Navigating Complex Orthopedic Issues After a Car Accident

Q: Navigating Complex Orthopedic Issues After a Car Accident

Dear netizen： The symptoms you described, such as "aching and tingling sensations in both legs," could indeed be indicative of sciatica caused by lumbar spine issues. <br>However, further physical examination and possibly imaging studies are necessary to confirm the diagnosis. <b

My ailments torment me so much~~

I was involved in a car accident a year ago, resulting in a fracture and protrusion between my left neck and clavicle, as well as a deviation of the left neck muscles.
Approximately a year ago, after the accident, I consulted many doctors at the hospital, and most advised against surgical treatment due to the dangerous nature of surgery in the area where various blood vessels and nerves intersect near the heart.
However, I have encountered several cases similar to mine where surgery was performed successfully, and they had their surgeries during the critical period shortly after the injury.
Because the doctors at the hospital warned me about the surgical risks, I have delayed treatment until now.
The left clavicle fracture and ligament protrusion have since developed scar tissue, but I am still experiencing discomfort affecting the movement of my left arm and causing pressure on the neck muscles.
After seeing so many doctors, my confidence in the healthcare system in Taiwan has diminished, and I have lacked the courage to continue seeking treatment.
However, the discomfort from my injuries has persisted.
Recently, I learned about a successful case from Dr.
Liu at Tzu Chi Hospital, which has given me some hope.
I am concerned that I may have missed the optimal surgical window.
I would like to ask if undergoing surgery for the left clavicle ligament fracture and protrusion is indeed very dangerous.
I have seen Dr.
Liu, who is a meticulous and caring physician, but unfortunately, I consulted him just before he went abroad.
I hope to have him reassess my situation for potential surgical treatment upon his return.
I have never undergone surgery before, and I am anxious about the risks as many doctors have mentioned.

Another issue I have is that since the car accident, I have been experiencing persistent soreness and a tingling sensation in both legs.
Other hospitals have indicated that this may be due to sciatic nerve compression, while some doctors have mentioned degenerative changes in the sciatic nerve or sciatica, leading to various interpretations of my condition.
Recently, a friend took me to meet a doctor who suggested that I might have osteoporosis or calcium deficiency, and he recommended that the hospital conduct a bone density test during treatment.
I am unsure whether my condition is due to sciatic nerve compression, degenerative changes, or sciatica, and I would like to know which specialty I should consult for this issue.
I am confused about what my condition is.
I would greatly appreciate your guidance.
Thank you!

Mr. Hsu, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2006/04/04

Dr. Chen Xingyuan reply Orthopedics

Dear netizen: The symptoms you described, such as "aching and tingling sensations in both legs," could indeed be indicative of sciatica caused by lumbar spine issues.
However, further physical examination and possibly imaging studies are necessary to confirm the diagnosis.
You may consider consulting an orthopedic specialist for evaluation.
Since you are still young and generally in good health, it is unlikely that your symptoms are related to osteoporosis caused by calcium deficiency.
Bone density typically reaches its peak around the age of thirty and then gradually declines.
It would be beneficial to undergo a bone density test to assess your bone health.
Any surgical procedure carries risks; fortunately, advancements in medicine and the increased focus on "patient safety" in recent years have significantly reduced the incidence of adverse events related to surgery or anesthesia.
However, individual circumstances vary, so I encourage you to have a thorough discussion with the surgeon who will be performing the procedure.
Wishing you health and safety! Sincerely, Dr.
Chen.

Reply Date: 2006/04/04

More Info

Navigating complex orthopedic issues after a car accident can be incredibly challenging, especially when dealing with multiple opinions and the potential for serious complications. Your situation, involving a left clavicle fracture with associated ligament displacement and neck muscle strain, is indeed complex and requires careful consideration.

Firstly, it’s important to understand that fractures and dislocations in the area around the clavicle and neck can lead to significant complications, particularly when they involve nerves and blood vessels. The fact that multiple doctors have advised against surgery due to the risks associated with the proximity to vital structures is a valid concern. Surgical interventions in such sensitive areas can lead to complications such as nerve damage, vascular injury, or even chronic pain syndromes if not performed correctly.

