Breathing Training for Vocal Recovery After Tuberculosis Infection - Pulmonology

Share to:

Regarding respiratory training?


I previously had a throat infection caused by tuberculosis, which resulted in a loss of voice.
Although the tuberculosis has been treated, I still can only speak with a breathy voice.
An endoscopic examination revealed that this is due to the inability of my vocal cords to close properly.
I have undergone speech therapy, but the therapist mentioned that due to the vocal cord closure issue, they are unsure how to improve my condition.
An ENT specialist suggested that I could purchase a respiratory training device to use at home for breathing exercises, which might be helpful.
The respiratory therapy department at the hospital also provided a brief tutorial, so I bought a respiratory training device for home use (I purchased one that can connect via Bluetooth to an app to monitor breathing-related data).
Recently, I researched diaphragmatic breathing techniques and found that inhalation should be done through the nose.
However, when using the respiratory training device, I need to keep my mouth around the mouthpiece and inhale through my mouth for the device to register properly.
If I try to inhale through my nose, the device often fails to register or shows very low data.
I would like to ask if it is acceptable to inhale through my mouth while using the device, or should I continue to attempt inhaling through my nose?

x, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2024/01/18

Dr. Cai Zongwei reply Pulmonology


Hello: If the issue with breathy voice is due to the inability of the vocal cords in the upper respiratory tract to close, then training the respiratory muscles should be considered a separate matter.
Additionally, general pulmonary function tests primarily measure expiratory volume (with various influencing factors including inspiratory volume, expiratory muscle strength, and upper and lower airway resistance, etc.).
The respiratory training device you described mainly focuses on inspiratory training.
This consultation is for reference only and cannot replace a medical consultation; please follow the guidance of your original treating physician.

Reply Date: 2024/01/18

More Info


Breathing training can be an essential component of vocal recovery, especially after experiencing a serious condition like tuberculosis (TB) that may have affected your respiratory and vocal functions. It’s great to hear that you are actively seeking ways to improve your voice and lung capacity after your treatment for TB.
To address your specific question about using a breathing training device, it is indeed acceptable to use the device as instructed, which may involve inhaling through your mouth while keeping your lips sealed around the mouthpiece. Many breathing trainers are designed to measure airflow and resistance, which can be more effectively gauged when using the mouth for inhalation. However, it is also important to incorporate nasal breathing into your overall training regimen, as nasal breathing has its own benefits, including better filtration of air, increased oxygen uptake, and improved diaphragm engagement.

Here are some considerations and recommendations for your breathing training and vocal recovery:
1. Incorporate Both Mouth and Nasal Breathing: While using the breathing trainer, you can focus on mouth breathing as it is necessary for the device to function correctly. However, outside of using the device, practice nasal breathing as much as possible. This can help strengthen your diaphragm and improve your overall lung function.

2. Diaphragmatic Breathing: Focus on diaphragmatic or abdominal breathing, which involves engaging your diaphragm fully. When you inhale, your abdomen should expand rather than your chest. This type of breathing can help improve lung capacity and efficiency, which is crucial for vocal recovery.

3. Vocal Exercises: Since you have experienced issues with vocal cord closure, consider working with a speech-language pathologist who specializes in voice therapy. They can provide tailored exercises that focus on improving vocal cord function and closure, which may include humming, lip trills, and gentle phonation exercises.

4. Regular Practice: Consistency is key in any rehabilitation process. Set aside time each day to practice your breathing exercises and vocal exercises. This will help reinforce the muscle memory needed for effective breathing and voice production.

5. Monitor Your Progress: Use the app connected to your breathing trainer to track your progress. Look for improvements in airflow and resistance over time. If you notice any difficulties or setbacks, consult with your healthcare provider or a respiratory therapist.

6. Stay Hydrated and Healthy: Ensure you are drinking plenty of water to keep your vocal cords hydrated. Avoid irritants such as smoke or excessive caffeine, which can dry out your throat and vocal cords.

7. Consult with Professionals: Regular follow-ups with your ENT specialist and possibly a pulmonologist can help monitor your recovery and ensure that any underlying issues are addressed. They can also provide additional recommendations based on your specific condition.

In summary, using your breathing training device as instructed is beneficial, and you should also incorporate nasal breathing into your practice when not using the device. Combining these techniques with vocal exercises and professional guidance will enhance your recovery process. Remember to be patient with yourself, as recovery can take time, especially after a significant health challenge like tuberculosis.

Similar Q&A

Managing Severe Tuberculosis: Treatment Strategies and Patient Care

Hello Doctor, My mother is currently 66 years old and recently experienced sudden hemoptysis, which led to massive bleeding and loss of respiration and heartbeat in the emergency room. After over 20 minutes of resuscitation, she was revived and diagnosed with pulmonary tubercul...


Dr. Lin Wufu reply Internal Medicine
Hello, the considerations for the above issues will vary based on the individual patient's condition. It is recommended to have a detailed discussion with your mother's current attending physician, as this type of online consultation cannot address such individual and c...

[Read More] Managing Severe Tuberculosis: Treatment Strategies and Patient Care


Understanding Vocal Cord Paralysis and Its Impact on Respiratory Failure

Hello, doctor. My mother is currently in the respiratory care unit due to respiratory failure caused by vocal cord paralysis. According to her attending physician, the respiratory failure is a result of the vocal cord paralysis, and she is on a ventilator that cannot be removed. ...


Dr. Li Jiaxuan reply Otolaryngology
It is important to first determine whether your mother's vocal cord paralysis is adductor type or abductor type (based on your description, it seems to be the former). Indeed, after evaluation, vocal cord lateralization surgery could be considered. However, the surgery itsel...

[Read More] Understanding Vocal Cord Paralysis and Its Impact on Respiratory Failure


Understanding Mild Tonsil Swelling and Vocal Cord Edema: Treatment and Care

Mild swelling of the tonsils and slight edema of the vocal cords can cause a strange voice when speaking. Given that you have performances and competitions in the next few days, how long it will take to fully recover depends on the severity of the condition. Treatment methods m...


Dr. Zheng Jueyi reply Otolaryngology
Hello: The recovery time may vary. It is recommended to avoid spicy foods and to drink plenty of water. If the results are not satisfactory, it is advisable to seek medical treatment. Wishing you safety and health. Sincerely, Dr. Cheng Jue-Yi, Director of the Department of Otolar...

[Read More] Understanding Mild Tonsil Swelling and Vocal Cord Edema: Treatment and Care


Voice Rehabilitation for Vocal Cord Nodules: Treatment Options Explained

Hello, doctor. I am a recent university graduate and have been working as an English teacher at a tutoring center since July 3rd. I have been experiencing a sore throat for about half a month. I visited a doctor last night, and he said that I have vocal nodules, but surgery is no...


Dr. Hu Kexin reply Otolaryngology
Hello~ Our Rehabilitation Department offers "voice rehabilitation." If needed, you can schedule an appointment at the Rehabilitation Clinic for treatment. Hook Shin.

[Read More] Voice Rehabilitation for Vocal Cord Nodules: Treatment Options Explained


Related FAQ

Throat

(Pulmonology)

Breathing

(Pulmonology)

Choking

(Pulmonology)

Tracheostomy

(Pulmonology)

Breathing

(Otolaryngology)

Difficulty Breathing

(Pulmonology)

Wheezing, Coughing

(Pulmonology)

Hoarseness

(Otolaryngology)

Bronchitis

(Pulmonology)

Aspiration Pneumonia

(Pulmonology)