Should You See Urology or General Surgery for Circumcision?

Circumcision should be evaluated by a urologist or a surgeon. I encountered a urologist who referred me to a surgeon?

If I really need to see a surgeon, can I have surgery at a general surgery clinic? I was all prepared, and then suddenly this happened, sigh~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

juéde guàiguài de, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2004/01/16

Dr. Pan Zhenqin reply Urology

I also find it strange! Circumcision surgery is generally within the realm of urologists.
Of course, some surgical clinics may also offer this service.
Do you have any other issues besides the foreskin that the urologist suggested you consult a surgeon for first?

Reply Date: 2004/01/16

More Info

When considering circumcision, the choice between seeing a urologist or a general surgeon can depend on several factors, including the specific reasons for the procedure, the patient's medical history, and the complexity of the case.
Urology vs. General Surgery for Circumcision:
1. Urologist: Urologists specialize in the urinary tract and male reproductive organs. If the circumcision is being considered due to medical issues such as phimosis (where the foreskin cannot be easily retracted), recurrent infections, or other urological concerns, it is advisable to consult a urologist. They have specialized training in managing conditions related to the penis and foreskin, and they can provide a thorough evaluation and appropriate surgical intervention.

2. General Surgeon: General surgeons are trained to perform a wide range of surgical procedures, including circumcision. If the circumcision is elective or for non-medical reasons, such as cultural or religious practices, a general surgeon may be a suitable option. Many general surgery clinics can perform this procedure safely and effectively.

Considerations for Choosing a Surgeon:
- Experience and Specialization: Regardless of whether you choose a urologist or a general surgeon, it is essential to ensure that the surgeon has experience performing circumcisions. Ask about their training and how many procedures they have performed.

- Facility and Anesthesia: Consider where the procedure will be performed. Some general surgeons may perform circumcisions in an outpatient clinic, while others may do so in a hospital setting. Discuss the type of anesthesia that will be used (local or general) and the recovery process.

- Follow-Up Care: Post-operative care is crucial for a smooth recovery. Ensure that the surgeon provides clear instructions for post-operative care and is available for follow-up appointments if needed.

Can You Go to a General Surgery Clinic?
Yes, you can go to a general surgery clinic for circumcision, provided that the surgeon is qualified and experienced in performing the procedure. It is advisable to have a consultation beforehand to discuss your specific situation, any concerns you may have, and the expected outcomes of the surgery.

Pre-Operative Considerations:
- Medical History: Be prepared to discuss your medical history, including any medications you are taking, allergies, and previous surgeries. This information is vital for the surgeon to assess your overall health and any potential risks associated with the procedure.

- Informed Consent: Ensure that you understand the risks and benefits of circumcision. The surgeon should provide you with information about the procedure, potential complications, and what to expect during recovery.

Post-Operative Care and Recovery:
After circumcision, patients typically experience some swelling and discomfort, which can be managed with pain relief medications. It is essential to follow the surgeon's post-operative care instructions, which may include keeping the area clean, avoiding certain activities, and monitoring for any signs of infection.

In conclusion, whether you choose to see a urologist or a general surgeon for circumcision depends on your specific needs and circumstances. Both types of specialists can perform the procedure safely, but consulting with a healthcare provider will help you make an informed decision based on your individual situation. Always prioritize finding a qualified surgeon who can provide the care and expertise necessary for a successful outcome.

Similar Q&A

Choosing Between Circumcision and Foreskin Restoration: A Guide for Young Men

Hello, I am 20 years old, but I have been hesitant about whether to undergo circumcision or preputial restoration. From the information I've gathered, I understand that circumcision can leave unsightly scars and may involve prolonged pain. I've also seen the benefits of...

Dr. Li Xinyi reply Urology
There seems to be a concept known as "foreskin restoration" online, but there is no definitive literature to support it. In principle, I cannot provide recommendations on this matter. Personally, I do not believe in it, as the portion that is cut off has its blood suppl...

Should You Get Circumcision at a Major Hospital or a Local Clinic?

Hello Dr. Huang, I would like to ask whether circumcision should be performed in a large hospital's urology department or at a general urology clinic. Thank you.

Dr. Huang Chikai reply Urology
Hello, A-Tuo: Circumcision can be performed at major hospitals' urology departments or urology clinics. However, please make sure to confirm that the procedure is being done by a board-certified urologist. Wishing you health and happiness! Dr. Huang Chih-Kai, February 26, 20...

Understanding Circumcision: Key Considerations and Surgical Options

I would like to consult Dr. Liu Chien-Ting... I am considering a circumcision. What issues should I be aware of? Also, what are the surgical methods for circumcision? Which one is better? Thank you, Dr. Liu.

Dr. Liu Jianting reply Urology
It's best to consult a urologist to evaluate your condition before deciding whether to proceed with surgery.

Circumcision vs. Foreskin Restoration: Which is Better for You?

Hello, doctor... I've been troubled by phimosis for a long time... I would like to ask you, as I've found too much information online and it's hard to distinguish between what's true and what's not. Which treatment would be better? Thank you for your guid...

Dr. Xu Weikai reply Urology
Concern: Hello, we need to examine the type of foreskin to determine whether surgery is necessary. In fact, in most cases, circumcision is not required. If there are any unclear points, feel free to ask again, and we can discuss and research further. This response is from Dr. Hsu...