Choosing the Right Skincare: Medical vs. Natural Products for Sensitive Skin

How to choose skincare products?

I heard that long-term use of topical medications prescribed by dermatologists for treating acne can make the skin more sensitive.
Is this correct? Initially, these treatments are very effective, but after stopping the medication, there may be side effects or worsening of the condition, which makes me hesitant to use dermatological products, often referred to as medical skincare.
Do medical skincare products necessarily contain active ingredients? Is it better to choose medical skincare products or plant-based products that are more natural?
My skin reacted with redness, swelling, stinging, and itching after using a particular brand of skincare product.
After applying it, my face became very dry.
However, the beautician said that this is normal and that once the acne is metabolized and cleared, the skin will improve.
But it was too painful, so I stopped using it and later went to a dermatologist for tretinoin.
The next morning, my entire face was red and itchy.
The dermatologist diagnosed me with seborrheic dermatitis.
My skin has improved since then, but it is still prone to redness and breakouts.
Before using Clindamycin, I had been getting medications from the dermatologist's office, where I also used tretinoin, and my skin was in good condition at that time.
After a while without using dermatological medications, I went to see a beautician.
Currently, my skin is sensitive, oily, and prone to acne, and I am unsure how to choose skincare products.
I have questions about medical skincare products, specifically what ingredients should be avoided by those trying to conceive or who are pregnant.
Could you please recommend which brand of skincare products I can use?

Pei, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2006/08/12

Dr. Huang Ruiyun reply Dermatology

There are many types of medications for acne, and those that have exfoliating and comedolytic effects can make the skin more sensitive.
There is no medication that can completely eradicate acne; if left untreated, it will recur not due to the medication but because it returns to your natural skin type.
Products that do not contain active ingredients are classified as skincare products, while medical skincare products do not contain drugs.
Terms like "plant-based" and "natural" are merely marketing jargon and hold no real significance.
If the treatment is too painful, it is best to discontinue use.
Medical skincare products can still be used during pregnancy, but retinoids (such as tretinoin) should not be used during pregnancy.
There is no need to be overly loyal to a brand; no single brand is suitable for everyone, and no individual is compatible with all products from a specific brand.
The suitability of a product can only be determined through use.
You might consider trying products that contain lactobionic acid or polyhydroxy acids (PHA), which are gentler than traditional small molecule alpha hydroxy acids, such as those from NeoStrata.

Reply Date: 2006/08/12

More Info

When it comes to choosing the right skincare products for sensitive skin, particularly for those dealing with acne and other skin conditions, it is essential to understand the differences between medical (or pharmaceutical) products and natural or botanical products. Your concerns about the long-term use of topical medications, such as those prescribed by dermatologists, are valid and shared by many individuals with sensitive skin.

Medical vs. Natural Products
Medical Products: These are often formulated with active ingredients that target specific skin conditions. For acne, common ingredients include retinoids (like tretinoin or adapalene), benzoyl peroxide, and salicylic acid. While these products can be highly effective, they may also lead to increased skin sensitivity, especially when used over extended periods. This sensitivity can manifest as redness, irritation, or even a worsening of acne in some cases, particularly if the skin barrier is compromised.

Natural Products: These typically contain botanical ingredients that are perceived as gentler on the skin. However, "natural" does not always mean "safe" for everyone. Some natural ingredients can cause allergic reactions or irritation, especially in sensitive skin types. Therefore, it is crucial to patch-test any new product before widespread application.

Concerns About Sensitivity and Rebound Effects
It is not uncommon for individuals to experience increased sensitivity after discontinuing topical medications. This phenomenon, sometimes referred to as "rebound," can occur when the skin becomes reliant on the active ingredients, and their sudden absence leads to a flare-up of the original condition. This is particularly true for potent medications like retinoids or corticosteroids.
If you find that your skin becomes red, itchy, or irritated after stopping a medication, it may be beneficial to consult with a dermatologist. They can provide guidance on how to taper off medications safely or suggest alternative treatments that may be less irritating.

