Complications and Recovery from Comminuted Knee Fractures

Q: Complications and Recovery from Comminuted Knee Fractures

Hello： 1. <br>Comminuted fractures around the joints are complex injuries, especially in the knee joint, which contains the anterior and posterior cruciate ligaments and the meniscus. <br>A comprehensive approach is necessary to achieve good outcomes. <br>2. <br>Generally, fractu

Comminuted fracture of the left knee joint?

Hello Dr.
Chou,
In early August 2003, I was involved in a car accident that resulted in a comminuted fracture of my left knee joint.
Since the treatment, I have experienced the following situations: (1) On August 6, I underwent surgery at Mackay Memorial Hospital for reconstruction of the knee joint and meniscus, during which three bone screws and two circular fixation rings were implanted, followed by a cast immobilization.
(2) I was discharged on August 11 and continued outpatient treatment.
(3) The cast was removed approximately 2-3 weeks later.
(4) About a week after the cast removal, I experienced pain due to the displacement of a bone screw that was in contact with the subcutaneous tissue.
The physician subsequently performed another surgery to remove this bone screw, but two weeks later, another bone screw exhibited the same issue.
During this consultation with an orthopedic surgeon at National Taiwan University, after reviewing the X-rays, the physician advised against removing the displaced bone screws, as the bone healing had not reached the necessary level.
He recommended taking another X-ray six months post-surgery to assess the healing progress and determine whether all fixation devices should be removed.
(5) What kind of sequelae might such patients experience, or is it possible to fully recover to the pre-injury normal condition? I would appreciate Dr.
Chou's insights or any additional recommendations.

Yang, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2004/01/24

Dr. Zhou Lizhi reply Orthopedics

Hello: 1.
Comminuted fractures around the joints are complex injuries, especially in the knee joint, which contains the anterior and posterior cruciate ligaments and the meniscus.
A comprehensive approach is necessary to achieve good outcomes.
2.
Generally, fractures take about three months to heal completely; however, fractures around the joints may lead to joint stiffness and difficulty in movement if immobilized for such a long period.
Therefore, the timing for the removal of some fixation devices should be based on the patient's recovery status.
3.
Common sequelae after knee joint fracture surgery often include limited joint mobility (inability to return to the pre-injury state) and post-traumatic arthritis.
Appropriate rehabilitation should be conducted based on the healing status of the fracture to achieve the maximum recovery and minimize the occurrence of sequelae.

Reply Date: 2004/01/24

More Info

In your case, the complications following a comminuted knee fracture, particularly after a traumatic event like a car accident, can be quite significant. Comminuted fractures, where the bone is shattered into several pieces, often require extensive surgical intervention and rehabilitation. The details you've provided indicate a complex recovery process, including multiple surgeries and the insertion of hardware to stabilize the knee joint.

Surgical Intervention and Complications
You underwent surgery shortly after your injury, which is standard practice for managing severe fractures. The use of bone screws and rings for stabilization is common, but as you've experienced, complications can arise. The migration of bone screws into the subcutaneous tissue can lead to pain and discomfort, necessitating further surgical intervention. This is not uncommon, especially in cases where the bone has not healed sufficiently to support the hardware.

The recommendation from your orthopedic surgeon to wait six months before reassessing the need for hardware removal is prudent. The healing process for bone can vary significantly among individuals, influenced by factors such as age, overall health, and the extent of the injury.

Potential Long-term Effects
As for the long-term effects of your injury, several complications can arise from comminuted knee fractures:
1. Chronic Pain: Many patients experience ongoing pain in the knee joint, which can be due to a variety of factors including hardware irritation, joint instability, or post-traumatic arthritis.

2. Range of Motion Limitations: After such significant trauma, regaining full range of motion can be challenging. Stiffness in the knee joint is a common complaint, and physical therapy is crucial in addressing this.

