidance on the timing and appropriateness of shockwave therapy based on your specific injury and overall healing progress.
In summary, the decision between surgical and non-surgical treatment should be made after careful consideration of the fracture's nature, the potential for complications, and your personal goals for recovery. If surgery is recommended, it is typically to ensure proper alignment and stability, which can significantly reduce the risk of long-term issues. If you choose conservative treatment, close monitoring and follow-up imaging will be crucial to ensure that the fracture heals correctly and to address any complications that may arise.
Additionally, engaging in rehabilitation exercises, once cleared by your physician, will be vital for restoring strength and function to your foot. This may include range-of-motion exercises, strengthening exercises for the foot and ankle, and eventually, progressive loading to prepare for a return to your strength training routine. Always follow your healthcare provider's recommendations and listen to your body throughout the recovery process.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Second Metatarsal Fractures: Recovery Tips and Support Options

I would like to ask about a fracture of the second metatarsal in my left foot. I had a cast applied on June 25, and it was removed on July 3. The doctor only advised me to walk on my heel and did not mention the need for a brace. However, after researching, I found that most peop...


Dr. Wang Jiacheng reply Orthopedics
It is advisable for you to discuss the above situation further with your attending physician. Thank you, and wishing you good health!

[Read More] Understanding Second Metatarsal Fractures: Recovery Tips and Support Options


Managing Nonunion in Metatarsal Fractures: Treatment Options Explained

Hello, doctor. I suffered a fracture of the second, third, and fourth metatarsals in a car accident at the end of June. The doctor recommended surgery, so I opted for a procedure involving micro screws at my own expense. Now, three months have passed, and the second and fourth me...


Dr. Chen Bochen reply Orthopedics
Hello, I recommend that you consult a foot and ankle specialist. Some larger hospitals or medical centers have more specialized orthopedic departments, including foot and ankle specialists who handle more complex foot and ankle issues. It is advisable to seek care from these phys...

[Read More] Managing Nonunion in Metatarsal Fractures: Treatment Options Explained


Effective Rehabilitation Strategies for Fractured Metatarsals After an Accident

Since your accident at the end of this month, you have been experiencing soreness, tightness, and pain daily in your fractured second and fourth metatarsals. What rehabilitation should you pursue?


Dr. Zhou Jianwen reply Rehabilitation
First, confirm that the fracture site is properly stabilized before beginning rehabilitation.

[Read More] Effective Rehabilitation Strategies for Fractured Metatarsals After an Accident


Understanding Treatment Options for 2nd and 3rd Metatarsal Fractures

Hello, I have sustained fractures of the second and third metatarsals due to a car accident. The doctor mentioned that there is displacement and I have the option to continue with a cast, or to use screws or plates. The doctor indicated that not undergoing surgery with a cast mig...


Dr. Li Yongheng reply Orthopedics
Hello, generally speaking, for displaced fractures of the second and third metatarsals, you can choose to continue with casting, or use screws or plates. The outcomes and recovery speeds of these three methods are quite similar. Personally, I would recommend against surgery. If y...

[Read More] Understanding Treatment Options for 2nd and 3rd Metatarsal Fractures


Related FAQ

Second Metatarsal Fracture

(Orthopedics)

Metatarsal Fracture

(Orthopedics)

Fifth Metatarsal Fracture

(Orthopedics)

Fifth Metatarsal

(Orthopedics)

Post-Tibial Fracture Surgery

(Orthopedics)

Bunion

(Orthopedics)

Hallux Varus

(Orthopedics)

Tibia And Fibula Fracture

(Orthopedics)

Plantar Fasciitis

(Orthopedics)

Post-Fracture Rehabilitation

(Orthopedics)