Swelling and Pain in the Middle Finger: Surgical Options Explained

Q: Swelling and Pain in the Middle Finger: Surgical Options Explained

Dear Netizen： There are many reasons for the redness and swelling of the finger joint membrane. <br>Although X-rays show no issues with the bones, there are still numerous possibilities, such as ligament injuries, soft tissue inflammation, bacterial infections, tumors, foreign bo

Swelling and redness of the middle finger?

Hello Dr.
Chen, I would like to ask you a question.
My middle finger joint has swelling and redness of the periosteum, and it hurts a lot even with a light touch.
Initially, I visited many traditional Chinese medicine clinics and various acupuncture practitioners, but I have not been able to heal my hand, and the doctors could not identify the cause.
Recently, I went to an orthopedic hospital and had an X-ray taken.
The doctor said there are no fractures or breaks in the bone, only swelling and inflammation, and mentioned that the periosteum might be torn.
He suggested surgery for repair and told me that rehabilitation might not be effective.
Finally, he asked if I wanted to take medication.
I asked him if the medication would help, and he replied that it would only be painkillers and would not lead to recovery.
Is it true that surgery is the only way to heal? Also, will the surgery cost be very high? PS: I have been seeing doctors for my middle finger for six months, and it has not improved at all.
Thank you.

Xiao Lin, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2006/06/27

Dr. Chen Xingyuan reply Orthopedics

Dear Netizen: There are many reasons for the redness and swelling of the finger joint membrane.
Although X-rays show no issues with the bones, there are still numerous possibilities, such as ligament injuries, soft tissue inflammation, bacterial infections, tumors, foreign bodies, and rheumatic autoimmune diseases.
Whether surgical treatment is necessary depends on the underlying cause; using periosteal rupture as a reason for surgery seems too vague.
It is best to consult your physician for an accurate diagnosis, as well as to discuss the surgical procedure, associated risks, and success rates.
If you still have doubts, it is advisable to seek a second opinion from another hand surgery specialist.
Wishing you health and safety! Sincerely, Dr.
Chen

Reply Date: 2006/06/27

More Info

Hello! It sounds like you've been dealing with a challenging situation regarding your middle finger. Based on your description, it appears that you are experiencing significant pain and swelling around the joint, which has persisted despite various treatments. The diagnosis of periosteal inflammation (inflammation of the periosteum, the tissue surrounding the bone) can indeed be quite painful and may not always respond well to conservative treatments like physical therapy or traditional Chinese medicine.

When it comes to the options available for treatment, surgery is often considered when conservative measures fail, especially if the pain and inflammation are significantly affecting your quality of life. The periosteum plays a crucial role in bone health and healing, and if it is damaged or inflamed, it can lead to chronic pain and dysfunction. Surgical intervention may involve debridement (removal of damaged tissue) or repair of the periosteum, which could potentially alleviate your symptoms.

Regarding your question about whether surgery is the only option for recovery, it is essential to understand that while surgery can provide a more definitive solution, it is not always the first line of treatment. In some cases, a combination of physical therapy, medication, and lifestyle modifications can lead to improvement. However, given that you have been experiencing symptoms for six months without significant improvement, surgery may indeed be the most effective option at this point.

As for the cost of surgery, it can vary widely depending on several factors, including your location, the specific procedure required, and whether you have insurance coverage. It's advisable to discuss the financial aspects with your healthcare provider or the hospital's billing department to get a clearer picture of what to expect.

In addition to the surgical options, here are some considerations that may help you in your decision-making process:
1. Second Opinion: If you have doubts about the necessity of surgery, seeking a second opinion from another orthopedic specialist could provide you with additional insights and options.

2. Pain Management: While your doctor mentioned that pain medications may not resolve the underlying issue, they can still play a role in managing your discomfort while you explore treatment options.

3. Rehabilitation Post-Surgery: If you do opt for surgery, be prepared for a rehabilitation period afterward. Physical therapy is often crucial in restoring function and strength to the affected finger.

4. Lifestyle Modifications: Depending on the nature of your work or daily activities, you may need to make adjustments to avoid aggravating the injury further.

5. Monitoring Symptoms: Keep track of any changes in your symptoms, as this information can be valuable for your healthcare provider in determining the best course of action.

In conclusion, while surgery may be a viable option for your condition, it is essential to weigh the benefits and risks carefully. Engaging in open communication with your healthcare provider about your concerns and treatment goals will help you make an informed decision. I hope you find relief soon and can return to your normal activities without pain. Thank you for sharing your situation, and I wish you the best in your recovery journey!

Similar Q&A

Swelling in the Middle Joints of Pinky and Ring Fingers: Causes and Insights

The middle joints of the right hand's little finger and middle finger have gradually swollen (with noticeable deformity for about six months) but are not painful.

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
The middle joint of the finger is called the proximal interphalangeal joint. Swelling that is painless, aside from injury, could be due to the presence of a tumor or arthritis. Additionally, overuse may also cause enlargement. It is advisable to consult a physician for a proper e...

Swollen Joint at the Tip of Right Middle Finger: Causes and Solutions

Hello Doctor, this morning I noticed that the tip of my right middle finger's nail, extending to the joint area, is swollen. The swelling is more pronounced on the left side, measuring approximately 1 cm in length and 0.5 cm in width. It is not painful or itchy, and there ar...

Dr. Lin Zhebin reply Family Medicine
Hello: Based on your description, it could possibly be an epidermoid cyst, a mucous cyst, or a ganglion cyst, among others. If you wish to improve the condition, surgical excision may be considered. It is recommended to consult a dermatologist.

Post-Surgery Pain and Swelling: Understanding Complications After Finger Injury

Hello Doctor, in 2020, I had an accident that resulted in a rupture of the flexor tendon in my ring finger. After suturing, although the wound healed after a few months, there is a translucent protrusion with a black dot in the middle. Upon returning for a follow-up, I was inform...

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
1. Hand surgery 2. May improve 3. May not be visible

Understanding Sudden Pain and Swelling in the Middle Finger Joint

Hello, doctor! A few days ago, the first joint of my right middle finger suddenly became painful and swollen. I haven't lifted anything heavy, nor have I twisted it or sustained any other injury; it just started hurting for no apparent reason. What could be the issue? If it ...

Dr. Chen Xianchang reply Rehabilitation
Hello, thank you for your inquiry. Here are my responses and recommendations: 1. It is possible that the joints have been overused, leading to a chronic condition. Sudden use can result in pain. 2. Painful arthritis can be evaluated by checking for elevated levels of uric acid a...