Nerve Pain: Is It Related to Disc Herniation or High Arches? - Neurology

Share to:

Numbness in the right calf extending to the sole of the foot while standing?


Hello Doctor: I consulted you on April 27 regarding persistent numbness in my left third toe.
Later, in May, I underwent an MRI and was diagnosed with a herniated disc.
Since the diagnosis, I have been undergoing rehabilitation (about once a week from May to July, and about three times a week in August), but the discomfort in my left foot varies.
I now do stretching exercises and Pilates (to strengthen my core) daily, and when I stretch, the level of discomfort is somewhat reduced.
The rehabilitation physician mentioned that I have a high arch foot and recommended that I use orthotics (which I started using in May, but only wear when going out) and also suggested stretching my toes to see if it can alleviate the numbness.
I also noticed that whenever my left foot is not too sore, I experience numbness in varying areas of my right calf and sole; this does not occur when I wake up but starts after I begin walking.
If my left foot is very sore, I almost do not experience any numbness in my right calf.
I would like to know if this situation indicates a worsening of the herniated disc or if it is related to the high arch foot.
Additionally, should I avoid doing Pilates (core exercises) at this stage? Thank you for your assistance.

Ms. Li, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2023/09/02

Dr. Jiang Junyi reply Neurology


Hello Ms.
Li: You mentioned that "the left foot feels somewhat sore, while the right calf to the sole of the foot experiences intermittent numbness; this does not occur upon waking but starts after I begin walking.
If the left foot is very sore, there is almost no numbness in the right calf." High arches may cause nerve compression in the foot.
Lumbar nerve root compression could lead to numbness and tingling in the areas it innervates.
Typical symptoms of lumbar nerve root pathology include pain radiating from the buttocks down the leg, as well as numbness, tingling, and weakness in the toes.
Thank you for your inquiry, and feel free to discuss any related questions! Wishing you good health and peace.
Dr.
Jiang Junyi, Department of Internal Medicine, Taoyuan Hospital, cares about you.

Reply Date: 2023/09/02

More Info


Understanding nerve pain, particularly in relation to conditions like disc herniation and high arches, can be quite complex. Based on your description, it seems you are experiencing a combination of symptoms that could be influenced by both your diagnosed disc herniation and your high arches.


Disc Herniation and Nerve Pain
Disc herniation occurs when the inner gel-like core of a spinal disc bulges out through a tear in the outer layer. This can lead to compression of nearby nerves, resulting in pain, numbness, or weakness in the areas served by those nerves. In your case, the left foot's third toe experiencing persistent numbness could be a direct result of nerve compression due to the herniated disc, particularly if the herniation is affecting the nerve roots that innervate that part of your foot.


High Arches (Pes Cavus)
High arches, or pes cavus, can lead to a variety of foot problems, including pain and discomfort in the foot and lower leg. This condition can alter the way weight is distributed across the foot, potentially leading to increased strain on certain muscles and tendons. The symptoms you describe, such as the variability in numbness and pain between your left and right legs, could be exacerbated by the mechanics of high arches. When your foot structure is altered, it can lead to compensatory changes in posture and gait, which may further aggravate nerve pain or discomfort.


Interaction Between Conditions
The interplay between your disc herniation and high arches may be contributing to the symptoms you are experiencing. For instance, if your left foot is more affected by the herniation, you might unconsciously adjust your gait to relieve discomfort, which could lead to increased strain on your right leg and foot. This compensatory mechanism could explain why you experience numbness in your right calf and foot when your left foot is less painful.


Treatment Considerations
1. Physical Therapy: Continuing with physical therapy is crucial. It can help strengthen the muscles around your spine and improve your overall posture, which may alleviate some of the pressure on the affected nerves. Your therapist can also provide exercises tailored to your high arches to help improve foot mechanics.

2. Orthotics: Since you have high arches, custom orthotics can be beneficial. They can provide better arch support and help distribute pressure more evenly across your foot, potentially reducing discomfort and improving your gait.

3. Stretching and Core Exercises: Engaging in stretching exercises and core strengthening (like Pilates) is generally beneficial. However, if you find that certain movements exacerbate your symptoms, it may be wise to modify those exercises or consult with your physical therapist for alternatives.

