Whole Milk vs. Skim Milk: What's Best for Your Toddler's Nutrition? - Pediatrics

Share to:

Is low-fat better or whole-fat?


Hello Dr.
Lin: My child is currently 2 years old, and I would like to ask you a few questions.
1.
I have heard that it is better for children to drink whole milk.
Is this true? 2.
Is the nutritional content of goat's milk inferior to that of cow's milk? 3.
What is CPP (casein phosphopeptides) that is added to calcium powder? I was told by a pharmacy staff that it can help with calcium absorption.
4.
Does adding nutritional supplements (such as calcium powder, multivitamins, probiotics, etc.) to milk actually help children grow, or could it potentially create a burden instead? Thank you!

Cao Ma, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2005/09/16

Dr. Lin Huizhen reply Pediatrics


Dear Ms.
Tsao,
I am Dr.
Lin Huizhen, the Director of the Pediatrics Department at Tainan Hospital, Ministry of Health and Welfare.

1.
It is essential for developing children to consume full-fat products! However, since there are many sources of dietary fats available for children today, if a child has a limited intake of other food types, drinking whole milk is appropriate.

2.
The nutritional content of goat's milk is lacking in certain components (such as folate) compared to cow's milk.

3.
I am not very familiar with such products.

4.
Generally, if children have a sufficient variety and quantity of food in their diet, there is no need for additional supplementation.
However, the extent to which individuals can absorb added nutrients in milk varies from person to person, and the claimed effects are uncertain.

Wishing you good health and all the best,
Pediatrics Department, Tainan Hospital

Reply Date: 2005/09/16

More Info


When it comes to choosing the right type of milk for toddlers, the debate between whole milk and skim milk is quite significant. For a two-year-old child, whole milk is generally recommended due to its nutritional profile. Whole milk contains essential fats that are crucial for a toddler's growth and brain development. The fat content in whole milk provides energy and helps in the absorption of fat-soluble vitamins such as A, D, E, and K.
1. Whole Milk vs. Skim Milk: It is indeed true that whole milk is often recommended for children under the age of two. This is because toddlers require higher fat content in their diets to support their rapid growth and development. Skim milk, while lower in calories and fat, may not provide the necessary energy that toddlers need. The American Academy of Pediatrics suggests that children aged 1 to 2 years should consume whole milk unless there are specific health concerns that warrant a lower fat option.

2. Nutritional Comparison of Goat Milk and Cow Milk: Goat milk is often considered a good alternative to cow milk, especially for children who may have sensitivities to cow's milk. Goat milk has a different protein structure and is generally easier to digest. However, it is important to note that goat milk does not contain as much folate as cow milk and may not have sufficient levels of certain vitamins unless fortified. Therefore, while goat milk can be a nutritious option, it should be chosen based on the child's specific dietary needs and preferences.

3. Understanding CPP (Casein Phosphopeptides): CPPs are bioactive peptides derived from casein, a protein found in milk. They are known to enhance calcium absorption in the body. When added to calcium supplements, CPPs can help improve the bioavailability of calcium, making it easier for the body to utilize this essential mineral. This can be particularly beneficial for children who may not be getting enough calcium from their diet.

4. Adding Nutritional Supplements to Milk: The addition of nutritional supplements such as calcium powder, multivitamins, or probiotics to milk can be beneficial, but it should be approached with caution. While these supplements can help fill nutritional gaps, over-supplementation can lead to an imbalance and may place unnecessary stress on the child's digestive system. It is crucial to consult with a pediatrician or a nutritionist before introducing any supplements to ensure they are appropriate for the child's age, health status, and dietary needs.

In summary, for your two-year-old, whole milk is typically the best choice due to its higher fat content, which supports growth and development. Goat milk can be a suitable alternative if there are concerns about cow's milk. Understanding the role of CPPs can help in making informed decisions about calcium supplementation. Lastly, while adding supplements can be beneficial, it is essential to do so under professional guidance to avoid potential negative effects. Always prioritize a balanced diet that includes a variety of foods to meet your child's nutritional needs.

Similar Q&A

Fresh Milk vs. Formula: Which is Better for Your Toddler's Nutrition?

Hello, Nutritionist: My daughter is currently 1 year and 9 months old. Since she was 1 year and 7 months, I have replaced all her formula milk with regular whole milk. In the morning, she drinks about 180cc of goat milk from Chianan, about 150cc of full-fat cow's milk from G...


Dr. Shi Guimei reply Nutrition
Hello! For children over one year old, dairy sources can include either fresh milk or formula milk. If a child has external moles, it is advisable to first check if they are consuming enough vegetables and fruits during their meals, as well as whether they are not drinking enough...

[Read More] Fresh Milk vs. Formula: Which is Better for Your Toddler's Nutrition?


Can Toddlers Drink Fresh Milk? Understanding Pediatric Guidelines

Hello! Recently, my baby has shown some signs of milk aversion. In the morning, after waking up, he should be very hungry, but he only drinks a few sips and then refuses to continue. He only reluctantly finishes when he is sleepy, and the amount of milk he consumes has also decre...


Dr. Wang Jiayi reply Pediatrics
Dear Miss Lin: A one-year-old baby can drink commercially available whole milk without causing adverse effects on the kidneys. It is advisable to use whole milk rather than skim milk. Children should consume a variety of adult meal foods, but it is best to avoid greasy, fried, he...

[Read More] Can Toddlers Drink Fresh Milk? Understanding Pediatric Guidelines


Which Age Groups Should Drink Whole vs. Skim Milk?

Hello: May I ask 1. Which age groups are suitable for whole milk and skim milk? 2. What are the differences between whole milk and skim milk? Thank you!


Dr. Shi Guimei reply Nutrition
Dear Dolphin, Hello! Whether it is whole milk, low-fat milk, or skim milk, each serving is 240cc. Whole milk contains 8 grams of protein, 8 grams of fat, 12 grams of carbohydrates, and 150 calories per serving. Low-fat milk contains 8 grams of protein, 4 grams of fat, 12 grams o...

[Read More] Which Age Groups Should Drink Whole vs. Skim Milk?


Concerns About Toddler Nutrition: Milk-Only Diet and Growth Issues

Hello Dr. Chang, My son is 2 years and 1 month old, but he does not like to eat solid food and only drinks milk, three times a day. I am concerned whether he is getting enough nutrition and if his growth and development might be affected. He is currently 90 cm tall and weighs 1...


Dr. Zhang Wenwang reply Pediatrics
Dear Concerned Mother, 1. In fact, height and weight are significantly influenced by genetics. Your baby's growth curve shows a height around the 75th percentile, while the weight is slightly lighter at about the 25th percentile relative to height. 2. Regarding the intake ...

[Read More] Concerns About Toddler Nutrition: Milk-Only Diet and Growth Issues


Related FAQ

Infant Formula

(Pediatrics)

Breastfeeding

(Pediatrics)

Complementary Foods

(Pediatrics)

Diet

(Pediatrics)

Infant Nutrition

(Nutrition)

Kidney

(Pediatrics)

Baby Stool

(Pediatrics)

Tongue

(Pediatrics)

Bedwetting

(Pediatrics)

Thalassemia

(Pediatrics)