Do All Men Need Circumcision? Foreskin and Health - Urology

Share to:

Is circumcision necessary?


Is it necessary for all males to undergo circumcision? How can one determine if the foreskin is too long? Is it essential to retract the foreskin to expose the glans? What are the consequences if the foreskin is not retracted? I am very curious about these questions.

jeff, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2004/01/29

Dr. Lin Hexing reply Urology


Hello Jeff: Not all males need to undergo circumcision.
If the foreskin completely covers the glans when the penis is erect, it may be considered phimosis.
It is best to retract the foreskin to expose the glans for proper hygiene.
If the foreskin cannot be retracted at all, it indicates a phimosis issue, and a visit to a urologist is recommended to determine if circumcision is necessary.

Reply Date: 2004/01/29

More Info


Circumcision, or the surgical removal of the foreskin from the penis, is a topic that often generates a lot of discussion and debate. The decision to circumcise is influenced by various factors, including cultural, religious, and medical considerations. It is important to understand that not all men need circumcision, and the necessity of the procedure can vary significantly from person to person.


Understanding Foreskin and Its Function
The foreskin is a fold of skin that covers the glans (the head) of the penis. It serves several functions, including protecting the sensitive glans, maintaining moisture, and providing sensory stimulation. In infants and young boys, the foreskin is often adhered to the glans, which can make it difficult to retract. As boys grow, the foreskin typically becomes more mobile and can be retracted without discomfort.


When Is Circumcision Recommended?
Circumcision may be recommended in certain medical situations, such as:
1. Phimosis: This condition occurs when the foreskin cannot be retracted over the glans. If it causes pain, difficulty with urination, or recurrent infections, circumcision may be considered.

2. Paraphimosis: This is a more serious condition where the retracted foreskin cannot be returned to its normal position, leading to swelling and pain. This situation often requires immediate medical attention.

3. Recurrent Infections: Some men may experience frequent urinary tract infections or balanitis (inflammation of the glans) that may be alleviated by circumcision.

4. Hygiene Issues: In some cases, men may find it difficult to maintain proper hygiene due to a tight or long foreskin, leading to a buildup of smegma (a combination of dead skin cells and oils).


What Constitutes a Long Foreskin?
A "long" foreskin is somewhat subjective and can vary from individual to individual. Generally, if the foreskin covers the glans and cannot be retracted easily, it may be considered long. However, the length of the foreskin does not necessarily indicate a need for circumcision unless it leads to medical issues.


Do All Men Need to Expose the Glans?
It is not necessary for all men to retract their foreskin to expose the glans. In fact, many men retain their foreskin without any issues. The decision to retract the foreskin should be based on comfort and hygiene practices. If a man can maintain good hygiene without retracting the foreskin, there may be no need to do so.


Potential Consequences of Not Retracting the Foreskin
If the foreskin is not retracted, it can lead to a few potential issues:
- Hygiene Problems: If the foreskin is not cleaned properly, it can lead to the accumulation of smegma, which may cause irritation or infection.

- Infections: In some cases, a non-retractable foreskin can increase the risk of urinary tract infections or balanitis.

- Psychological Factors: Some men may feel self-conscious about their foreskin, especially if they are in cultures where circumcision is the norm.


Conclusion
In summary, circumcision is not a requirement for all men. The decision to circumcise should be based on individual medical needs, cultural beliefs, and personal preferences. If there are concerns about the foreskin, such as difficulty with retraction or recurrent infections, it is advisable to consult a healthcare professional for a thorough evaluation and personalized recommendations. Ultimately, maintaining good hygiene and addressing any medical issues as they arise is crucial for overall penile health.

Similar Q&A

Should You Circumcise? Understanding the Pros and Cons for Men's Health

Hello, Dr. Hsu. My foreskin is quite loose and can be easily retracted. I clean it daily during my shower, but I’ve noticed that when I pull the foreskin back to expose the glans and maintain that position, it becomes very painful during an erection, as if the glans is being stre...


Dr. Xu Weikai reply Urology
Hello, not all males necessarily need to undergo circumcision. In your case, it seems that surgery may not be required unless there is phimosis, difficulty in cleaning, or the presence of lumps or fibrosis; these conditions would warrant consideration for surgery. In most other c...

[Read More] Should You Circumcise? Understanding the Pros and Cons for Men's Health


Should I Get Circumcised? Understanding the Myths and Facts

Hello, Dr. Hsu: I would like to undergo a circumcision, but the doctor told me that it is unnecessary because my foreskin normally covers the penis, and I need to retract it during an erection to expose the glans. I consulted the doctor, and he said circumcision is not needed. Ho...


Dr. Xu Weikai reply Urology
Hello, first of all, let me clarify a concept: circumcision and local odor are two different matters. In other words, if proper hygiene is not maintained, there will still be odor even after circumcision. Regarding the timing for circumcision, generally, there are only a few situ...

[Read More] Should I Get Circumcised? Understanding the Myths and Facts


Do You Really Need a Circumcision? Understanding Phimosis at 17

Is it necessary for everyone to undergo circumcision? I am seventeen and still have phimosis; what will happen if I don't get circumcised? Why do some people get circumcised as children while others do not? Who makes that decision?


Dr. Chen Zhihong reply Urology
1. Not everyone needs to undergo circumcision; typically, there are two conditions that warrant the procedure: one is complete phimosis (where the foreskin completely covers the glans and cannot be retracted even with manual manipulation), and the other is recurrent balanitis. ...

[Read More] Do You Really Need a Circumcision? Understanding Phimosis at 17


To Circumcise or Not: Addressing Concerns About Foreskin Issues

Hello doctor, I have a problem with phimosis, but I can push it back to expose the entire glans; during erection, I can also fully retract it to reveal the glans. I always use body wash to clean the glans while showering. Is there still a need for circumcision? Some people say th...


Dr. Xu Weikai reply Urology
Hesitation: Hello, it seems that your condition may not require a circumcision. However, a professional evaluation is necessary to confirm this. If there are any unclear aspects, feel free to ask again, and we can discuss and research further. Online responses can only serve as a...

[Read More] To Circumcise or Not: Addressing Concerns About Foreskin Issues


Related FAQ

Circumcision

(Urology)

Foreskin

(Urology)

Post-Circumcision

(Urology)

Genitals

(Urology)

Post-Vasectomy

(Urology)

Foreskin

(Dermatology)

Frenulum Of The Foreskin

(Urology)

Wound

(Urology)

Health Check-Up

(Urology)

Epididymis

(Urology)