Bone Grafting vs. Bone Cement: Which is Best After Screw Removal?

Bone grafting and bone cement?

I am a scoliosis patient who had surgery eight years ago and I am considering having the screws removed.
I would like to ask about the differences between bone grafting and using bone cement for filling the void left after the screws are removed, as some doctors recommend one while others suggest the other.

mm, 40~49 year old female. Ask Date: 2024/01/12

Dr. Chen Yongxue reply Orthopedics

Hello, actually, there is no need for additional filler material after the removal of the metal pins.
Thank you.

Reply Date: 2024/01/12

More Info

When considering the options of bone grafting versus bone cement after the removal of screws, it's essential to understand the context of your specific situation, particularly after a long-term recovery from scoliosis surgery. Both methods serve different purposes and have distinct advantages and disadvantages.

Bone Grafting involves taking bone tissue from another part of your body (autograft), from a donor (allograft), or using synthetic materials (synthetic graft). The primary goal of bone grafting is to promote new bone growth in the area where the screw was removed. This method is particularly beneficial if there is a significant void or defect in the bone, as it encourages the body to regenerate bone tissue over time. The graft acts as a scaffold, allowing new bone cells to grow and fill in the area.
Advantages of Bone Grafting:
1. Natural Healing: Bone grafts can stimulate natural bone healing and regeneration.

2. Long-term Stability: Over time, the graft can integrate with the existing bone, providing a stable and durable solution.

3. Potential for Full Recovery: If successful, bone grafting can restore the bone's strength and functionality.

Disadvantages of Bone Grafting:
1. Surgical Risks: Harvesting bone from another site can lead to additional pain, complications, and longer recovery times.

2. Variable Success Rates: The success of bone grafting can depend on various factors, including the patient's overall health and the quality of the graft material.

Bone Cement, on the other hand, is a synthetic material (often polymethylmethacrylate, or PMMA) that is used to fill in bone voids. It hardens quickly and provides immediate structural support. However, it does not promote new bone growth in the same way that grafting does.

Advantages of Bone Cement:
1. Quick Application: It can be applied quickly and provides immediate stability to the area.

2. Less Invasive: There is no need for harvesting bone from another site, which reduces surgical risks and recovery time.

3. Effective for Small Defects: It can be particularly useful for small voids or defects where immediate support is needed.

Disadvantages of Bone Cement:
1. No Biological Healing: Unlike bone grafts, bone cement does not promote new bone formation. Over time, the cement may not integrate with the surrounding bone, potentially leading to complications.

2. Potential for Fracture: In some cases, the surrounding bone may weaken over time, leading to a higher risk of fracture.

In your case, the choice between bone grafting and bone cement should be made based on several factors, including the size of the void left after screw removal, your overall health, and your surgeon's experience and preference. If the area is large and requires biological healing, bone grafting may be the better option. Conversely, if the void is small and immediate stability is the priority, bone cement might suffice.

Ultimately, it's crucial to have a detailed discussion with your orthopedic surgeon about the specific characteristics of your bone defect, the potential risks and benefits of each option, and what would be the best approach for your long-term recovery and mobility. They can provide personalized recommendations based on your unique situation and help you make an informed decision.

Similar Q&A

Understanding the Differences Between Bone Screws and Bone Cement in Orthopedics

Hello: My mother fell while pulling her scooter when the handlebar came off, and she sat down on the ground. She was taken to the emergency room for an X-ray, where the medical staff advised that she could rest for a while and then get up to walk, allowing her to be discharged. L...

Dr. Chen Yongxue reply Orthopedics
Hello, as mentioned in your letter, it is generally a compression fracture (without neurological damage aside from pain). Conservative treatment (using a Taylor brace) has a success rate of about 80%, but it cannot restore the height of the vertebral body. If the pain persists fo...

Managing Complications After Humerus Fracture Surgery: What You Need to Know

Previously, I had a sports accident that resulted in a humeral fracture. After examination at the hospital, it was discovered to be a pathological fracture. The doctor recommended surgery to remove the damaged area and to use a plate for fixation with artificial bone. Initially, ...

Dr. Li Yongheng reply Orthopedics
1. Pathological fractures in young individuals are uncommon, so it is essential to rule out the possibility of malignant bone tumors first. 2. If a wound suddenly opens and continues to exude tissue fluid, it could indicate an infection or a rejection of the artificial bone. Th...

Should You Remove Titanium Screws After Fifth Metatarsal Fracture?

The recommendation for removal is based on the fact that the patient would have to live with the bone screws and plates for the next 50-60 years, which could introduce additional uncertainties. Since the lower extremities bear significant weight, there is a possibility of develop...

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
1. It is possible. 2. There is no increased risk of fractures because continued walking makes it less likely to develop osteoporosis. There may be temporary cavities, but over time, the bone will regenerate and fill in. 3. Removing it requires another surgery, which carries its o...

Understanding Screw Displacement and Bone Healing After Fracture Surgery

Earlier this year, I was involved in a car accident that resulted in a comminuted fracture of my right femur. After surgery, a steel plate and 12 screws were implanted. About four months later, an X-ray revealed that three of the screws at the fracture site had shifted. I asked m...

Dr. Wang Shouji reply Orthopedics
Hello: If it has not healed after 8 months, the medical likelihood of nonunion requiring further surgery is high. The presence of metal screws and malalignment of the fracture can create an unstable environment for healing. Ultimately, it may be necessary to undergo additional su...