Pneumothorax: Risks of Acupuncture for Back Pain - Pulmonology

Share to:

Emphysema


Hello Director Chang: Recently, I came across a medical news article stating that several patients in Taoyuan experienced back pain and, due to improper acupuncture treatment, inadvertently injured the pleura, leading to pneumothorax.
Their pain worsened, prompting them to seek help from Western medicine.
I have had a similar experience; after receiving acupuncture treatment for back pain at a traditional Chinese medicine clinic in Zhongli (needles inserted from the back), I noticed the pain extending from my back to my chest the next day (not referred pain), accompanied by abnormal sounds in the thoracic cavity during breathing and the onset of coughing.

Zhou, 40~49 year old female. Ask Date: 2001/05/07

Dr. Zhang Zhengda reply Pulmonology


1.
Emphysema is a syndrome of reduced lung function, which is a natural phenomenon of aging in humans.
The natural destruction of alveoli is irreversible, but maintenance can slow down the damage.
Therefore, asymptomatic patients should pay attention to fresh air intake and avoid smoking.
Symptomatic patients still require evaluation by a physician to be taught breathing exercises and medication usage.
More severe patients will need to use oxygen regularly.
2.
Deep acupuncture can lead to...

Reply Date: 2001/05/07

More Info


Pneumothorax, or the presence of air in the pleural space, can be a serious condition that may arise from various causes, including trauma, certain medical procedures, and, in rare cases, acupuncture. Your concern regarding the risks associated with acupuncture, particularly in the context of back pain treatment, is valid and warrants a thorough discussion.

Acupuncture is a traditional Chinese medicine practice that involves inserting thin needles into specific points on the body to alleviate pain and promote healing. While acupuncture can be effective for various conditions, including musculoskeletal pain, there are inherent risks, especially when performed improperly or in patients with certain pre-existing conditions.

In your case, it seems that after receiving acupuncture for back pain, you experienced a worsening of symptoms, including pain radiating to the chest, abnormal sounds during breathing, and coughing. These symptoms could potentially indicate a pneumothorax, especially if the acupuncture needles inadvertently punctured the pleura, the membrane surrounding the lungs. This is a rare but documented complication of acupuncture, particularly when needles are inserted in the thoracic region.

The risk of pneumothorax from acupuncture is generally low, but it can increase if the practitioner lacks experience or if the patient has underlying lung conditions, such as chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) or a history of lung infections. Additionally, certain acupuncture techniques that involve deeper needle insertion may pose a higher risk.

If you are experiencing symptoms such as chest pain, difficulty breathing, or a persistent cough following acupuncture, it is crucial to seek immediate medical attention. A healthcare professional can perform a physical examination and imaging studies, such as a chest X-ray, to determine if a pneumothorax has occurred. If confirmed, treatment may involve observation for small pneumothoraces or more invasive procedures, such as chest tube insertion, for larger ones.

In terms of managing back pain, it is essential to consider a comprehensive approach that includes physical therapy, medication, and possibly alternative treatments like acupuncture, but always under the guidance of qualified healthcare providers. If you choose to pursue acupuncture again, ensure that the practitioner is licensed and experienced, and communicate any previous complications or concerns you may have.

In summary, while acupuncture can be beneficial for back pain, it is not without risks, particularly the potential for pneumothorax. If you experience any concerning symptoms after treatment, do not hesitate to seek medical evaluation. Always prioritize safety and ensure that any alternative therapies are conducted by qualified professionals.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Iatrogenic Pneumothorax from Acupuncture: Risks and Recovery

1. Regarding iatrogenic pneumothorax caused by acupuncture, is there a high possibility of recurrence after recovery? 2. After being hospitalized and receiving oxygen therapy for two days, I was discharged, but I still have symptoms of chest pain. How long is it likely to last? ...


Dr. Yang Wenda reply Pulmonology
Hello: 1. The chance of recurrence is very low, unless you already have small bubbles in your lungs (which is more common in tall and thin individuals, and can be more easily seen on a CT scan), in which case there is a possibility of recurrence. 2. The chest pain symptoms should...

[Read More] Understanding Iatrogenic Pneumothorax from Acupuncture: Risks and Recovery


Understanding Pneumothorax: Recovery Time and Pain Management Tips

I visited a traditional Chinese medicine clinic for acupuncture due to shoulder pain on August 31. After the treatment, I started experiencing chest pain. The next day, I consulted a cardiologist who performed an X-ray and diagnosed me with a pneumothorax. Since the area was smal...


Dr. Zhang Zhengda reply Pulmonology
Hello: Acupuncture in the chest area is very dangerous and can often lead to pneumothorax. Common symptoms include chest pain and difficulty breathing. If the affected area is small, it can be monitored as it will typically reabsorb on its own within about two weeks. Pain relief ...

[Read More] Understanding Pneumothorax: Recovery Time and Pain Management Tips


Can You Get Infected from Acupuncture Needles? Understanding Risks

Hello Doctor: I would like to ask, my father is a carrier of hepatitis B and also has issues with antibiotic-resistant bacteria. If on the evening of the 15th, he had acupuncture and the needle fell on a chair, and then on the 16th, I accidentally pricked myself on the chair but ...


Dr. Xiao Yongxun reply Family Medicine
Dear Mr. Hsiao-Lü: 1. Since 1985, all infants and young children in our country have been vaccinated against hepatitis B, unless there are special circumstances. Therefore, the likelihood of you contracting hepatitis B from your father is extremely low. 2. Regarding accidental ...

[Read More] Can You Get Infected from Acupuncture Needles? Understanding Risks


Understanding Upper Left Back Pain: Causes and Remedies

Hello Dr. Huang, I would like to ask about a situation I experienced a couple of days ago. When I woke up in the morning, I suddenly felt pain in my upper left back. It hurts when I take deep breaths, and it also hurts when I hold my breath or bend over. Could this be due to a st...


Dr. Huang Hongshuo reply Family Medicine
In most cases, this symptom may be caused by inflammation due to muscle or ligament strain, which aligns with your observation that the back muscles may be strained or inflamed. Movements involving inflamed muscles or ligaments can lead to pain and discomfort. It is recommended t...

[Read More] Understanding Upper Left Back Pain: Causes and Remedies


Related FAQ

Pneumothorax

(Pulmonology)

Rib Pain

(Pulmonology)

Sharp Chest Pain

(Pulmonology)

Difficulty Breathing

(Pulmonology)

Chest Tightness

(Pulmonology)

Cold Medicine

(Pulmonology)

Throat Itching

(Pulmonology)

Wheezing, Coughing

(Pulmonology)

Aspiration Pneumonia

(Pulmonology)

Smoking Cessation

(Pulmonology)