Schizophrenia
Hello Dr.
Lin, I would like to explain my condition.
I started hearing three voices around August 2011, one male and one female, and occasionally a child's voice.
At first, I couldn't understand what they were saying, but by April 2012, I began to recognize my inner thoughts as they echoed my thoughts verbatim.
This continued until around 2016 when those three voices suddenly disappeared, but I was still hearing voices (auditory hallucinations).
Instead, I began to hear more voices, up to five or six, all of which were malicious, criticizing, mocking, and attacking me and my family.
They would say that we were short, ugly, poor, and overweight, even though we have always been a middle-class family, and my mother is quite well-off (she divorced my father when I was four).
They also made derogatory comments about my brother (actually my cousin), claiming he was unwanted, even though he had been married for many years and tragically passed away in November 2011.
In May 2017, after moving to a new home, those voices continued to follow me.
By 2018, the female voice began to fade, leaving only the male voices, which still numbered up to five or six.
In 2019, while on a train, I saw a woman walking towards me, pointing at me and voicing my inner thoughts, criticizing me, and telling me to stop talking before she walked off the train, leaving me astonished but not scared.
I was intrigued by the idea that someone could know what I was thinking.
Similar incidents continued, and in July 2020, I was admitted to a psychiatric ward.
However, after being discharged, my condition did not improve.
Over the past ten years, I have changed doctors multiple times and tried various medications, but I never felt any improvement until I received a long-acting injection of paliperidone last August, which provided a slight improvement, akin to moving from 0 to 1.
Throughout these years, I felt that others could hear those voices too.
When they laughed at me loudly, people around would look in the direction of the voices, even though there was no one there.
I'm unsure if this is a hallucination.
Currently, I experience symptoms that seem to include auditory hallucinations, visual hallucinations, and delusions.
The auditory hallucinations come in three forms: the primary type occurs at the entrance of my home and in the vacant lot behind it; the second type occurs when I turn on the TV or computer while in the bathroom or outside my back door, where the original sounds are replaced by the same voices; the third type involves auditory and visual hallucinations related to others, which only occur when they are speaking.
I also suspect that my father can hear those voices based on his expressions and reactions, but this could also be a delusion.
I have experienced paranoid delusions, relational delusions, and a feeling of being scrutinized.
For over a decade, I believed that a group of people was monitoring me, represented by those voices, and I often misinterpret unrelated events as being about me.
For example, I enjoy watching political commentary shows, and even though they discuss politicians, I think they are talking about me.
This has been a daily occurrence.
For many years, I lacked insight into my condition until last year when I realized I truly had schizophrenia, which I thought was impossible.
Last year, I began recording audio to see if I could capture the voices.
I recorded about ten times, but only captured sounds three or four times, which I initially dismissed as nearby machinery.
However, on January 19 of this year, I recorded clearly audible voices criticizing, mocking, and cursing my family, which made me question whether everything was just my auditory hallucinations, delusions, or if my father could no longer hear those voices.
This has led to a significant decline in my mood over the past month.
I wonder if there are truly people with the ability to read minds, which has deterred me from considering electroconvulsive therapy (ECT).
Recently, I have been calmly reflecting on whether the voices recorded on my phone could also be my hallucinations.
During the New Year, I watched a Thai video on YouTube that also contained those voices, clearly stating my current thoughts, even though the video was uploaded three days ago.
I have a follow-up appointment on the 29th and plan to discuss ECT with my doctor.
However, I face a challenge because my father is likely to disagree, as he is extremely stubborn and difficult to persuade.
Therefore, I kindly ask you, Dr.
Lin, to provide compelling evidence that ECT is safe and not dangerous to reassure my father and allow me to proceed with the treatment.
You may wonder why I don't ask my primary doctor for this evidence; it's because a previous incident has led to a significant distrust of him.
Thank you, Dr.
Lin, for listening to my lengthy explanation, and I greatly appreciate your support and assistance!
Niming, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2024/02/24
Dr. Lin Mianzhang reply Psychiatry
Hello: Thank you for your hard work! It seems that you have a good understanding of your situation, but you are also quite troubled.
Based on your description, you indeed exhibit symptoms of schizophrenia, including auditory hallucinations, delusions of reference (believing that political commentary programs are talking about you), and paranoid delusions (feeling that a group of people is watching you).
Although you mentioned that you have tried many medications, I cannot confirm whether your condition is truly resistant to pharmacological treatment without knowing which medications you have taken and their dosages.
Therefore, I still recommend discussing medication options with your treating physician.
As for electroconvulsive therapy (ECT), it is generally used in cases where medication treatment is ineffective, and some physical examinations are required to ensure there are no significant health issues before proceeding.
This should also be discussed with your doctor! For more information on electroconvulsive therapy, you can refer to the following webpage: https://www.depression.org.tw/communication/info.asp?/47.html Wishing you a speedy recovery!
Reply Date: 2024/02/24
More Info
Thank you for sharing your personal journey and experiences with schizophrenia. It sounds like you have been through a lot over the years, and I commend you for your courage in seeking help and trying to understand your condition.
