False Positives in Military HIV Testing: Key Insights - Internal Medicine

Share to:

Military service medical examination issues?


Hello doctor, I underwent a military physical examination in December, and a month later I was informed that I tested positive for HIV.
In January, I immediately purchased an at-home rapid HIV test, which returned a negative result.
I would like to know how common false positive results are, as the nurse who informed me mentioned that false positives can frequently occur in military physical exams.
Additionally, I have never engaged in unprotected sexual intercourse, but I still feel uneasy.
I would also like to ask if stress and irregular sleep patterns can influence the occurrence of false positives.
Thank you!

S, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2023/01/31

Dr. Hong Yuanbin reply Internal Medicine


Hello, it is recommended to visit the infectious disease outpatient department at a medical center for a Combo test or Western blot test to confirm whether there is an actual infection.
As for your daily routine, it should not significantly affect the test results.
Thank you for your inquiry.

Reply Date: 2023/01/31

More Info


Understanding false positives in HIV testing, particularly in the context of military service examinations, is crucial for individuals who may find themselves in similar situations. False positives can occur for various reasons, and it's essential to understand the factors that contribute to them, as well as the implications for your health and well-being.

Firstly, it's important to recognize that HIV testing typically involves two stages: initial screening tests (such as ELISA or rapid tests) and confirmatory tests (like the Western blot or HIV RNA tests). The initial screening tests are designed to detect antibodies or antigens related to HIV. However, these tests are not perfect and can yield false positive results due to cross-reactivity with other proteins or conditions. For instance, certain autoimmune diseases, recent vaccinations, or even pregnancy can lead to a false positive result.

In military settings, where large groups of individuals are tested, the prevalence of HIV is generally low. This low prevalence can increase the likelihood of false positives, as the positive predictive value of a test decreases when the actual prevalence of the disease is low. This means that even if a test indicates a positive result, the probability of it being a true positive diminishes when the disease is rare in the tested population.

Regarding your specific situation, the fact that you received a positive result during the military examination but subsequently tested negative with a self-test is concerning and warrants further investigation. Self-testing kits can vary in accuracy, and while many are reliable, they are not a substitute for professional medical testing. The best course of action would be to follow up with a healthcare provider and request a confirmatory test, such as a Western blot or an HIV RNA test, which are more definitive.

As for the impact of stress and lifestyle factors on HIV testing results, while they do not directly cause false positives, they can affect your overall health and immune system. High levels of stress can lead to various physiological changes in the body, which may indirectly influence the immune response. However, the direct correlation between stress and false positive HIV results is not well-established in medical literature. It is always advisable to maintain a balanced lifestyle, manage stress effectively, and ensure adequate sleep, as these factors contribute to overall health and well-being.

In summary, false positives in HIV testing can occur due to a variety of factors, including the testing method used, the prevalence of HIV in the population being tested, and individual health conditions. If you have received conflicting test results, it is crucial to seek further testing from a healthcare professional to clarify your status. Remember, early detection and treatment are vital for managing HIV effectively, should it be present. Always consult with a healthcare provider for personalized advice and testing options.

Similar Q&A

Understanding HIV Testing: Risks of Infection After Mixed Test Results

I was a woman, and a few days ago I had an encounter with a man. Later, during our conversation, he mentioned that he tested positive for HIV during his military service, but subsequent tests came back negative. After a few years, he tested positive again on the first test, but t...


Dr. Liao Zhongxin reply Internal Medicine
Dear readers: Regarding the previous case of testing positive for HIV during military service, the response is as follows: 1. HIV testing is conducted in two stages: first is the ELISA test, and second is the Western blot test. 2. The former is a screening method that measures...

[Read More] Understanding HIV Testing: Risks of Infection After Mixed Test Results


Understanding HIV Testing: False Positives and Antigen/Antibody Concerns

About five years ago, I engaged in unprotected vaginal and oral intercourse with an online acquaintance, which were high-risk behaviors. I have since undergone RT-PCR and military physical examinations, both of which were negative (I have not engaged in any high-risk behaviors si...


Dr. Du Shixi reply Urology
Hello: In your situation, even if it is a false positive, you must have a blood test for confirmation. Please seek medical attention. Wishing you good health.

[Read More] Understanding HIV Testing: False Positives and Antigen/Antibody Concerns


Understanding Military Health Exams: Accuracy of STD Testing Explained

Hello doctor, I had sexual intercourse with someone around August and September of last year. I didn't have time to get a check-up and blood tests until I underwent a military physical examination in February and March of this year. The results showed negative for HIV and sy...


Dr. Liao Yaopan reply Family Medicine
The currently used screening tools have a high accuracy rate, but it is important to understand the concept of the window period. It is recommended to conduct regular follow-ups. Of course, practicing safe behaviors remains the most important!

[Read More] Understanding Military Health Exams: Accuracy of STD Testing Explained


Understanding HIV: Transmission, Testing, and Military Service Eligibility

Infection with HIV does not necessarily mean that one will develop AIDS. Before the onset of symptoms, it is possible to transmit the virus to others. Blood tests are used to determine whether a person is infected with HIV, not whether they have progressed to AIDS. Individuals wh...


Dr. Liu Jianting reply Urology
What should I do? Are you worried about your boyfriend? In individuals infected with HIV, antibodies can be found in their blood. However, there is a window period during the early stages of infection. I recommend visiting the website of the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) or o...

[Read More] Understanding HIV: Transmission, Testing, and Military Service Eligibility


Related FAQ

Hiv Test

(Internal Medicine)

Hiv Screening

(Internal Medicine)

Hiv

(Internal Medicine)

Hiv Transmission

(Internal Medicine)

Std Screening

(Internal Medicine)

Syphilis

(Internal Medicine)

Hiv

(Family Medicine)

Needlestick

(Internal Medicine)

Hiv Screening

(Urology)

Covid-19 Diagnosis

(Internal Medicine)