However, the presence of persistent discomfort and functional limitations in your left arm and neck suggests that conservative management may not be sufficient. If the injury has resulted in a malunion or nonunion of the fracture, or if the ligamentous structures are not healing properly, surgical intervention may become necessary despite the risks. It’s crucial to weigh the potential benefits of surgery against the risks, especially since you have seen successful outcomes in similar cases.
Regarding your concerns about missing the "golden period" for surgery, it’s essential to note that while early intervention can often lead to better outcomes, it is not always too late for surgery. Many orthopedic surgeons are skilled at addressing chronic issues, and they can provide a tailored approach based on your specific condition. Consulting with a surgeon who specializes in orthopedic trauma or shoulder surgery may provide you with more clarity on your options.

As for the persistent pain and discomfort in your legs, which you mentioned could be related to sciatica or degenerative changes, this is another area that requires thorough evaluation. Sciatica can result from a herniated disc, spinal stenosis, or other spinal issues that compress the sciatic nerve. The varying opinions you've received highlight the complexity of diagnosing such conditions. A comprehensive evaluation, including imaging studies like an MRI or CT scan of the lumbar spine, may help clarify the underlying cause of your symptoms.

In terms of which specialty to consult, you may want to see an orthopedic surgeon for the issues related to your clavicle and neck, and a neurologist or a physiatrist (a specialist in physical medicine and rehabilitation) for your leg symptoms. They can work together to provide a comprehensive treatment plan that addresses both your orthopedic and neurological concerns.

Lastly, regarding your concerns about osteoporosis or low bone density, it’s wise to follow up on this with your healthcare provider. A bone density test can help assess your bone health and determine if you need any specific interventions, such as dietary changes, supplements, or medications to improve bone density.

In summary, while navigating your complex orthopedic issues may feel overwhelming, seeking a second opinion from specialists who are experienced in treating similar cases can provide you with the confidence and clarity you need to make informed decisions about your health. Don’t hesitate to advocate for yourself and seek out the care that you feel is necessary for your recovery.

Similar Q&A

One Year Post-Car Accident: Struggling with Severe Orthopedic Issues

Hello doctors, I had a car accident over a year ago, resulting in a comminuted fracture of the right femur, as well as fractures in my pelvis and sacrum. My arm was also broken. Currently, the issue is that my pelvis is misaligned, and I am unable to fully extend or bend my leg; ...

Dr. Chen Xingyuan reply Orthopedics
Dear Netizen: You have suffered severe trauma, which has resulted in multiple fractures. The purpose of surgery, rehabilitation, and other treatments is to minimize the extent of sequelae, reduce pain, and promote functional recovery, rather than to guarantee a return to the pre-...

Understanding Post-Car Accident Orthopedic Care and Recovery Risks

Dear Doctor, The patient is my husband, who was involved in a car accident on January 28, 2022. The medical summary indicates a comminuted fracture of the right acetabulum with mild displacement, contusions and lacerations to the forehead, and a concussion resulting in head inju...

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
After a hip joint fracture, there is a possibility of developing arthritis many years later, which requires ongoing monitoring. As for bladder issues, it may be necessary to consult a urologist.

Managing Post-Car Accident Orthopedic Issues: Pain Relief Strategies

I was in a car accident yesterday, and I don't remember how I fell. When I woke up, I was able to get up and ride my bike to work. After that, I immediately went to the emergency room, where I had an X-ray, and the doctor said everything was fine. However, my bones were seve...

Dr. Li Wenlin reply Orthopedics
Hello: In response to your question, injuries caused by a car accident typically result in contusions or sprains. Muscles, tendons, and soft tissues may experience bruising or microvascular hematomas or bleeding, usually leading to pain and weakness within 48 to 72 hours. Based o...

Knee Pain After Car Accident: When to Seek Orthopedic Care

Hello, doctor. Two months ago, I was in a car accident, and at that time, I had abrasions and slight swelling on my knee. An X-ray was taken, and it seemed that there were no issues with the bones. However, in the two weeks following the accident, I was unable to bend my knee or ...

Dr. Chen Yongxue reply Orthopedics
Hello, I would recommend consulting a specialist for further examination. Thank you.