From what you describe, it seems that you are experiencing a range of symptoms commonly associated with schizophrenia, including auditory hallucinations (hearing voices), delusions (such as the belief that others can hear your thoughts or that you are being watched), and possibly visual hallucinations. These symptoms can be incredibly distressing and can significantly impact your daily life and relationships.
Auditory hallucinations, like the ones you mentioned, can vary in nature. Some individuals hear voices that are critical or derogatory, while others may hear more neutral or even supportive voices. The fact that you have experienced a shift in the nature and number of voices over the years is not uncommon in schizophrenia. Many individuals report that their symptoms can change in intensity and character over time.
Regarding your question about whether hallucinations can be recorded, it is important to understand that hallucinations are perceptions that occur without external stimuli. This means that while you may hear voices, those sounds do not exist outside of your mind. The recordings you made could be a result of your perception of those voices, but they do not provide definitive proof that the voices are real in the external world. This can be a challenging concept to grapple with, especially when the experiences feel very real.
You mentioned that you have been on various medications and have recently started a long-acting injectable medication, which has provided some slight improvement. It's important to remember that finding the right medication can be a process of trial and error, and what works for one person may not work for another. It can take time to find the right combination and dosage that helps manage your symptoms effectively.
Electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) is a treatment option that can be effective for some individuals with severe mental health conditions, including treatment-resistant schizophrenia. It is typically considered when other treatments have not been successful. ECT can help alleviate symptoms, but it is essential to have a thorough discussion with your healthcare provider about the potential benefits and risks. If your father is concerned about ECT, it may be helpful to provide him with educational resources that explain the procedure, its safety, and its effectiveness. Many mental health professionals can provide literature or even discuss it with family members to help alleviate their concerns.
Lastly, I encourage you to continue seeking support from mental health professionals. It can be beneficial to have a therapist or psychiatrist who understands your experiences and can work with you to develop coping strategies. Support groups, whether in-person or online, can also provide a sense of community and understanding from others who have similar experiences.
In summary, your journey with schizophrenia is complex and multifaceted. It is crucial to maintain open communication with your healthcare providers and your family about your experiences and treatment options. Remember that you are not alone in this journey, and there are resources and support available to help you navigate through it. Thank you for sharing your story, and I wish you the best in your ongoing treatment and recovery.
Similar Q&A
Understanding and Managing Psychotic Disorders: A Personal Journey
I have been diagnosed with schizophrenia, but I feel very unhappy every day. I experience auditory hallucinations where I hear people cursing at me, and I can barely tolerate it because it’s so loud. I have had sleep issues since childhood. I am currently a senior in the vocation...
Dr. Tian Xinqiao reply Psychiatry
Hello, dear user: Thank you for your message. Individuals with schizophrenia often experience similar concerns, worrying about their condition and how others perceive them. The treatment of psychiatric symptoms can indeed affect one's work performance and social interactions...[Read More] Understanding and Managing Psychotic Disorders: A Personal Journey
Understanding Unpredictable Phenomena: A Personal Journey with Schizophrenia
I experience auditory hallucinations and delusions, and I have been diagnosed with schizophrenia in psychiatry. I have undergone involuntary treatment, but I do not need medication for control and live a normal life. I wonder why people do not believe in unpredictable phenomena.
Dr. Huang Xiangxiong reply Psychiatry
Patients with schizophrenia often experience hallucinations that can have a significant negative impact on their well-being, such as emotional instability, disrupted sleep, impaired reality perception, and in severe cases, a loss of self-control leading to destructive or aggressi...[Read More] Understanding Unpredictable Phenomena: A Personal Journey with Schizophrenia
Voices in My Head: Navigating Mental Health Challenges and Emotional Turmoil
Hello, doctor. Since I was a child, I have had the impression that there are voices in my head talking to me. At first, I thought everyone experienced this, so I would directly converse with them. Later, when asked why I was talking to the air, I realized it wasn't normal, s...
Dr. Lin Mianzhang reply Psychiatry
Hello Li, It appears that you are experiencing auditory hallucinations and may also be dealing with depression. I recommend that you seek medical attention from a psychiatrist as soon as possible. With medication and psychotherapy, these conditions can significantly improve! On...[Read More] Voices in My Head: Navigating Mental Health Challenges and Emotional Turmoil
Understanding the Challenges of Diagnosing Mental Health Issues
Hello doctor, I started experiencing auditory hallucinations and delusions at the age of 23, but at that time, I didn't believe I was ill. My family forced me to seek medical help, and the doctors repeatedly emphasized that what I was hearing was not real. I was adamant that...
Dr. Wang Zhenyang reply Psychiatry
Hello, online user: It sounds like some of your symptoms are indeed troubling you, but it seems that the doctors have not yet been able to resolve your issues. I recommend that you find a physician to regularly follow up with, so that they can truly understand your problems and p...[Read More] Understanding the Challenges of Diagnosing Mental Health Issues
Related FAQ
(Psychiatry)
Talking To Oneself(Psychiatry)
Auditory Hallucinations(Psychiatry)
Ptsd(Psychiatry)
Hearing(Psychiatry)
Cbt(Psychiatry)
Self-Harm(Psychiatry)
Involuntary Psychiatric Treatment(Psychiatry)
Others(Psychiatry)
Breathing(Psychiatry)