Comminuted Fractures: Healing Concerns and Recovery Tips - Orthopedics

Share to:

Comminuted fracture


Hello, Doctor: My husband had a car accident in mid-November last year, resulting in a comminuted fracture of the right tibia and a clavicle fracture.
He had steel nails and plates inserted (he is 36 years old).
It has been over three months now, but the doctor said the clavicle has healed, while there are no signs of healing in the tibia, which is very concerning.
I would like to ask the doctor: 1.
Is this considered normal? 2.
How can we promote faster bone healing? 3.
Are there specific foods or rehabilitation exercises he should do? 4.
How long can we wait before considering bone graft surgery if there is no healing? 5.
If he undergoes bone graft surgery, is there a guarantee that it will heal completely? Thank you for your assistance!

Xiao Yun, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2006/03/08

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics


Fractures of the tibia (shinbone) that are comminuted often lead to poor healing or nonunion, as the extent of the fracture typically results in damage to the surrounding soft tissues (skin, subcutaneous tissue, blood vessels, nerves, etc.) to varying degrees.
Generally, if a tibial fracture has not healed within six months, it is classified as delayed union, and if it has not healed after one year, it is termed nonunion.
A balanced diet is usually sufficient for healing.
If nonunion is due to a bone defect, performing a bone grafting (autologous bone graft) surgery is typically the better option.
In cases of simple delayed union, it may be advisable to wait and see; however, the stability of the fixation with bone screws significantly impacts the healing process.
The chances of healing are greatly increased after bone grafting surgery, and in some more complicated cases, multiple procedures may be necessary.

Reply Date: 2006/03/08

More Info


Comminuted fractures, such as the one your husband has sustained, can indeed pose significant challenges in terms of healing and recovery. Given the complexity of his injuries, including a comminuted fracture of the tibia and a clavicle fracture, it is understandable that you have concerns about the healing process. Let’s address your questions one by one.

1. Is this normal?
It is not uncommon for comminuted fractures to take longer to heal compared to simpler fractures. The healing process can be influenced by several factors, including the severity of the fracture, the patient's age, overall health, and any underlying medical conditions. In your husband's case, the fact that the clavicle has healed while the tibia has not may indicate that the tibia fracture is more complex or that there are other factors at play, such as blood supply to the area or the stability of the fracture fixation.

2. How can bone healing be accelerated?
To promote faster healing of the bone, several strategies can be employed:
- Nutrition: Ensure a diet rich in calcium and vitamin D, which are essential for bone health. Foods such as dairy products, leafy greens, fish, and fortified cereals can be beneficial. Additionally, protein is crucial for tissue repair, so include lean meats, beans, and legumes in the diet.

- Hydration: Staying well-hydrated is important for overall health and can aid in the healing process.

- Avoiding smoking and excessive alcohol consumption: Both can significantly impair bone healing.

- Physical therapy: Once cleared by the doctor, engaging in physical therapy can help improve circulation to the area and promote healing.

3. What foods or rehabilitation activities should be considered?
As mentioned, focus on a balanced diet that includes calcium and vitamin D. Foods like yogurt, cheese, almonds, and fatty fish (like salmon) are excellent choices. In terms of rehabilitation, gentle range-of-motion exercises may be recommended to maintain joint mobility and prevent stiffness, but these should only be done under the guidance of a healthcare professional to avoid stressing the healing bone.

4. When should surgery be considered for bone grafting?
If there is no evidence of healing after a certain period—typically around 3 to 6 months, depending on the fracture and the individual’s health—your husband’s orthopedic surgeon may consider surgical options such as bone grafting. This procedure involves transplanting bone tissue to facilitate healing. The decision will depend on various factors, including the type of fracture, the patient’s overall health, and the presence of any complications.

5. Will surgery guarantee complete healing?
While bone grafting can significantly improve the chances of healing, it does not guarantee that the bone will heal completely. The success of the procedure depends on various factors, including the patient’s health, adherence to post-operative care, and the biological response to the graft. Regular follow-ups with the orthopedic surgeon will be essential to monitor healing progress.

In conclusion, it is crucial to maintain open communication with your husband’s healthcare team. They can provide tailored advice based on his specific situation and monitor his recovery closely. Encourage him to follow medical advice, maintain a healthy diet, and engage in appropriate rehabilitation activities to support his healing process. If there are any concerns about his recovery, do not hesitate to reach out to his doctor for further evaluation and guidance.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Open and Comminuted Fractures: Recovery and Rehabilitation Insights

Hello Dr. Shi, I would like to ask you some questions. On October 1, 2015, I jumped from a height and was diagnosed with an open fracture of the right tibia with internal fixation using steel nails. I underwent surgery, and the surgeon mentioned that there were bone fragments tha...


Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
An open fracture refers to a fracture where there is a wound in the skin, connecting the fracture to the outside environment. If the fractured bone ends have protruded through the skin, it is considered a more severe open fracture. Some open fractures may only have a small wound ...

[Read More] Understanding Open and Comminuted Fractures: Recovery and Rehabilitation Insights


Understanding Complications and Recovery from Comminuted Knee Fractures

Hello Dr. Chou, In early August 2003, I was involved in a car accident that resulted in a comminuted fracture of my left knee joint. Since the treatment, I have experienced the following situations: (1) On August 6, I underwent surgery at Mackay Memorial Hospital for reconstruct...


Dr. Zhou Lizhi reply Orthopedics
Hello: 1. Comminuted fractures around the joints are complex injuries, especially in the knee joint, which contains the anterior and posterior cruciate ligaments and the meniscus. A comprehensive approach is necessary to achieve good outcomes. 2. Generally, fractures take about t...

[Read More] Understanding Complications and Recovery from Comminuted Knee Fractures


Understanding Non-Healing Fractures: Challenges in Orthopedic Recovery

A comminuted fracture of the radius has not healed after more than 8 months. There is a noticeable bulge at the surgical site where the plate is located when touching the area. Rotating the hand causes pain, especially when bending the fingers upwards. There is also a popping sou...


Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
If a fracture has not yet healed, it is important to wait for it to heal and not to abandon treatment. You can return to the physician for follow-up. If it still does not improve, you can seek alternative treatment options.

[Read More] Understanding Non-Healing Fractures: Challenges in Orthopedic Recovery


Understanding Comminuted Fractures: Plates vs. Nails and Healing Time

Hello doctor, I would like to ask whether a comminuted fracture should be treated with a plate or screws? What types of plates are available? Generally, how long does it take for a comminuted fracture to heal? What constitutes nonunion in bone healing?


Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
To determine the type of fixation plate material to use, such as stainless steel or titanium alloy, it is essential to examine the morphology of the fracture. There are various types of fractures based on their shapes. If a fracture heals in a misaligned manner or deviates signif...

[Read More] Understanding Comminuted Fractures: Plates vs. Nails and Healing Time


Related FAQ

Fracture Healing

(Orthopedics)

Ankle Fracture Recovery

(Orthopedics)

Post-Fracture Rehabilitation

(Orthopedics)

Closed Fracture

(Orthopedics)

Fibula Fracture

(Orthopedics)

Coccygeal Fracture

(Orthopedics)

Post-Femoral Fracture Surgery

(Orthopedics)

Clavicle Fracture

(Orthopedics)

Fracture

(Rehabilitation)

Metacarpal Fracture

(Orthopedics)