Nail Injuries: Should You Remove or Protect a Split Nail? - Surgery

Share to:

Nail


When your nail splits in the middle while bowling, and the crack is wide but some parts are still attached to the nail bed, it's not uncommon to experience little to no pain.
In this case, it may not be necessary to go to the hospital for removal.
You can consider using adhesive bandages to protect the area and prevent further pulling or irritation.

It's generally advisable not to cut the broken nail if it is still partially attached, as this can allow the new nail to grow underneath without interference.
However, if the nail becomes painful, shows signs of infection, or if you notice any unusual changes, it would be best to consult a healthcare professional.
The condition of the existing nail can potentially affect the growth of the new nail, so monitoring the situation is important.
Thank you!

Tina, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2005/08/08

Dr. Huang Junxiong reply Surgery


Hello: If there is a nail fracture, dislocation, or significant deformation due to a contusion, nail removal may aid in the subsequent recovery.
It is advisable to consult a clinical physician (surgeon) for evaluation and discussion.
Additionally, the presence of the remaining nail can sometimes affect the speed of new nail growth, which is also a consideration for removal.
Wishing you good health!

Reply Date: 2005/08/08

More Info


When dealing with a split nail, especially one that has a significant crack and is partially attached to the nail bed, it's essential to approach the situation with care. Here’s a comprehensive guide on how to handle this type of nail injury.


Understanding Nail Injuries
Nail injuries can occur due to various reasons, including trauma from activities like bowling, where the nail may be subjected to excessive force. A split nail can be classified as either a superficial injury, where the nail plate is damaged but the nail bed remains intact, or a more severe injury where the nail bed is also affected. In your case, since the split is wide but still partially attached, it suggests that the injury might not be severe, especially if you are not experiencing pain.


Should You Remove or Protect the Split Nail?
1. Assess the Injury: First, examine the extent of the split. If the nail is still attached to the nail bed and there is no bleeding or severe pain, it may not require immediate removal. However, if the nail is hanging loosely or if there is significant pain, it might be advisable to seek medical attention.

2. Protection: If the split nail is stable and you are not in pain, protecting it is often the best course of action. You can use adhesive bandages or medical tape to cover the nail and prevent it from catching on clothing or other objects. This will help reduce the risk of further injury and allow the nail to heal.

3. Avoiding Removal: It is generally not necessary to remove a split nail unless it is causing pain or there is a risk of infection. If the nail is still partially attached and not causing discomfort, allowing it to remain can be beneficial. The new nail will grow underneath, and the old nail will eventually fall off as the new one grows out.


Will It Affect New Nail Growth?
In most cases, a split nail will not significantly affect the growth of a new nail, provided that the nail bed is intact and healthy. The new nail will grow from the nail matrix, which is located at the base of the nail under the cuticle. If the matrix is undamaged, the new nail should grow normally.

However, if the injury leads to an infection or if the nail bed is severely damaged, it could potentially affect the appearance and growth of the new nail. Signs of infection include increased redness, swelling, warmth, or discharge from the area. If you notice any of these symptoms, it is crucial to seek medical attention promptly.


When to Seek Medical Attention
You should consider visiting a healthcare professional if:
- The nail is completely detached or hanging loosely.

- There is significant pain or discomfort.

- You notice signs of infection.

- You are unsure about the extent of the injury.

A healthcare provider can assess the injury, provide appropriate treatment, and advise you on whether the nail needs to be removed or if it can heal on its own.


Conclusion
In summary, if your split nail is stable and not causing pain, it is generally advisable to protect it rather than remove it. Use adhesive bandages to shield the nail from further injury and allow it to heal naturally. Monitor for any signs of infection, and if you have concerns about the injury or its impact on nail growth, consult a healthcare professional for personalized advice. Taking these steps will help ensure the best outcome for your nail injury.

Similar Q&A

Dealing with a Split Toenail: Should You Cut It or Leave It?

This morning, I injured my toenail, causing it to bleed and partially tear. A small piece of the nail is still attached to the skin. Should I trim it off or leave it alone?


Dr. Wu Yuxin reply Dermatology
If it is unstable, it is recommended to dispose of it.

[Read More] Dealing with a Split Toenail: Should You Cut It or Leave It?


How to Treat Nail Separation After Injury: Expert Dermatologist Advice

Hello doctor, after I fell off my bike, I noticed that my toenail on my big toe is slightly detached. The root is still connected, but the nail is hollow inside. I have seen a doctor who said that the nail does not need to be removed yet. However, recently after showering, I foun...


Dr. Li Yufen reply Dermatology
Hello: After a nail injury, the nail bed may separate, and it can take several months for a new nail to grow back. If the separation is quite noticeable, you can lightly secure it with breathable tape to prevent further injury. If the skin condition does not improve or worsens, i...

[Read More] How to Treat Nail Separation After Injury: Expert Dermatologist Advice


Should I Remove a Half-Detached Nail After Injury?

After my nail came off, I used a small pair of scissors to cut away the gel manicure portion. The left side of the nail has come out from the nail bed, while the right side is still attached, so it's half detached and half still connected. After cutting it, I couldn't p...


Dr. Chen Ronghong reply Surgery
Hello, based on your description, there is no need to remove the nail unless the remaining part is causing pain or is prone to snagging on objects, in which case medical intervention for removal would be necessary.

[Read More] Should I Remove a Half-Detached Nail After Injury?


Managing Nail Fragments After Finger Suturing: What to Do?

Hello Doctor, recently I had an accident where the tip of my finger and the side of my nail had some flesh removed. The emergency doctor performed a suturing procedure to stop the bleeding, stitching from the area of the nail, which resulted in half of the nail being cut off. How...


Dr. Wu Yuxin reply Dermatology
You should consult your attending physician about this issue.

[Read More] Managing Nail Fragments After Finger Suturing: What to Do?


Related FAQ

Nails

(Surgery)

Toe Injury

(Surgery)

Toe Fractures

(Orthopedics)

Nail Infection

(Dermatology)

Cat Scratch Or Bite

(Surgery)

Scar

(Surgery)

Bruising

(Surgery)

Cellulitis

(Surgery)

Wounds From Car Accident

(Surgery)

Dog Bite

(Surgery)