Managing Allergic Rhinitis: ENT vs. Immunology Approaches - Internal Medicine

Share to:

Allergic rhinitis


The practice in otolaryngology involves clearing the nose and administering nasal medication or nasal sprays.
This way, there is no need to schedule a follow-up appointment.
However, it seems that in immunology, follow-up appointments are required consistently.
It's unclear which approach is better.

Tian, 40~49 year old female. Ask Date: 2024/07/28

Dr. Gao Jiankai reply Internal Medicine


Hello, thank you for your question.
Each treatment method has its pros and cons, and individual needs vary, making it difficult to compare.
In otolaryngology, nasal sprays may reduce the need for medication, but patients generally still need to return for follow-up visits periodically, and nasal cleaning may not be comfortable for everyone.
Some people may dislike it.
The immunology department primarily relies on medication, which can be inconvenient since some individuals prefer not to take drugs.
However, if the medication is effective, symptoms can significantly improve, allowing patients to potentially reduce or discontinue their medication in the future without the need for constant follow-up appointments.
You can choose a physician based on what matters most to you.
The Allergy, Immunology, and Rheumatology Department at Changhua Hospital, Ministry of Health and Welfare, cares about you.

Reply Date: 2024/07/28

More Info


Managing allergic rhinitis can indeed be approached from different medical specialties, primarily ENT (Ear, Nose, and Throat) and Immunology. Each specialty has its own methods and philosophies regarding treatment, and the choice between them often depends on the severity of symptoms, the underlying causes, and the patient's overall health.


ENT Approach
The ENT specialist typically focuses on the anatomical and physiological aspects of the nasal passages and sinuses. When a patient presents with allergic rhinitis, the ENT may perform a thorough examination of the nasal cavity, looking for any structural abnormalities, such as nasal polyps or deviated septum, that could exacerbate symptoms. The common treatment methods include:
1. Nasal Corticosteroids: These are often the first-line treatment for allergic rhinitis. They help reduce inflammation in the nasal passages, leading to decreased symptoms such as nasal congestion, sneezing, and runny nose.

2. Antihistamines: These medications can be prescribed to alleviate symptoms caused by histamine release during allergic reactions. They can be taken orally or as nasal sprays.

3. Saline Nasal Irrigation: This method involves rinsing the nasal passages with saline solution to remove allergens and mucus, providing symptomatic relief.

4. Immunotherapy: In some cases, if the allergic rhinitis is severe and persistent, the ENT may refer the patient for allergy testing and consider immunotherapy (allergy shots) as a long-term solution.

The ENT approach is generally more focused on immediate relief and management of symptoms, which can be appealing for patients seeking quick solutions.


Immunology Approach
On the other hand, an immunologist takes a more comprehensive view of allergic rhinitis, often considering the patient's entire immune system and how it interacts with allergens. The immunology approach may involve:
1. Allergy Testing: This can include skin prick tests or blood tests to identify specific allergens that trigger symptoms. Understanding the exact triggers can help tailor treatment plans.

2. Immunotherapy: As mentioned earlier, this is a significant part of the immunology approach. It involves gradually desensitizing the immune system to specific allergens through controlled exposure, which can lead to long-term relief from symptoms.

3. Long-term Management Plans: Immunologists often focus on developing a comprehensive management plan that may include lifestyle modifications, environmental controls, and ongoing monitoring of symptoms.

4. Education and Support: Immunologists typically spend more time educating patients about their condition, potential triggers, and long-term management strategies.


Which Approach is Better?
The choice between ENT and immunology approaches largely depends on individual patient needs. If a patient is looking for quick relief from symptoms, an ENT may be the better option. However, if the patient has persistent symptoms, multiple allergies, or is interested in long-term solutions, consulting an immunologist may be more beneficial.

It's also worth noting that these specialties can work together. For instance, an ENT may manage immediate symptoms while an immunologist addresses the underlying allergic sensitivities. In some cases, patients may benefit from a combination of both approaches.


Conclusion
In summary, both ENT and immunology have valuable roles in managing allergic rhinitis. The ENT approach is often more immediate and symptom-focused, while the immunology approach provides a broader understanding of the immune system's role in allergies and offers long-term solutions. Patients should consider their specific symptoms, preferences, and the severity of their condition when deciding which specialist to consult. Ultimately, effective management of allergic rhinitis may involve collaboration between both specialties to provide comprehensive care.

Similar Q&A

Choosing Between Immunology and ENT for Allergic Rhinitis Treatment

I have a history of allergic rhinitis, a deviated septum, and enlarged inferior turbinates. I have been using nasal sprays and drops to treat nasal congestion; however, I still experience nasal congestion upon waking up in the morning, which forces me to breathe through my mouth....


Dr. Gao Jiankai reply Internal Medicine
Hello, thank you for your question. I believe there may be structural issues, such as turbinate hypertrophy or a deviated septum. It would be advisable to first consult an otolaryngologist. If there is still no improvement, then consider seeing a specialist in immunology and rheu...

[Read More] Choosing Between Immunology and ENT for Allergic Rhinitis Treatment


Understanding Allergic Rhinitis: Immunology vs. ENT Treatment Approaches

Can I also see the immunology department? May I ask if your treatment methods in immunology involve regular appointments for medication management? What is the difference between immunology and otolaryngology?


Dr. Gao Jiankai reply Internal Medicine
Hello, thank you for your question. Personally, I believe the differences between our department and the otolaryngology department are as follows: 1. We primarily focus on medication, while otolaryngologists can use endoscopy to observe changes in the nasal cavity, throat, and ea...

[Read More] Understanding Allergic Rhinitis: Immunology vs. ENT Treatment Approaches


Effective Strategies for Managing Allergic Rhinitis Symptoms

Hello, doctor... Regarding the management of allergic rhinitis, I feel really helpless. I have sought medical help multiple times, and each time I am prescribed antihistamines and nasal decongestant sprays. However, I originally had minimal sneezing and runny nose, and I haven&#x...


Dr. Zheng Jueyi reply Otolaryngology
Dear Wei, The management of allergic rhinitis primarily relies on oral antihistamines or intranasal corticosteroid sprays, which generally provide significant improvement. If the treatment is not effective, nasal congestion can be addressed through surgical intervention or enhan...

[Read More] Effective Strategies for Managing Allergic Rhinitis Symptoms


Managing Allergic Rhinitis: When to Seek Further Medical Advice

There is no obvious runny nose or cough, but there is discomfort around the nose area. Sometimes it feels like there is insufficient oxygen, as if the brain is lacking oxygen. Should I switch to an immunology or rheumatology specialist? I have visited the ENT department multiple ...


Dr. Ji Zhaoyun reply Otolaryngology
If you suspect symptoms of allergic rhinitis, you can visit an otolaryngologist for an endoscopic examination of the nasal cavity, blood tests for allergens, and other diagnostic evaluations. Based on the results, treatment options may include nasal sprays, oral medications, nasa...

[Read More] Managing Allergic Rhinitis: When to Seek Further Medical Advice


Related FAQ

Allergic Rhinitis

(Internal Medicine)

Allergic Rhinitis

(Otolaryngology)

Allergies

(Internal Medicine)

Asthma

(Internal Medicine)

Nasal Allergy

(Pediatrics)

Immune System

(Internal Medicine)

Hives

(Internal Medicine)

Sneezing

(Otolaryngology)

Antinuclear Antibodies

(Internal Medicine)

Allergy

(Dermatology)