Teratomas: Laparoscopic Surgery and Malignancy Risks

Teratoma benign and malignant classification / surgery / association with the liver?

Hello Dr.
Chen,
1) I would like to ask if both benign and malignant teratomas can be treated laparoscopically? My doctor only performed an AFP blood test after discovering a 4 cm teratoma on ultrasound and advised me to consult a hepatologist first to rule out liver-related issues.
He mentioned that if it is benign, minimally invasive surgery could be performed, but since the blood test results were elevated, there is a possibility of malignant cells.
Therefore, it needs to be confirmed whether it is malignant; if so, traditional open surgery would be necessary due to the risk of rupturing a malignant teratoma during minimally invasive surgery, which could lead to dissemination.
However, while researching teratoma treatment online, I came across an article stating: "Open surgery has limited visibility due to incision constraints, making it difficult to completely dissect teratoma tissue.
Laparoscopic surgery provides a wider field of view and magnification, allowing the teratoma-containing ovary to be placed in a plastic bag for complete removal without contaminating the abdominal cavity, while also facilitating examination of the contralateral ovary (over 50% of teratomas occur bilaterally).
Therefore, teratoma surgery does not require open surgery.
If the surgical consent form includes terms about the possibility of converting to open surgery or the need to remove the ovary due to malignant teratoma, do not sign it, as this indicates the hospital's laparoscopic skills may be inadequate and their understanding of malignant teratomas may be insufficient." - Source: http://cht.a-hospital.com/w/%E6%81%B6%E6%80%A7%E7%95%B8%E8%83%8E%E7%98%A4#google_vignette.
I am now hesitant about the surgical judgment made by my doctor, so I would like to hear your opinion.
2) Is it impossible to determine whether a teratoma is malignant solely through external examinations? My doctor only performed an AFP blood test and stated that during laparoscopic surgery, they would first assess whether it is benign or malignant.
If it is malignant, they would switch to traditional open surgery.
3) What is the difference between traditional open surgery and mini-laparotomy?
4) Is laparoscopic surgery or natural orifice transluminal endoscopic surgery (NOTES) typically used for teratoma surgery?
5) Could a high AFP level indicate that both the teratoma and a liver tumor are malignant? If a tumor is also found in the liver, would treatment be necessary? After treatment, would another blood test be needed to determine if the teratoma is malignant?
Thank you!

Ann, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2024/03/18

Dr. Chen Zhiyu reply Obstetrics and Gynecology

Each individual's condition is different.
Online articles are for reference only.
Please discuss your concerns with your attending physician.
If you need a second opinion, it is advisable to consult in an outpatient setting.
Thank you.

Reply Date: 2024/03/18

More Info

Understanding teratomas, particularly in the context of laparoscopic surgery and the associated risks of malignancy, is crucial for making informed decisions regarding treatment options. Teratomas are germ cell tumors that can contain various types of tissues, including hair, muscle, and even teeth. They can be classified as benign or malignant, and their management often depends on their characteristics and the patient's overall health.

1. Laparoscopic Surgery for Teratomas: Laparoscopic surgery is a minimally invasive technique that allows surgeons to access the abdominal cavity through small incisions. This method is often preferred for benign teratomas due to its advantages, including reduced postoperative pain, shorter recovery time, and minimal scarring. However, the concern arises when there is a suspicion of malignancy. If a teratoma is suspected to be malignant, the risk of rupture during laparoscopic removal could lead to the spread of cancerous cells within the abdominal cavity. Therefore, the decision to proceed with laparoscopic surgery versus traditional open surgery often hinges on preoperative assessments, including imaging studies and tumor markers like alpha-fetoprotein (AFP).

2. Determining Malignancy: It is indeed challenging to definitively determine whether a teratoma is malignant based solely on external examinations or imaging studies. While elevated AFP levels can indicate the presence of malignant germ cell tumors, they are not definitive. The diagnosis often requires histopathological examination of the tumor tissue, which can only be obtained through surgical intervention. Thus, your physician's approach of performing laparoscopic surgery to assess the tumor's nature is a common practice, albeit with the caveat of potential conversion to open surgery if malignancy is confirmed during the procedure.

