Mental Health Issues: How to Help a Loved One in Crisis

Please help me?

Hello, doctor.
My sister has been staying at home since she resigned from her job about a year ago.
I heard there was a significant dispute with her company at that time.
After about six months, her mood began to change; she became increasingly paranoid, claiming that our mother does not care for her and is trying to harm her.
She even uses abusive language.
This behavior extends to others as well, and she has become extremely volatile in her words and actions (there were no issues in the first six months, and she got along well with family).
It's like she has become a completely different person.
Recently, her behavior has escalated; during an argument with our father, she hurt him with her words, saying things that are damaging to our parents.
Does this indicate a mental health issue? She is currently ignoring everyone, and I don't know how to persuade her to see a psychiatrist.

TOTO, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2001/02/12

Dr. Zhang Zhehong reply Psychiatry

Hello,
I apologize for the delayed response.
Based on the situation described in your letter, it appears that your sister is indeed experiencing some abnormalities in her mental state, which may indicate mood disorders or other psychiatric conditions, and it is necessary for her to seek medical attention.
Encouraging a patient to seek treatment can be a very challenging task, especially if they currently harbor some distrust towards family members.
It may be helpful to enlist the support of friends or relatives whom she still trusts.

Alternatively, you could approach the situation from her perspective of suffering, rather than using terms that imply a mental health issue.
For example, discussing symptoms such as insomnia, poor appetite, or other physical discomforts may be more effective in persuading her to seek care.
If these efforts are unsuccessful, family members can visit a psychiatric facility that offers home treatment services (most nursing homes and larger general hospitals should provide this service) to arrange for healthcare professionals to visit her at home.

If she exhibits more dangerous behaviors, such as self-harm, suicidal tendencies, or aggression towards others, it is crucial to contact the local health department's psychiatric public health nurse, especially to arrange for involuntary hospitalization if necessary.

Best regards,
Wu Yu-Chuan

Reply Date: 2001/02/12

More Info

It sounds like your sister is going through a very challenging time, and it's understandable that you're feeling concerned about her mental health. Based on the description you've provided, it seems she may be exhibiting signs of a serious mental health issue, possibly a mood disorder or even a psychotic disorder. The sudden change in her behavior, including paranoia, aggression, and a breakdown in family relationships, is alarming and warrants immediate attention.

Understanding Mental Health Issues
Mental health issues can manifest in various ways, and they often affect not only the individual but also their loved ones. In your sister's case, her behavior has changed drastically from being sociable and close to her family to becoming suspicious and hostile. This kind of shift can be indicative of underlying mental health conditions, such as depression, anxiety disorders, or even more severe conditions like schizophrenia or bipolar disorder.

Signs of Mental Health Issues
1. Paranoia: Your sister's belief that her mother is trying to harm her suggests a level of paranoia that is concerning. This can be a symptom of various mental health disorders.

2. Aggression: The fact that she has become verbally aggressive towards family members, especially her father, indicates a significant change in her emotional regulation and coping mechanisms.

3. Isolation: Withdrawing from family and friends is another common sign of mental health issues. It can lead to further deterioration of mental health as social support is crucial for recovery.

How to Help
1. Open Communication: Start by expressing your concern in a non-confrontational manner. Let her know that you care about her well-being and that you are there to support her. Avoid using accusatory language; instead, focus on how her behavior has changed and how it affects you and the family.

2. Encourage Professional Help: Suggest that she sees a mental health professional. You can frame this as a way to help her feel better rather than implying that she has a problem. You might say something like, "I think talking to someone who understands these feelings could really help you."
3. Involve Family: If she is open to it, involve other family members in the conversation. Sometimes hearing concern from multiple loved ones can help her feel less isolated and more willing to seek help.

4. Educate Yourself and Her: Understanding mental health issues can help both you and your sister. Share resources about mental health that explain symptoms and the importance of seeking help. This can help normalize the conversation around mental health.

5. Be Patient: Change may not happen overnight. It’s important to be patient and continue to offer support, even if she initially resists help.
6. Crisis Management: If her behavior escalates to the point where she poses a danger to herself or others, it may be necessary to seek immediate help. This could involve contacting a mental health crisis line or taking her to an emergency room.

7. Self-Care: Supporting someone with mental health issues can be draining. Make sure you are also taking care of your own mental health during this time. Seek support from friends, family, or even a counselor for yourself.

Conclusion
Navigating a loved one's mental health crisis can be incredibly challenging. It’s crucial to approach the situation with empathy and understanding. Encourage her to seek professional help, and be there to support her through the process. Remember that mental health issues are complex and often require professional intervention for effective management and recovery. Your concern and willingness to help are significant first steps in supporting your sister through this difficult time.

Similar Q&A

Coping with Stress: Supporting a Loved One with Mental Illness

I feel like I'm going crazy right now. I have suspected that I might have depression and have a history of self-harm, but now a family member has also developed a mental illness (they are receiving treatment, but their condition fluctuates). Their situation seems to be more ...

Dr. Ding Shuyan reply Psychiatry
Hello, when a family member is ill and you are also under stress, it can indeed feel overwhelming. Regarding medical matters, there is limited information available for discussion. My suggestion is to seek medical attention promptly and allow healthcare professionals to assist in...

How to Help a Family Member Struggling with Depression

Having a family member suffering from depression who refuses to seek medical help can be challenging. It is important to approach the situation with empathy and understanding. Here are some steps you can take: 1. Open Communication: Try to have an open and non-judgmental con...

Dr. Wang Zuoren reply Psychiatry
Hello. I apologize for only seeing your message today. Patients with depression often experience persistent low mood and lack of motivation to engage in activities, including social interactions and attending medical appointments. Additionally, patients frequently worry about bei...

How to Handle a Family Member's Mental Health Crisis Effectively

Since May of this year, my grandfather has been suspicious that the children in the house are not his biological grandchildren, accusing their mother without any reason. He has verbally abused her, locked her out of the house, and frequently wakes everyone up in the middle of the...

Dr. Chen Wenyu reply Psychiatry
Hello, Shin: It seems very likely that he is suffering from "geriatric psychosis," and he indeed needs medical treatment. There is no need to complicate matters by filing a complaint. If there is "mental illness with a risk of self-harm or harm to others," he ...

How to Help a Loved One with Mental Health Issues Seek Treatment

My younger brother, who is 46 years old, is naturally shy and has never been married. Two years ago, he developed feelings for a female colleague at work, but she did not reciprocate and humiliated him in front of other male colleagues. Since then, he has often felt like he is be...

Dr. Wang Yaoting reply Psychiatry
Hello: It is recommended to first consult with the local health center, where you can apply for a home assessment by a physician (some counties have designated hospitals and subsidies), or a public health nurse can visit the home for care. If the individual exhibits violent behav...