Choosing the Right Products
For sensitive, oily, and acne-prone skin, consider the following tips when selecting skincare products:
1. Look for Non-Comedogenic Products: These are formulated to not clog pores, which is essential for acne-prone skin.

2. Choose Fragrance-Free Options: Fragrances can irritate sensitive skin, so opting for fragrance-free products can help minimize reactions.

3. Consider Gentle Exfoliants: Instead of harsh scrubs, look for chemical exfoliants like lactic acid or salicylic acid, which can help clear pores without causing excessive irritation.

4. Hydration is Key: Even oily skin needs hydration. Look for lightweight, oil-free moisturizers that contain ingredients like hyaluronic acid or glycerin.

5. Sunscreen is Essential: Protecting your skin from UV damage is crucial, especially when using active ingredients that can increase sensitivity to sunlight. Choose a broad-spectrum sunscreen that is also suitable for sensitive skin.

Ingredients to Avoid During Pregnancy
If you are pregnant or planning to become pregnant, certain ingredients should be avoided due to potential risks to fetal development. These include:
- Retinoids: Such as tretinoin, isotretinoin, and adapalene.

- Salicylic Acid: High concentrations should be avoided.

- Benzoyl Peroxide: While considered safer in lower concentrations, it’s best to consult a healthcare provider.

Recommendations
For sensitive skin, brands like CeraVe, La Roche-Posay, and Eucerin offer a range of products designed for sensitive and acne-prone skin. These brands focus on restoring the skin barrier and minimizing irritation. Always consult with a dermatologist to tailor a skincare regimen that suits your specific needs and conditions.

In conclusion, navigating skincare for sensitive skin, especially when dealing with acne, requires careful consideration of product ingredients and formulations. It’s essential to listen to your skin and consult with professionals when in doubt, ensuring that your skincare routine supports your skin's health rather than exacerbating its issues.

Similar Q&A

Recommended Intimate Care Products for Women's Health

As mentioned in the title, I would like to choose a skincare product, but there are so many options available on the market. I'm unsure how to select one and I'm afraid that using the wrong product might have adverse effects. Could you please recommend a product, doctor...

Dr. Zhou Dali reply Obstetrics and Gynecology
I cannot understand what you mean by maintenance care; I suggest visiting a gynecologist nearby for a face-to-face inquiry.

Choosing the Right Moisturizer for Oily, Dehydrated Skin: A Guide

Hello! I would like to ask two questions: 1. How can I choose a suitable moisturizer for oily but dehydrated skin? Generally, commercially available lightweight lotions may not provide enough hydration for mature women like us, while richer lotions may cause excess oiliness in th...

Dr. Zheng Lizhen reply Dermatology
Hello: 1. There is no standard answer for suitable skincare products; the best approach is to try them out and learn through trial and error to find what works for you. Different seasons may also require different products. 2. Products are generally labeled according to the areas...

Understanding Medical Cosmetics: Where to Find Effective Solutions?

Hello Dr. Chen, I consulted an article in the Dachen Report back in July that introduced medical cosmetics. It mentioned that the product could effectively cover post-surgical scars and dark circles under the eyes, among other things, and that it is already available in Taiwan....

Dr. Chen Yiying reply Dermatology
Hello: Regarding your question, medical cosmetics are typically formulated with special attention to their ingredients, making them less likely to cause sensitivity and easier to cleanse. There are indeed some brands that specialize in producing such products, but it is not conve...

Understanding Skin Sensitivities: Managing Allergies and Discomfort

Hello, doctor. My skin condition is not very good. I am sensitive to metal objects, such as the buttons and zippers on my pants and skirts. If I'm not careful, I easily develop rashes that become very itchy. Even after avoiding wearing the same pants, the swelling has not su...

Dr. Chen Yiying reply Dermatology
Hello: In response to your question. Your first condition is likely contact dermatitis, and you have already recognized your sensitivity to metals. The most important thing is to avoid further contact with metal products that trigger your sensitivity. If necessary, you can also u...