3. Traditional vs. Minimally Invasive Surgery: Traditional open surgery involves a larger incision, which can lead to more postoperative pain and a longer recovery period. In contrast, laparoscopic surgery utilizes smaller incisions, resulting in less trauma to the body. However, if a tumor is found to be malignant during laparoscopic surgery, the surgeon may need to convert to an open procedure to ensure complete removal and to manage any complications effectively.

4. Surgical Techniques: The choice between laparoscopic surgery and natural orifice transluminal endoscopic surgery (NOTES) depends on the specific case and the surgeon's expertise. Laparoscopic surgery is more commonly performed for teratomas due to its established safety and efficacy. NOTES, while innovative, is less frequently used and may not be available in all medical facilities.

5. AFP Levels and Malignancy: Elevated AFP levels can indicate the presence of malignant germ cell tumors, including teratomas and liver tumors. If both conditions are suspected, it is essential to address them sequentially. If a liver tumor is identified, it may require treatment before reassessing the teratoma. Post-treatment, further AFP testing can help monitor the status of the teratoma and determine if it is benign or malignant.

In conclusion, the management of teratomas, particularly with the potential for malignancy, requires a careful and individualized approach. It is essential to have open communication with your healthcare provider about the risks and benefits of laparoscopic versus open surgery, the implications of elevated AFP levels, and the overall treatment strategy. Seeking a second opinion or consulting with a specialist in gynecologic oncology may also provide additional insights and reassurance as you navigate this complex situation.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Teratomas: Risks, Surgery, and Fertility Concerns

Hello Doctor: A year ago, I was diagnosed by a gynecologist with a teratoma approximately 5 centimeters in size on my right ovary, which was confirmed to be benign. The doctor recommended laparoscopic surgery for removal, but I have been afraid and have not undergone the surgery ...

Dr. Dong Yuhong reply Obstetrics and Gynecology
Hello: More than 95% of teratomas are benign, with an approximate 0.2%-2% chance of malignant transformation. Therefore, without a pathological examination after surgery, it is not possible to completely rule out the possibility of malignancy. As for the potential complications o...

Minimizing Adhesions and Scarring After Laparoscopic Surgery for Teratoma

Hello Dr. Liu, I am scheduled for laparoscopic surgery for a teratoma on the 29th. I am currently looking into ways to reduce adhesions and scarring. I would like to inquire about which organs might be encountered or affected during the laparoscopic surgery for a left ovarian ter...

Dr. Liu Fuping reply Obstetrics and Gynecology
Hello, surgical adhesions and scar formation are natural processes of wound healing. In addition to minimizing tissue damage during surgery, if the patient has insurance coverage or can afford it, additional anti-adhesion products or scar treatment products are also options. Surg...

Laparoscopic Surgery for Ovarian Teratoma: Can It Be Combined with Appendectomy?

Hello Dr. Wu, I was recently hospitalized in Taoyuan due to appendicitis. The physician assessed that surgery for removal is not necessary, but my family wishes to proceed with the removal to prevent future recurrence. I also have a right-sided ovarian teratoma and would like to ...

Dr. Wu Xianghui reply Obstetrics and Gynecology
This pertains to surgical procedures within the fields of "General Surgery" and "Obstetrics and Gynecology." You should inquire at the outpatient clinic to see if there are any collaborating physicians and the feasibility of the surgery.

Understanding Lymphoma: Concerns About Tumors and Surgical Risks

Hello Doctor, my mom recently developed 3 to 4 tumors in her neck, one of which is particularly large and round. The test results indicate that they are benign, but the doctor who examined her mentioned that there is a possibility of benign tumors becoming malignant and recommend...

Dr. Lin Zongzhe reply Oncology
Hello: Surgical resection is intended for more accurate diagnosis. If those tumors are indeed malignant, removal will not cause issues with metastasis. Additionally, benign tumors in this area generally do not raise concerns about malignant transformation. Sincerely, Dr. Lin Tsun...