Is it hyperventilation or asthma?
Hello Dr.
Lin, I am someone who often coughs.
Whenever my breathing feels a bit off, I start to cough.
I have a lot of phlegm, which is almost clear, and it often gets stuck in my throat, making it hard to expel.
Even when I manage to cough it out, it quickly returns, which is really frustrating.
I have been experiencing breathing difficulties for about 10 years, but during episodes, I can't tell if it's asthma or hyperventilation.
I was once taken to the emergency room, and the doctor said it was hyperventilation.
Later, I consulted a traditional Chinese medicine practitioner who mentioned that I show mild signs of asthma but that it shouldn't be a major issue.
I then went to a larger hospital for a check-up, and my heart and lungs were found to be fine, but I do have severe allergic rhinitis, which often causes post-nasal drip.
When I explain my situation to doctors, I mention that during my breathing difficulties, I do not have wheezing; I just cough, as if the cough is triggered by inhaling too quickly.
However, the coughing is not continuous; I cough a few times, then pause, and continue coughing.
Even when I am not having an episode, I still cough, which makes it hard for me to identify the problem.
I find that when I lie down to sleep and relax, my breathing is the best.
However, when I get up to move around or watch TV or use the computer, I feel somewhat uncomfortable, as if there is a pressure on me.
The episodes do not occur at night; they only happen after I get up.
The most severe issue is when I eat, as I tend to become short of breath and often choke, which is the most troubling aspect.
Overall, this is my situation, and I hope Dr.
Lin can help me find answers so that I can escape this suffering soon.
Thank you.
zero, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2006/11/11
Dr. Lin Qingzhong reply Traditional Chinese Medicine
Dear zero/0/23 user,
(1) Your severe allergic rhinitis may be causing you to frequently choke while eating, along with issues such as phlegm in the throat, nasal congestion, and nasal discharge.
This could be due to chronic rhinitis (allergic rhinitis) leading to post-nasal drip into the throat.
If it were simply bronchitis, the presence of phlegm in the throat would not be associated with nasal issues.
(2) Chronic allergic rhinitis is often triggered by environmental factors related to autoimmune responses.
In my clinical observations, the most common allergens include air conditioning, dust mites, and polluted air.
In traditional Chinese medicine, treatment often focuses on strengthening the lungs and enhancing qi, using herbal remedies tailored to the patient's constitution.
It is also advisable to engage in regular exercise, take steam baths, and minimize exposure to air conditioning to improve overall health, which has shown positive results.
(3) Your hyperventilation has been evaluated, and there are no significant issues with your heart or lungs.
It may also be related to stress.
In addition to ongoing monitoring, increasing physical activity can help reduce stress, and incorporating traditional Chinese medicine can further improve your constitution.
Wishing you good health,
Dr.
Lin Ching-Chung
Director, Department of Traditional Chinese Medicine
Fengyuan Hospital
Reply Date: 2006/11/11
More Info
Coughing can be a complex symptom that may arise from various underlying conditions, and in your case, it appears to be linked to both asthma and possibly hyperventilation syndrome. Understanding the nuances between these two conditions is crucial for effective management and treatment.
Asthma is a chronic inflammatory disease of the airways characterized by recurrent breathing problems, which can include wheezing, shortness of breath, chest tightness, and coughing. The cough associated with asthma is often triggered by allergens, respiratory infections, exercise, or changes in weather. In your case, the presence of clear, viscous sputum and the sensation of mucus being stuck in your throat could indicate that your airways are inflamed and producing excess mucus, which is common in asthma. Additionally, the fact that you experience difficulty breathing, especially after physical activity or when lying down, aligns with asthma symptoms.
On the other hand, hyperventilation syndrome is characterized by rapid or deep breathing that can lead to a decrease in carbon dioxide levels in the blood, resulting in symptoms such as lightheadedness, tingling in the extremities, and sometimes a feeling of breathlessness. This condition can be triggered by anxiety, stress, or panic attacks. Your description of feeling like you are not getting enough air and the cough that follows rapid inhalation could suggest that hyperventilation is playing a role in your symptoms.
Given your history of allergic rhinitis and nasal drip, it’s also important to consider that post-nasal drip can contribute to chronic cough. When mucus from the nasal passages drips down the back of the throat, it can irritate the throat and trigger coughing. This could explain why you experience coughing more frequently when you are upright or engaged in activities.
