Standard for Weight Loss
Hello Doctor, I have found many different standards online regarding weight fluctuations, and I would like to ask you what is considered normal for daily or monthly weight changes.
The information I found states that a decrease of 5% within a month is abnormal, but since my weight is around 39 kilograms, 5% is less than 2 kilograms.
I also read that a daily weight difference of 1 to 2 kilograms can be normal.
If I weigh myself in the morning before breakfast (when I am lightest) and after dinner (when I am heaviest), and the maximum difference I observe over a week between these two times is 1.8 kilograms (not on the same day), is this considered normal? Or could there be any underlying health issues? I had a gastroscopy at the end of last year, which showed some inflammation in my gastrointestinal tract and gastroesophageal reflux.
I had blood tests around November, and my thyroid levels and blood sugar were normal.
Could thyroid levels fluctuate significantly in a short period? I do have some symptoms of mild hyperthyroidism, but my blood test results were normal.
Could this be related to anxiety or other neurological disorders?
JJ, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2023/03/28
Dr. Liao Yaopan reply Family Medicine
Hello, significant weight loss should indeed be taken seriously.
Minor fluctuations in weight throughout the day are acceptable, but if the overall average weight trend shows a noticeable decline, it is important to investigate the cause.
It is advisable to first consult your family physician for an evaluation, and then consider a referral to a specialist based on the situation.
Online consultations are not equivalent to in-person medical visits and cannot provide diagnoses or treatment recommendations.
Changhua Hospital cares about your well-being.
Reply Date: 2023/03/28
More Info
Understanding normal weight fluctuations is essential for maintaining a healthy lifestyle, especially when considering factors such as diet, exercise, and overall health. Weight can fluctuate daily due to various reasons, including water retention, food intake, and even hormonal changes.
Typically, a daily weight fluctuation of 1 to 2 pounds (approximately 0.5 to 1 kilogram) is considered normal for most individuals. This variation can be attributed to factors like hydration levels, the amount of food consumed, and the timing of meals. For instance, weighing yourself in the morning before breakfast usually yields the lowest weight of the day, while weighing yourself after dinner may show a higher weight due to food and fluid intake.
In your case, a weekly weight difference of 1.8 kilograms (approximately 4 pounds) between your lightest and heaviest measurements is within the normal range, especially considering that these measurements were taken at different times. It’s important to note that weight should not be the sole indicator of health; other factors such as body composition, muscle mass, and overall well-being are equally important.
Regarding your concern about weight loss, a decrease of 5% of body weight in a month can be a red flag, especially if it occurs without intentional changes in diet or exercise. However, since your weight is around 39 kilograms, a 5% loss would be less than 2 kilograms, which is a relatively small amount. If you are experiencing unintentional weight loss, it is advisable to consult a healthcare professional to rule out any underlying health issues.
You mentioned having undergone a gastroscopy that revealed mild inflammation and gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD). These conditions can affect your appetite and eating habits, potentially leading to weight fluctuations. If you are experiencing symptoms such as difficulty swallowing or changes in appetite, it is essential to follow up with your healthcare provider for further evaluation and management.
As for your thyroid function, while your blood tests indicated normal thyroid levels, it is possible for thyroid hormone levels to fluctuate slightly over time. Symptoms of hyperthyroidism, such as increased heart rate, anxiety, and weight changes, can sometimes occur even when blood tests are within the normal range. Stress and anxiety can also mimic or exacerbate these symptoms, leading to feelings of restlessness or nervousness. If you suspect that your symptoms may be related to thyroid function or anxiety, it would be beneficial to discuss these concerns with your healthcare provider. They may recommend further testing or a referral to an endocrinologist or mental health professional.
In summary, daily and weekly weight fluctuations are normal and can be influenced by various factors. Monitoring your weight consistently at the same time each day can help you better understand your body’s patterns. If you have concerns about significant weight changes, gastrointestinal symptoms, or thyroid function, seeking medical advice is crucial for proper assessment and management. Maintaining a balanced diet, staying hydrated, and incorporating regular physical activity can also support your overall health and weight management goals.
Similar Q&A
Understanding Weight Fluctuations: When to Worry About Your Health
Hello Doctor, I have recently been controlling my diet and brisk walking for weight loss. I weigh myself approximately every 2-3 days. Last Thursday (9/14), I weighed 91.3 kg, and I didn't weigh myself on Friday, Saturday, or Sunday. Yesterday (9/18), I weighed 90 kg, and to...
Dr. Li Jian reply Internal Medicine
If there is a need for weight loss, it doesn't have to be rapid; losing weight gradually is more sustainable. Thank you for your inquiry.[Read More] Understanding Weight Fluctuations: When to Worry About Your Health
Understanding Weight Fluctuations: Stress, Metabolism, and Mental Health
I wonder if it's related to my personality, but whenever I experience high work stress, I have a strong urge to eat and find it hard to control my appetite. Last year, during the busy season (about 3 to 4 months), I gained 10 kilograms, but I managed to lose that weight agai...
Dr. Wang Fangli reply Internal Medicine
Hello, Miss: The principles of weight control are proper diet and appropriate exercise. In terms of diet, it is important to maintain nutritional balance and avoid high-sugar and high-fat foods. An ideal weight loss rate is about 2 kilograms per month, so losing 10 kilograms in t...[Read More] Understanding Weight Fluctuations: Stress, Metabolism, and Mental Health
Understanding Weight Fluctuations: Is Your Eating Pattern a Concern?
Hello~~ I would like to ask, a few days ago I suddenly ate a lot of food almost non-stop, and it was all high-calorie food. My height is 165 cm and my weight was around 44 kg, but it suddenly increased to 46 kg in just one day. I felt very guilty about it. As a result, I have bee...
Dr. Cai Xiuwen reply Nutrition
Hello! Sudden binge eating or loss of appetite can have a negative impact on health. It is advisable to maintain a balanced intake of food. Is there any stress that might be causing changes in your eating habits? It is recommended that you visit a hospital for a comprehensive che...[Read More] Understanding Weight Fluctuations: Is Your Eating Pattern a Concern?
Understanding Weight Fluctuations: Diet, Hydration, and Exercise Impact
Hello doctor, today I weighed myself and my weight has increased to 91.7 kg. I would like to ask if this could be due to factors such as diet, hydration, and exercise? Thank you for your response.
Dr. Lin Zhebin reply Family Medicine
Hello: Body weight can fluctuate frequently due to factors such as diet, water intake, sweating, and bowel and urinary movements. Therefore, it is recommended to measure your weight at a consistent time each day for comparison. The time that is usually least affected by other fac...[Read More] Understanding Weight Fluctuations: Diet, Hydration, and Exercise Impact
Related FAQ
(Family Medicine)
Obesity(Family Medicine)
Height(Family Medicine)
Blood Pressure(Family Medicine)
Body Temperature(Family Medicine)
Waist(Family Medicine)
Dizziness(Family Medicine)
Hyperlipidemia(Family Medicine)
Common Cold(Family Medicine)
Bowel Movements(Family Medicine)