3. Muscle Atrophy: Due to immobilization and pain, muscle wasting can occur, particularly in the quadriceps and hamstrings. Rehabilitation focusing on strength training is essential to regain muscle mass and function.

4. Post-Traumatic Arthritis: The risk of developing arthritis in the knee joint increases after a fracture, especially if the joint surfaces were damaged. This can lead to long-term pain and functional limitations.

5. Instability: Depending on the extent of ligament damage during the injury, you may experience knee instability, which can affect your ability to perform certain activities.

Rehabilitation and Recovery
Your rehabilitation process will be critical in determining your long-term outcomes. Here are some recommendations:
- Physical Therapy: Engage in a structured physical therapy program focusing on range of motion, strength training, and proprioception exercises. This will help restore function and reduce the risk of future injuries.

- Regular Follow-ups: Keep up with your orthopedic appointments to monitor the healing process. X-rays will help assess whether the bone is healing adequately and if the hardware is still necessary.

- Pain Management: Discuss pain management strategies with your healthcare provider. This may include medications, physical therapy modalities (like ultrasound or electrical stimulation), and alternative therapies.

- Activity Modification: While you may want to return to your previous level of activity, it’s important to listen to your body and avoid high-impact activities until cleared by your physician.

- Supportive Devices: If you experience instability or pain, using a knee brace during activities may provide additional support.

Conclusion
In summary, while the road to recovery from a comminuted knee fracture can be long and fraught with challenges, many patients can achieve significant improvements with appropriate medical care and rehabilitation. It’s essential to maintain open communication with your healthcare team, adhere to rehabilitation protocols, and be patient with your recovery process. Each individual's healing journey is unique, and with time and effort, many can regain a functional and active lifestyle.

Similar Q&A

Post-Surgery Knee Pain: Understanding and Managing Discomfort After Patella Fracture

Hello, doctor. In mid-December last year, I suffered a comminuted fracture of the right patella due to a fall. The doctor treated it with two steel pins (which do not need to be removed) and artificial bone graft. It has been six months since the surgery, and there are no issues ...

Dr. Wang Shouji reply Orthopedics
Hello, a patellar fracture can cause direct pressure when kneeling, which will definitely result in pain that may persist for a long time. It is recommended to bend and straighten the knee as much as possible. If kneeling is necessary, use a soft cushion to avoid direct contact w...

Understanding Recovery from Comminuted and Open Fractures: What to Expect

I apologize, but I have suffered a comminuted and open fracture in my thigh and knee, and it has been exactly two months. The doctor said that I can start rehabilitation in another month. My parents are saying that I shouldn't have a job that requires standing for long perio...

Dr. Wang Shouji reply Orthopedics
Hello: The management of comminuted and open fractures depends on the presence of infection and the status of bone healing. Generally, if there is no infection and the fracture is healing well, with no severe damage to the joint, most patients can regain over 90% of their origina...

Recovery Timeline and Considerations for Patellar Fractures

I have a large open wound on my knee due to a car accident, and I have a comminuted fracture of the patella with one-third removed and two-thirds preserved without the use of steel pins. How long will it take for the bone to heal? How long will rehabilitation take? Will there be ...

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
The approximate healing time is three months, with rehabilitation lasting three to six months. There is a possibility of degenerative joint changes between the patella and femur in the future. Before complete healing, the knee joint should not be flexed excessively.

Understanding Knee Replacement Surgery: Costs and Recovery Insights

Dear Dr. Yang, On January 14, my mother was involved in a head-on collision with a drunk driver and was taken to Taichung Hospital's emergency department. The diagnosis included: left ulnar olecranon fracture and upper third fracture, left elbow joint open fracture-dislocat...

Dr. Yang Zhengfan reply Orthopedics
Dear Wan-Yi, your mother has sustained such severe injuries, and it is easy to imagine the force of the impact at the time of the injury. Strictly speaking, every injured area has the potential for complications. Of course, the severity of these complications is closely related t...