To differentiate between asthma and hyperventilation, a thorough evaluation by a healthcare provider is essential. This may include pulmonary function tests to assess lung function and determine if asthma is present. Additionally, monitoring your symptoms in relation to specific triggers can provide valuable insights. Keeping a diary of your coughing episodes, noting when they occur, their duration, and any associated activities or stressors, can help your healthcare provider make an accurate diagnosis.
In terms of management, if asthma is confirmed, a treatment plan may include inhaled corticosteroids to reduce airway inflammation, bronchodilators to relieve acute symptoms, and avoiding known triggers. If hyperventilation is identified, techniques such as controlled breathing exercises, relaxation techniques, and cognitive behavioral therapy may be beneficial in managing anxiety and reducing episodes.
Furthermore, addressing your allergic rhinitis through antihistamines or nasal corticosteroids may help reduce post-nasal drip and, consequently, your cough. It’s also advisable to avoid known allergens and irritants, such as smoke, strong odors, and cold air, which can exacerbate both asthma and hyperventilation symptoms.
In conclusion, your symptoms of chronic cough, difficulty breathing, and the sensation of mucus in your throat warrant a comprehensive evaluation to determine the underlying cause. Collaboration with a healthcare provider, possibly including an allergist or pulmonologist, will be key in developing an effective treatment plan tailored to your specific needs. By addressing both asthma and potential hyperventilation, you can work towards alleviating your symptoms and improving your quality of life.
Similar Q&A
Understanding Wheezing During Inhalation: Is It Asthma?
Hello Doctor: Recently, I've been experiencing a wheezing sound when inhaling, but not when exhaling. Additionally, I feel pain in the middle of my chest when I take a deep breath. I often have phlegm, especially when I'm emotionally excited or when the weather is very ...
Dr. Huang Yiwen reply Pulmonology
Dear Ms. Li: Yes, this is your asthma attack. The chest pain is due to airway obstruction. The weather and your emotions that you mentioned are also triggers. Each episode may not present the same way. If you experience wheezing during both inhalation and exhalation, that indicat...[Read More] Understanding Wheezing During Inhalation: Is It Asthma?
Understanding Chronic Cough and Asthma: Symptoms, Diagnosis, and Treatment
Hello Doctor: I have been coughing since mid-February of this year, and it has been over two months. My symptoms include an itchy throat and trachea, coughing, and a lot of phlegm (all white and transparent foam). Sometimes I feel a dull ache in my right chest. In previous years,...
Dr. Yang Wenda reply Pulmonology
Hello: The treatment provided by your physician is appropriate, but there may still be other factors that are not well controlled, such as dietary aspects. Western medicine may not emphasize this as much, while traditional Chinese medicine will consider your constitution and prov...[Read More] Understanding Chronic Cough and Asthma: Symptoms, Diagnosis, and Treatment
Asthma or Pneumonia? Understanding Symptoms and Seeking Help
I have a history of asthma. Four days ago, I played basketball outdoors, but since the next day, I've felt like there's phlegm stuck in my throat that I can't clear. Due to the current COVID-19 pandemic, I'm unsure whether this is pneumonia or an asthma exacer...
Dr. Yang Wenda reply Pulmonology
Hello: There is no wheezing, so it does not resemble an asthma attack. Without an X-ray, it is impossible to determine if there is pneumonia (which usually presents with fever and cough). Your issue is simply excessive phlegm; it is recommended to avoid consuming very cold or ver...[Read More] Asthma or Pneumonia? Understanding Symptoms and Seeking Help
Understanding Breathing Issues: Is It Asthma or Just a Cold?
Hello, doctor. I usually don't experience wheezing in my daily life, but I have issues with wheezing when I engage in intense exercise. Every time I catch a cold, I have difficulty breathing and need a doctor to prescribe me oral bronchodilators to breathe properly. Should I...
Dr. Wang Lanfeng reply Pulmonology
Hello: Based on your description, your condition is generally fine, and you only experience wheezing during a cold or intense exercise. This could indeed be caused by asthma. I recommend that you visit a pulmonology clinic for a thorough evaluation. Thank you.[Read More] Understanding Breathing Issues: Is It Asthma or Just a Cold?
Related FAQ
(Traditional Chinese Medicine)
Asthma(Traditional Chinese Medicine)
Acid Reflux(Traditional Chinese Medicine)
Cough(Internal Medicine)
Sleep(Traditional Chinese Medicine)
Palpitations(Traditional Chinese Medicine)
Headache(Traditional Chinese Medicine)
Hemorrhoids(Traditional Chinese Medicine)
Menopausal Disorders(Traditional Chinese Medicine)
Medication Consultation(Traditional Chinese Medicine)