4. Monitoring Symptoms: Keep track of your symptoms. If you notice a significant increase in pain or numbness, especially if it becomes more consistent or severe, it may warrant further evaluation by a healthcare professional. This could include imaging studies to assess the status of your disc herniation.

5. Consultation with Specialists: If your symptoms persist or worsen, consider consulting a neurologist or an orthopedic specialist who focuses on spine health. They can provide a more comprehensive evaluation and may suggest additional interventions, such as injections or, in some cases, surgical options if conservative treatments fail.


Conclusion
In summary, the relationship between your disc herniation and high arches is likely contributing to your symptoms. Continuing with physical therapy, using orthotics, and being mindful of your body mechanics will be essential in managing your condition. Always communicate openly with your healthcare providers about your symptoms and any changes you notice, as this will help them tailor the best treatment plan for you.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Back Pain: Is It Sciatica or Scoliosis-Related?

Doctor, my lower back hurts and the pain radiates down to my feet. I previously had an X-ray at the hospital, which showed that I have scoliosis. Could this be causing sciatica? The doctor mentioned something about nerve pain related to a herniated disc. What should I do? Also, r...


Dr. Chen Xianchang reply Rehabilitation
Hello, Miss: Thank you for your question. Here are my suggestions: 1. Generally speaking, pain radiating to the soles of the feet is caused by a herniated disc that compresses the sciatic nerve. 2. Sneezing and coughing can increase abdominal pressure, which may exacerbate a hern...

[Read More] Understanding Back Pain: Is It Sciatica or Scoliosis-Related?


Understanding My Symptoms: Seeking Answers for Nerve Pain Issues

Hello, doctor. Recently, I've been experiencing numbness or a prickling pain in my upper lower back when sitting down. My tailbone also hurts, and I feel numbness near my knees. However, these symptoms disappear when I stand up, walk around, or lie down. What could this pain...


Dr. Lan Shengxing reply Neurology
Dear Mr. Tsao, the symptoms you described should be considered as a potential issue with the lumbar nerve. The sciatica you mentioned seems less likely. I recommend that you visit a neurosurgery outpatient clinic. Best regards, Lan Shengxing.

[Read More] Understanding My Symptoms: Seeking Answers for Nerve Pain Issues


Understanding Coccydynia: Causes, Symptoms, and Treatment Options

I had an X-ray of my coccyx, and the bones are fine. However, I experience significant pain when I stand up while riding my motorcycle, and some chairs cause pain when I sit down and then stand up. This has been bothering me for a long time. I also feel a tingling sensation in my...


Dr. Jiang Junyi reply Neurology
Hello, Miss: You mentioned that "it hurts a lot when I stand up after riding a motorcycle, and some chairs also cause pain when I sit and then stand up." Your symptoms may indicate a potential issue with the sciatic nerve. Herniated discs are often caused by spinal dege...

[Read More] Understanding Coccydynia: Causes, Symptoms, and Treatment Options


Is My Discomfort Due to Herniated Discs? Seeking Answers for Neck and Limb Pain

Hello Dr. Pan: Initially, I experienced fatigue easily and often felt mentally unwell (about two or three years ago). Later, I began to have neck pain and continued to feel unwell (about two years ago). Since last year, I have been waking up in the morning with tingling in my fin...


Dr. Pan Yingda reply Rehabilitation
First, let's confirm some conditions: You have a medium build (not tall), are somewhat thin, have a hunched back, likely have significant myopia (or a large difference between your eyes), have poor dental health (do you have a full set of dentures?), experience periodic migr...

[Read More] Is My Discomfort Due to Herniated Discs? Seeking Answers for Neck and Limb Pain


Related FAQ

Foot Pain

(Neurology)

Muscle Pain

(Neurology)

Lower Back Pain

(Neurology)

Neck Pain

(Neurology)

Carpal Tunnel Syndrome

(Neurology)

Ulnar Nerve

(Neurology)

Shoulder Joint Pain

(Neurology)

Thigh Nerve Pain

(Neurosurgery)

Nerve Compression

(Neurology)

Herniated Disc

(Neurosurgery)