Is traditional Chinese medicine effective for stroke?
My father had a stroke 5 years ago, and a few days ago, an old classmate recommended a type of scientific traditional Chinese medicine, claiming it would improve his condition.
What is the difference between traditional Chinese medicine and scientific traditional Chinese medicine? Is traditional Chinese medicine effective? The treatment costs over $10,000 in less than a month; is this a scam?
Xiao Jie, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2005/12/06
Dr. Yan Sumei reply Traditional Chinese Medicine
Scientific Chinese medicine is concentrated into powder or small granules after being decocted in a GMP-certified pharmaceutical factory.
Traditional Chinese medicine is generally divided into decoction pieces and crude drug powders.
Decoction pieces are the herbal medicines purchased for brewing, while crude drug powders are made by grinding the herbs directly without undergoing the decoction and concentration process.
A medical expense of over ten thousand is exorbitant and may be related to direct sales products.
The primary purpose of taking scientific Chinese medicine is to promote the flow of meridians and regulate Qi and blood.
During the six months to one year following a stroke, consistent rehabilitation can lead to improvements in mobility.
For someone who had a stroke five years ago, the medication is mainly for maintenance and preventive care to avoid another stroke, and it offers little help for the flexibility of limbs affected by nerve damage.
Reply Date: 2005/12/06
More Info
Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) has been a part of healthcare for thousands of years and is often sought after for various conditions, including stroke recovery. However, the effectiveness of TCM, particularly in the context of stroke recovery, can vary widely depending on several factors, including the specific herbs used, the individual’s overall health, and the timing of treatment.
Firstly, it's essential to understand the difference between traditional herbal remedies and what is referred to as "scientific herbal medicine." Traditional herbal medicine typically involves the use of whole plants or plant parts, often in combinations that have been used for generations. In contrast, scientific herbal medicine may involve standardized extracts or formulations that have undergone clinical testing to determine their efficacy and safety. This distinction is crucial because while traditional remedies may have anecdotal support, scientific formulations are often backed by research.
In the case of stroke recovery, TCM approaches the condition by focusing on restoring balance and promoting circulation. Common herbs used in TCM for stroke recovery include Ginkgo biloba, which is known for its potential to improve blood flow and cognitive function, and various other herbs that may help with qi (energy) and blood circulation. However, the effectiveness of these herbs can be subjective and may not be universally accepted in Western medicine.
Regarding the cost of herbal treatments, it is essential to approach any treatment with a critical eye, especially if the cost is significantly high, such as the 10,000+ you mentioned for less than a month’s supply. While some herbal treatments can be expensive, it is crucial to evaluate whether the cost aligns with the expected benefits. If the claims seem too good to be true, or if there is a lack of scientific evidence supporting the treatment, it may be wise to proceed with caution. Consulting with a qualified healthcare provider who understands both TCM and Western medicine can provide a more balanced perspective.
Moreover, stroke recovery is a multifaceted process that often requires a combination of therapies. While TCM can play a role, it should not replace conventional medical treatments, especially in the acute phase following a stroke. Rehabilitation therapies, including physical therapy, occupational therapy, and speech therapy, are critical for improving function and quality of life after a stroke. These therapies have a solid evidence base supporting their effectiveness and should be part of any recovery plan.
In conclusion, while TCM may offer some benefits for stroke recovery, it is essential to approach it with a critical mindset. The effectiveness of herbal treatments can vary, and the high cost of certain products should be carefully considered. It is advisable to consult with healthcare professionals who can provide guidance on integrating TCM with conventional treatments for a more comprehensive approach to stroke recovery. Always prioritize evidence-based practices and ensure that any treatment plan is tailored to the individual’s specific needs and circumstances.
Similar Q&A
Exploring Acupuncture for Stroke Recovery After 15 Years
Hello Dr. He: I am a stroke patient who has been suffering for 15 years. My stroke was caused by a hemorrhage in the brainstem, and the blood clot has since been absorbed. In the past few years, I underwent rehabilitation at a Western medicine hospital, but the results were not s...
Dr. He Yujun reply Traditional Chinese Medicine
Hello: You may need to come to the clinic for a thorough assessment to understand your current physical activity status. Traditional Chinese medicine acupuncture can enhance the flow of Qi and blood by stimulating meridian points. While it may not provide immediate significant ef...[Read More] Exploring Acupuncture for Stroke Recovery After 15 Years
Can Mild Stroke Patients Safely Use Traditional Chinese Medicine?
Can a person who has had a mild stroke continue to drink traditional Chinese medicine? My mother has had a mild stroke and feels that drinking traditional Chinese medicine doesn't seem to have much effect. Can I take her to see a traditional Chinese medicine practitioner for...
Dr. Lan Shengxing reply Neurology
The most important things after a stroke are rehabilitation and preventing a subsequent stroke. Therefore, continuing to take medication to prevent another occurrence is crucial. It is not that the medication is ineffective; in fact, the absence of a recurrence is its effectivene...[Read More] Can Mild Stroke Patients Safely Use Traditional Chinese Medicine?
Can Traditional Chinese Medicine Help Post-Stroke Recovery at 65?
I would like to ask, my father is 65 years old and had a stroke, resulting in complete immobility of his left hand and left leg. He is already on a fixed regimen of Western medication. Can traditional Chinese medicine help with his condition, or is rehabilitation the only option ...
Dr. Ding Hanxiang reply Traditional Chinese Medicine
Hello: The golden period for stroke treatment is six months, and it also depends on the extent of brain damage. If it exceeds six months, it is more difficult to achieve significant improvement. It is recommended that Western rehabilitation should not be interrupted, and acupunct...[Read More] Can Traditional Chinese Medicine Help Post-Stroke Recovery at 65?
Exploring Traditional Chinese Medicine Alternatives for Stroke Recovery
My mother previously experienced a mild stroke and sought treatment at the Neurology Department of Kaohsiung Chang Gung Memorial Hospital, where the doctor prescribed the following medications: Trenfylline, Bokey, Wesu tab, and Lescol XL. I would like to ask if there are any herb...
Dr. Lin Qingzhong reply Traditional Chinese Medicine
Dear Mr. Ren / Online User 028, 1. Trenfylline, known as Xuexinmin, is a new brand name for the old drug Trental. Bokey is a new packaging for the old drug Aspirin. Wesu tab is an aluminum-containing antacid, and Lescol XL is a medication that lowers blood lipids. In summary, th...[Read More] Exploring Traditional Chinese Medicine Alternatives for Stroke Recovery
Related FAQ
(Rehabilitation)
Traditional Chinese Medicine(Neurology)
Postpartum Recovery(Traditional Chinese Medicine)
Herbal Decoction(Traditional Chinese Medicine)
Traditional Chinese Medicine Consultation(Traditional Chinese Medicine)
Weight Loss(Traditional Chinese Medicine)
Acid Reflux(Traditional Chinese Medicine)
Heart(Traditional Chinese Medicine)
Headache(Traditional Chinese Medicine)
Lower Back(Traditional Chinese Medicine)