Does attempting to walk stimulate bone healing?
Dear Director Shih,
I have greatly benefited from reading your detailed responses regarding fracture issues.
I have some questions to ask you, and I appreciate your time amidst your busy schedule!
I sustained a tibial fracture in the middle of my left calf due to a car accident.
Since the fracture is clean and the fibula is intact, my attending physician recommended that I do not require surgery and that I should use a cast for a prolonged period to allow for natural healing.
It has been a month since the accident, and the cast extends from my thigh down to the bottom of my foot.
Some people have suggested that I "try using assistive devices and allow my foot to touch the ground while walking" to stimulate bone healing.
However, the weight of the cast makes the fracture site very sore, making walking difficult.
Is this a correct approach?
Additionally, when I move my foot, I sometimes hear a sound that feels like the fractured bone is rubbing against something.
Is this a normal phenomenon, or does it indicate that the bone is not adequately stabilized?
Thank you for your professional insights! Wishing you all the best!
Ya Yan, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2005/12/11
Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
Your condition may require evaluation by a physician to determine if you can begin walking.
If the fracture is non-displaced and remains stable after being cast, you may be able to attempt walking, but you must use crutches and avoid putting too much weight on the affected leg.
Generally, this type of activity can be initiated about two months after the fracture.
Initially, it will likely be uncomfortable, as blood will rush to the lower leg, causing a feeling of swelling.
However, after several attempts, this discomfort should gradually improve.
Don't forget to return for an X-ray at three months to check if the fracture has healed.
Reply Date: 2005/12/11
More Info
Walking can indeed play a role in stimulating bone healing after a fracture, but it is essential to approach this activity with caution and under the guidance of a healthcare professional. The healing process of bones involves several stages, and mechanical loading—such as walking—can promote bone remodeling and healing. However, the timing and extent of weight-bearing activities depend on the type and severity of the fracture, as well as the individual’s overall health and recovery progress.
In your case, you have sustained a tibial fracture that has been stabilized with a cast. Since your fracture is described as non-displaced and stable, your doctor’s recommendation to avoid surgery and allow for natural healing is common practice. Typically, after a fracture, the initial phase of healing involves immobilization to allow the bone to form a callus, which is a temporary structure that stabilizes the fracture site. This phase usually lasts for several weeks.
After about four to six weeks, if the fracture is stable and there are no signs of complications, many physicians will encourage gradual weight-bearing activities. This is because applying gentle pressure to the bone can stimulate osteoblast activity, which is crucial for bone formation. However, it is vital to start slowly and use assistive devices like crutches or a walker to avoid putting too much stress on the healing bone.
Regarding the discomfort you experience when attempting to walk, it is not uncommon for individuals to feel pain or discomfort in the area of the fracture, especially when beginning to bear weight. This discomfort can be attributed to several factors, including muscle weakness, joint stiffness, and the body adjusting to the new demands placed on it. The sensation of bones rubbing or making noise can also occur, particularly if there is still some swelling or if the surrounding soft tissues are not yet fully healed. However, if you experience significant pain or if the noise is accompanied by other concerning symptoms (like swelling or instability), it is crucial to consult your physician.
It is essential to follow your doctor’s advice regarding the timing of weight-bearing activities and to have regular follow-ups to monitor the healing process. Typically, X-rays are taken at intervals to assess the progress of bone healing. If your doctor has indicated that you can begin to bear weight, it is advisable to do so gradually, listening to your body and stopping if you experience excessive pain.
In summary, walking can stimulate bone healing after a fracture, but it should be done cautiously and under medical supervision. If you have any doubts or concerns about your recovery process, it is best to discuss them with your healthcare provider, who can provide personalized advice based on your specific situation. Remember that the goal is to promote healing while minimizing the risk of re-injury or complications.
Similar Q&A
Does Walking After a Fracture Affect Bone Healing?
Doctor, I have a fracture in my right hand, but I go for a brisk walk for over an hour every day after meals. Will this affect the healing of my bone?
Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
It is important to assess the location of the fracture and whether you are moving the fractured area during exercise. If you are only brisk walking and not engaging the fractured site, it should not be a concern. If the fracture is in the fingers, hand, wrist, or forearm, as long...[Read More] Does Walking After a Fracture Affect Bone Healing?
Understanding Delayed Bone Healing After Open Fracture Surgery
Hello Doctor, I was in a car accident at the end of last year and sustained an open and comminuted fracture of my right thigh, for which I had a steel plate implanted. I underwent three debridement surgeries, and now, five months later, during my last follow-up, the doctor mentio...
Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
Complete healing without any gaps is necessary before one can walk with strength. Stable bone support is essential for promoting bone growth. Comminuted fractures are typically more challenging to heal; however, if healing does not occur, one must consider whether to undergo bone...[Read More] Understanding Delayed Bone Healing After Open Fracture Surgery
Managing Disuse Osteoporosis After a Fracture: Treatment and Dietary Tips
Hello doctor, I have had a foot fracture for over two months. Recent X-rays show that the fracture has healed, but there is a significant presence of osteoporosis. What treatment do you recommend? What dietary considerations should I keep in mind? Thank you very much.
Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
After a fracture has healed, it is generally safe to walk or bear weight. Normal weight-bearing activities can stimulate bone density increase. Additionally, it is important to supplement with vitamin D and calcium, and to maintain regular exercise to promote recovery.[Read More] Managing Disuse Osteoporosis After a Fracture: Treatment and Dietary Tips
Post-Fracture Rehabilitation: Key Questions for a Smooth Recovery
Hello Dr. Lee: I am the one who asked a question on May 17th. Thank you for your blessings. Yesterday (which was seven months and twenty days after my fracture), I went for a follow-up appointment, and the doctor said that the fracture has healed and that I can start walking with...
Dr. Li Wenlin reply Orthopedics
Hello: In response to your questions, please have confidence in yourself, especially since your attending physician has reviewed your imaging and provided appropriate instructions. Question 1: Please use your crutches without fear. Question 2: Normal individuals do not re-fra...[Read More] Post-Fracture Rehabilitation: Key Questions for a Smooth Recovery
Related FAQ
(Orthopedics)
Post-Fracture Rehabilitation(Orthopedics)
Post-Tibial Fracture Surgery(Orthopedics)
Ankle Fracture Recovery(Orthopedics)
Fracture(Rehabilitation)
Post-Clavicle Fracture Surgery(Orthopedics)
Metatarsal Fracture(Orthopedics)
Fibula Fracture(Orthopedics)
Open Fracture(Orthopedics)
Osteomyelitis(Orthopedics)