Bone Tumors: Concerns and Alternatives for Healing

I would like to inquire about issues related to bone tumors?

First of all, I would like to express my gratitude for your time in addressing my concerns.
My mother unfortunately fell in early November last year, resulting in a fracture at the junction of her right upper arm and shoulder.
She was taken to Fengyuan Hospital for surgery, where steel pins were used for fixation.
However, the fracture has not healed after more than six months.
The physician at Fengyuan Hospital recommended that she undergo a whole body bone scan at China Medical University.
After the examination, the orthopedic surgeon at China Medical University Hospital informed us that there were no issues.
However, the doctor observed that the bone in my mother’s right upper arm appeared to be porous, as if it were decayed, and suspected bone cancer, leaving my mother and me speechless.
The doctor suggested that my mother should undergo surgery to install a prosthetic joint to address the non-healing fracture, and to take a bone sample from the problematic area for further testing to determine the next steps in treatment.
I would like to inquire about the following two questions:
1.
Regarding the suspected bone cancer:
(1) Since the results of the whole body bone scan showed no issues, why is bone cancer still a possibility that cannot be ruled out?
(2) Considering my mother’s symptoms, are there other potential conditions besides bone cancer, such as osteoporosis or an infection resulting from the initial surgery? Can a diagnosis of bone cancer be made solely based on an X-ray?
(3) Since my mother is very afraid of surgery, are there any alternative methods for obtaining a sample without surgery? Or are there other testing methods available?
2.
Concerning the fracture:
Since my mother is very fearful of surgery, I would like to ask if there would be any long-term consequences if a prosthetic joint is not installed.
What precautions should be taken? Is there a possibility that the fracture could heal on its own with long-term calcium supplementation?

Mr. Hong, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2004/05/31

Dr. Xu Xijing reply Orthopedics

Please visit the outpatient clinic for consultation.

Reply Date: 2004/05/31

More Info

Understanding bone tumors, especially in the context of your mother's situation, can be quite complex and concerning. Let's break down your questions and provide clarity on the issues at hand.

1. Concerns Regarding Suspected Bone Cancer
#
(a) Why can't bone cancer be ruled out despite a normal whole-body bone scan?
A whole-body bone scan is a useful diagnostic tool that can help identify areas of increased or decreased bone activity, which may suggest the presence of cancer. However, it is not definitive for diagnosing bone tumors. Some bone cancers may not show up on a scan, especially in their early stages or if they are localized. Additionally, certain types of bone lesions may not exhibit significant changes detectable by a bone scan. Therefore, while the scan results may not indicate cancer, they do not completely rule it out.

#
(b) Other Possible Conditions
Your mother's symptoms could indeed be indicative of other conditions besides bone cancer. Osteoporosis, which is characterized by weakened bones, could lead to similar symptoms, especially in older adults. Additionally, if the initial surgery did not heal properly, it could lead to complications such as non-union or infection, which might also present as bone pain or structural changes seen on X-rays. An X-ray can provide valuable information, but it is not always sufficient to definitively diagnose bone cancer. Further imaging studies, such as MRI or CT scans, may be necessary for a more comprehensive evaluation.

#
(c) Alternatives to Surgical Sampling
If your mother is apprehensive about surgery, there are non-invasive methods to obtain tissue samples, such as a needle biopsy. This procedure involves using a thin needle to extract a small sample of bone tissue for analysis. It is less invasive than traditional surgery and can often be done under local anesthesia. Additionally, imaging techniques like MRI can provide more detailed information about the bone structure and any abnormalities present.

2. Concerns Regarding the Fracture
#
(a) Risks of Not Installing an Artificial Joint
If your mother opts not to have an artificial joint installed, there are potential risks, including chronic pain, limited mobility, and the possibility of the fracture not healing properly. Non-union of the fracture can lead to further complications, including the development of avascular necrosis, where the bone tissue dies due to a lack of blood supply.

#
(b) Possibility of Healing with Calcium Supplementation
While calcium supplementation is essential for bone health, it is unlikely to facilitate healing of a fracture that has not healed for over six months. Bone healing typically requires a stable environment, adequate blood supply, and sometimes surgical intervention, especially in cases of non-union. While maintaining a healthy diet rich in calcium and vitamin D is beneficial, it is not a substitute for medical intervention when healing is not progressing.

Conclusion
Given your mother's situation, it is crucial to have a thorough discussion with her healthcare provider about the findings and the best course of action. If there is still uncertainty regarding the diagnosis, seeking a second opinion from an orthopedic oncologist may provide additional insights. It is also important to address her fears about surgery and explore all available options, including less invasive procedures. Open communication with her medical team will be key in navigating her treatment and ensuring she receives the best possible care.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Benign Bone Tumors in Children: Diagnosis and Treatment Options

My child is 9 years old and accidentally bumped their right upper arm against the edge of the bed, resulting in a fracture in the upper arm bone. An X-ray examination revealed that there is a benign tumor in that area of the bone, which is why a minor impact caused a fracture. Cu...

Dr. Li Wenlin reply Orthopedics
Hello, in response to your questions: 1. The first step in diagnosing bone tumors is through X-rays, as orthopedic specialists are trained to interpret X-ray images for bone tumors. Most benign bone tumors can be assessed using X-rays. If there is any suspicion, further imaging...

Understanding Bone Tumors: Symptoms, Concerns, and Next Steps

Hello Doctor: Thank you for taking the time to patiently answer my questions. Thirty years ago, I suffered an open fracture of the tibia in my right leg, which required four surgeries over four years, including the insertion and removal of a metal plate. During rehabilitation, I ...

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
1. Go to the hospital for a check-up when you have time. 2. It may be unrelated. 3. If the tumor is growing, there is usually a phenomenon of pain. 4. Temporarily avoid vigorous exercise.

Understanding Tibial Tumor Surgery: Risks, Recovery, and Rehabilitation

Hello: I recently confirmed that I have a tumor on my tibia and I am scheduled for surgery. However, I am unsure about any potential complications or side effects. Will I need another surgery to remove the bone graft? Will I need to undergo rehabilitation? Are there any foods I s...

Dr. Xu Xijing reply Orthopedics
Please visit the outpatient clinic for a consultation.

Understanding Benign Osteosarcoma: Post-Surgery Care and Recovery Tips

Hello Dr. Li, I am 22 years old, and after undergoing various examinations, I was diagnosed with a "benign osteosarcoma" below my right knee. I just had a curettage surgery two weeks ago, during which artificial bone material was implanted. I had my stitches removed to...

Dr. Li Wenlin reply Orthopedics
Hello, in response to your questions: 1. There is no such thing as a benign osteosarcoma. Osteosarcoma, despite having various forms based on different cell types, locations, and characteristics, is classified as a malignant tumor. In addition to surgery, chemotherapy is also r...