Spontaneous vs. Traumatic Pneumothorax: Key Differences Explained

The definitions of spontaneous pneumothorax and traumatic pneumothorax are as follows: Spontaneous pneumothorax refers to the accumulation of air in the pleural space without any obvious external cause, often occurring in otherwise healthy individuals, typically due to the rupture of small blebs on the

Hello, Doctor.
I would like to ask you two questions.
The first pneumothorax occurred in the afternoon after I was playing with classmates and got bumped in the lower back, which caused pain in that area.
That evening, I went to the hospital and was diagnosed with a pneumothorax and received oxygen therapy.
However, the diagnosis did not specify whether it was spontaneous or traumatic.
Could you please clarify what type of pneumothorax this situation would be classified as?
The second pneumothorax occurred the following year, and there was no external force involved at the time.
This time, I underwent minimally invasive surgery to remove three blebs from the right upper lobe of the lung, and there was a small amount of fibrosis near the blebs.
I would like to ask if this situation would be considered a recurrence of traumatic pneumothorax or if it falls under spontaneous pneumothorax? Is the fibrosis a result of the initial impact to my lower back?
Thank you for your assistance with these questions, and I wish you a pleasant day.

charlie, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2023/11/26

Dr. Shen Bochan reply Pulmonology

Hello, based on your description, in the case of the first pneumothorax, if there was no external object piercing the alveoli, the cause of the pneumothorax would likely be due to pre-existing unhealthy alveoli.
A sudden impact could cause uneven stress on the surface of the alveoli, leading to rupture.
To explain this with a tire analogy, if the surface is uneven and the tire pressure is insufficient, it can lead to a blowout; thus, there is no need to specifically categorize it as spontaneous or traumatic.

In the case of the second pneumothorax, given the prior history of pneumothorax and the absence of significant external force, it would generally be classified as a spontaneous pneumothorax.
Alveoli do not rupture without reason; there is always an underlying cause, which could be coughing, turning over, compression, friction, surface tension, infection, or inflammation.
In summary, the unhealthier the alveoli are, the higher the likelihood of rupture leading to pneumothorax.
Therefore, it is not necessary to overly focus on whether it is spontaneous or traumatic.
Additionally, regarding the fibrosis aspect, a CT scan is needed to determine potential causality, and generally, it does not significantly impact lung function or health.

Reply Date: 2023/11/26

More Info

Understanding the differences between spontaneous and traumatic pneumothorax is crucial for accurate diagnosis and treatment. Pneumothorax occurs when air enters the pleural space, leading to lung collapse. It can be classified into two main types: spontaneous pneumothorax and traumatic pneumothorax.

Spontaneous Pneumothorax occurs without any external injury or trauma. It can be primary, often seen in young, tall males without any underlying lung disease, or secondary, which occurs in individuals with pre-existing lung conditions such as COPD, asthma, or cystic fibrosis. The air enters the pleural space due to the rupture of blebs or weak areas in the lung tissue.

Traumatic Pneumothorax, on the other hand, results from an external force or injury to the chest, such as a blunt force trauma (like being hit or falling) or penetrating injuries (like stab wounds or gunshot wounds). In your case, the first pneumothorax occurred after being struck in the back, which suggests that it is likely a traumatic pneumothorax. The absence of a clear indication in the diagnosis report does not negate the fact that the injury was a contributing factor.

Regarding your second pneumothorax, which occurred without any external force, it is classified as spontaneous. The fact that you underwent surgery to remove air-filled blebs (or bullae) from the lung indicates that this was a recurrent issue, likely related to the structural changes in your lung tissue. The presence of fibrosis near the bullae could suggest that there was some degree of lung damage or scarring, which may have been a consequence of the initial trauma or could be due to other factors such as smoking or underlying lung disease.

To address your question about whether the fibrosis is a result of the initial injury, it is possible. Trauma can lead to inflammation and subsequent scarring in the lung tissue, but fibrosis can also develop independently due to various other factors. It would be essential to discuss your medical history and any other symptoms with your healthcare provider to determine the exact cause of the fibrosis.

In summary, your first pneumothorax is likely traumatic due to the incident involving external force, while the second is spontaneous as it occurred without any direct trauma. The fibrosis observed may be related to the initial injury, but further evaluation would be necessary to establish a definitive link. Regular follow-ups with your healthcare provider are crucial to monitor your lung health and manage any potential complications.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Pneumothorax: Recovery, Risks, and Travel Considerations

Hello Doctor: I was in a car accident on October 20th, and it seems that the airbag deployed and impacted my chest, leading to a pneumothorax and collapse of my left lung. I was taken to the emergency room, where they performed intubation and drainage, but I believe no surgery wa...

Dr. Yang Wenda reply Pulmonology
Hello: 1. Your condition is post-traumatic pneumothorax combined with hemothorax, not spontaneous pneumothorax. Unless your CT scan shows abnormal dilated alveoli (bullae) in the normal lung areas, it cannot be assumed that you have a chance of developing spontaneous pneumothorax...

Understanding Spontaneous Pneumothorax: Causes, Symptoms, and Treatment

Hello, doctor. I am a high school student experiencing left-sided chest pain. The hospital examination revealed a pneumothorax, with a chest X-ray showing normal findings but a 2 cm area compressing the lung by 3.5 cm. The doctor recommended a drainage procedure to remove the gas...

Dr. Yang Wenda reply Pulmonology
Hello: First, alleviate the symptoms (oxygen therapy or chest tube drainage). Follow up with X-rays; if there is no absorption or improvement after two weeks, consider surgery. A chest CT scan can also be referenced. If there are still other subpleural blebs in the lungs (unruptu...

Understanding Spontaneous Pneumothorax and Mitral Valve Prolapse Connections

Dear Doctor: In the past, I was hospitalized for spontaneous pneumothorax and underwent tube thoracostomy. Two years later, during treatment for a recurrence, the physician used a syringe for drainage. I would like to ask: 1. Is there a relationship between spontaneous pneumothor...

Dr. Lin Liangyu reply Cardiology
Hello: In response to your questions: 1. The correlation between the two conditions is not very strong; however, both are commonly seen in tall, slender patients, which suggests a possible issue with connective tissue. 2. Theoretically, using a fine needle for drainage should cau...

Understanding Pneumothorax: Diagnosis, Treatment, and Military Service Implications

Seven years ago, I went to the emergency department of National Taiwan University Hospital due to a pneumothorax. After several days of oxygen therapy and X-ray examinations, I was discharged in stable condition. The hospital issued a diagnosis certificate for bilateral spontaneo...

Dr. Yang Wenda reply Pulmonology
In my personal opinion, I would like to respond as follows: 1. For recurrent pneumothorax with abnormal air bubble expansion visible on CT scans, surgical treatment is recommended. 2. Regarding the second question, I cannot speak on behalf of Tri-Service General Hospital and the ...