Stroke
Hello doctor, I would like to ask again.
My friend's grandfather is over 70 years old and has had a stroke for some time.
Recently, they heard a report on television about the use of placenta extract in Japan that can help stroke patients recover and even stand up and walk.
They are very eager to try it, but my friend feels it might not be possible and is a bit worried that it could be a scam.
Is there any real effectiveness to this treatment?
Xiao Jie, 10~19 year old female. Ask Date: 2005/03/09
Dr. Ye Boshou reply Neurology
Stroke results in the death of brain cells, and after a stroke, brain cells cannot regenerate.
Additionally, placental growth factor does not increase the number of brain cells, making it ineffective in treating strokes.
In fact, my patients have also experienced the use of placental growth factor, but the outcomes were the same.
Reply Date: 2005/03/09
More Info
The use of placenta extract, particularly in the context of stroke recovery, has garnered attention in various media and anecdotal reports. However, it is essential to approach such claims with caution and a critical eye, especially when it comes to medical treatments.
Firstly, it is important to understand what placenta extract is. It is derived from the placenta of mammals, often touted for its supposed regenerative properties due to its rich content of growth factors, hormones, and nutrients. In some cultures, placenta extract has been used in traditional medicine for various ailments, including skin conditions and fatigue. However, scientific evidence supporting its efficacy in stroke recovery is limited and largely anecdotal.
When it comes to stroke recovery, the primary focus should be on established rehabilitation methods. Stroke recovery typically involves a multidisciplinary approach, including physical therapy, occupational therapy, and speech therapy, depending on the areas affected by the stroke. These therapies are designed to help patients regain lost functions and improve their quality of life. The recovery process can be lengthy and varies significantly from person to person, depending on factors such as the severity of the stroke, the area of the brain affected, and the patient's overall health.
Regarding the specific claims about placenta extract helping stroke patients stand up and walk again, it is crucial to note that there is no substantial clinical evidence to support these assertions. While some studies have explored the potential benefits of various growth factors in promoting neural repair, these studies are often preliminary and do not provide conclusive evidence that placenta extract can significantly aid in stroke recovery.
Moreover, the use of placenta extract raises several concerns. The safety and quality of such products can vary widely, and there may be risks associated with their use, including allergic reactions or contamination. Additionally, the regulatory status of placenta extract products can differ by region, and many may not be subject to rigorous testing for efficacy and safety.
In summary, while the idea of using placenta extract for stroke recovery may sound appealing, it is essential to rely on proven rehabilitation strategies and consult with healthcare professionals. If your friend's grandfather is considering trying placenta extract, it would be wise for them to discuss this with his healthcare provider first. The provider can offer guidance based on the latest research and the individual's specific medical condition.
In conclusion, while the search for effective treatments for stroke recovery is ongoing, it is crucial to prioritize evidence-based practices and remain skeptical of unverified claims. Engaging in established rehabilitation therapies and maintaining open communication with healthcare providers will provide the best chances for recovery and improved quality of life after a stroke.
Similar Q&A
Exploring the Benefits and Risks of Placenta Extract for Menopausal Headaches
I have been experiencing headaches since 1995. Could this be related to menopause? A friend suggested that I could benefit from daily injections of placental extract (PLACENTA-H BIO-FARMA) at a dosage of 2ml intramuscularly. Dr. Wang, is there really such miraculous efficacy in p...
Dr. Wang Hanzhou reply Obstetrics and Gynecology
If the cause of the headache cannot be identified, one might consider trying hormone replacement therapy, specifically female hormones. However, there is currently limited research on the use of placental extracts in obstetrics and gynecology, so it may be worth exploring, but be...[Read More] Exploring the Benefits and Risks of Placenta Extract for Menopausal Headaches
Can Dialysis Patients Safely Use Placenta Extract for Health Benefits?
Hello Dr. Yang: A while ago, I traveled to Japan and bought a bottle of placental extract at a duty-free shop. The staff there told me that placental extract can activate human cells, enhance bodily functions, and has no side effects for dialysis patients. Since my mother is a di...
Dr. Yang Zhangzhi reply Urology
The active ingredients of placental extract are unclear, and its efficacy is uncertain; therefore, dialysis patients are advised against using it blindly.[Read More] Can Dialysis Patients Safely Use Placenta Extract for Health Benefits?
Is Drinking Postpartum Herbal Soup Safe for Uterine Recovery?
Hello, doctor. I just gave birth three days ago. My mother-in-law has prepared a herbal soup for me to drink. Is that okay? Does this herbal soup promote uterine contractions? Thank you!
Dr. Lin Wenbin reply Obstetrics and Gynecology
The herbal formula known as "Shenghua Decoction," which contains ingredients like safflower, is believed to promote blood circulation and break up blood stasis. In my opinion, with the current standards of natural childbirth, physicians ensure that the placenta is deliv...[Read More] Is Drinking Postpartum Herbal Soup Safe for Uterine Recovery?
Can Hepatitis C Patients Safely Use Placenta Extract During Treatment?
I have hepatitis C and am currently undergoing interferon treatment. Someone suggested administering placenta extract. Will this affect my treatment?
Dr. Chen Zhiping reply Gastroenterology and Hepatology
Hello, I apologize for your question, but I am unable to answer it. I'm not sure if there will be any interactions between the two.[Read More] Can Hepatitis C Patients Safely Use Placenta Extract During Treatment?
Related FAQ
(Neurology)
Stroke(Rehabilitation)
Stroke(Pediatrics)
Stroke(Internal Medicine)
Migraine(Neurology)
Electroencephalogram(Neurology)
Post-Car Accident(Neurology)
Cervical Ultrasound(Neurology)
Palm(Neurology)
Intracranial Hemorrhage(Neurology)