Pulmonary tuberculosis
Hello Doctor: I went to Mackay Memorial Hospital for an examination in early November, and the X-ray showed abnormalities.
The doctor prescribed a week of antibiotics for me, and after a week, the X-ray showed no changes (the findings were the same as the X-ray taken in September).
Next, I underwent three days of sputum tests, all of which were negative...
further sputum cultures showed two positive results.
I am currently in home isolation.
The doctor asked me if I want to pay out of pocket for a $1500 species identification test...
the results will be available in a week.
Doctor, can I be certain that I have open pulmonary tuberculosis? Is it possible that I do not? Do I need to go to another hospital for a diagnosis?
Danxin de ren, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2006/11/26
Dr. Zhou Ziguang reply Pulmonology
Hello: A positive sputum culture is mostly indicative of Mycobacterium tuberculosis, which would suggest open pulmonary tuberculosis.
However, a portion may be non-tuberculous mycobacteria, which requires further identification of the species.
Traditional methods take about a month, while molecular biology techniques can provide preliminary results in a few days.
It is advisable to wait for the molecular biology results before further discussion with the physician.
Sincerely, Dr.
Chou Tzu-Kuang, attending physician in internal medicine.
Reply Date: 2006/11/26
More Info
Understanding tuberculosis (TB) is crucial for both patients and healthcare providers, especially in light of the complexities surrounding its diagnosis and treatment. Based on your situation, it appears that you are navigating a challenging path with potential TB infection, and I will address your concerns while providing additional context about TB diagnosis and management.
Firstly, it's important to understand that a positive sputum culture for Mycobacterium tuberculosis (the bacteria that causes TB) is a significant indicator of active TB disease. If your sputum cultures have returned positive, this suggests that you may indeed have active TB, particularly if you are experiencing symptoms such as cough, fever, or weight loss. However, the confirmation of whether it is "open" or "closed" TB (meaning whether it is contagious or not) depends on several factors, including the presence of cavitary lesions on imaging studies and the results of your sputum tests.
In your case, the initial chest X-ray showed abnormalities, and despite a course of antibiotics, there was no improvement. This lack of change, combined with the positive sputum cultures, raises the suspicion of active TB. It is also worth noting that TB can sometimes present with atypical symptoms or radiographic findings, particularly in immunocompromised patients or those with a history of lung disease.
Regarding the need for further testing, the decision to undergo additional tests, such as the 1500菌種鑑定 (species identification test), is often based on clinical judgment and the need for precise treatment. Identifying the specific strain of TB can help guide treatment, especially if drug resistance is a concern. If your healthcare provider recommends this test, it is likely to ensure that you receive the most effective treatment regimen.
As for whether you need to seek a second opinion or visit another hospital, this can depend on your comfort level and the resources available at your current facility. If you feel uncertain about the diagnosis or treatment plan, it is entirely reasonable to seek a second opinion, especially in complex cases like TB. However, ensure that any new consultations have access to your previous medical records and test results to provide a comprehensive evaluation.
In terms of treatment, if you are diagnosed with active TB, the standard treatment involves a combination of antibiotics taken over a period of at least six months. The initial phase typically includes four medications: isoniazid, rifampin, pyrazinamide, and ethambutol. Adherence to this regimen is crucial to prevent the development of drug-resistant TB, which can complicate treatment and prolong recovery.
Isolation is an important step in managing TB, especially if you are confirmed to have an infectious form. This helps prevent the spread of TB to others while you are undergoing treatment. Your healthcare provider will guide you on when it is safe to return to normal activities based on your response to treatment and follow-up tests.
In summary, based on your positive sputum cultures and the previous imaging findings, there is a strong possibility of active TB. It is essential to follow up with your healthcare provider regarding treatment options and any further testing that may be necessary. If you have any doubts or concerns, do not hesitate to seek additional opinions or clarification from your medical team. TB is a serious condition, but with appropriate treatment and monitoring, it is manageable, and many patients go on to lead healthy lives post-treatment.
Similar Q&A
Understanding Tuberculosis Symptoms: What You Need to Know
What are the symptoms of tuberculosis (TB)? Recently, I experienced chest pain and visited a doctor. After an X-ray, the doctor asked if I had any chest injuries and suspected I might have tuberculosis, requesting a sputum test. Later, I checked the symptoms of tuberculosis on th...
Dr. Yang Wenda reply Pulmonology
Hello Jack: Tuberculosis (TB) is a slowly progressing disease that can be asymptomatic in its early stages. However, abnormal white infiltrates can be observed on a chest X-ray. Some individuals may have these lesions detected during a routine examination. If not identified early...[Read More] Understanding Tuberculosis Symptoms: What You Need to Know
Exploring Rapid TB Testing Options with MGIT 960 for Timely Diagnosis
My father was diagnosed with suspected tuberculosis at the end of May, but he has not yet been confirmed as having the disease since the sputum culture results are still pending. When he returned home for rest at the end of May, the doctor prescribed antitubercular medication as ...
Dr. Zhou Ziguang reply Pulmonology
Hello: 1. For patients suspected of having tuberculosis who experience side effects from medication, it is advisable to discuss subsequent management or medication adjustments with their physician, or they may seek consultation at our hospital. 2. If cultures have been incubated ...[Read More] Exploring Rapid TB Testing Options with MGIT 960 for Timely Diagnosis
Understanding Potential Tuberculosis Diagnosis: Key Questions and Next Steps
Hello Doctor, In June, during a medical examination for studying abroad, a chest X-ray revealed a fibrotic calcified nodule in the upper lobe of my right lung. The examining physician suggested that it might be a scar from a past tuberculosis infection (there is no record of thi...
Dr. Zhou Ziguang reply Pulmonology
Hello, 1. If there were no abnormalities in the chest X-ray six years ago and there are now significant lesions, the likelihood of an active lesion is greater (unless there has been a history of other lung diseases in the past six years). 2. If there is a lesion in the right ...[Read More] Understanding Potential Tuberculosis Diagnosis: Key Questions and Next Steps
Understanding Tuberculosis Risk and Screening After Exposure
Hello, my family member is a patient with open pulmonary tuberculosis and has just returned home after a week of treatment in the hospital. They are still continuing medication for control, and I sleep in the same room as the patient. What is the likelihood that I will contract t...
Dr. Jiang Zhenyuan reply Pulmonology
If your family member tests positive for acid-fast bacilli in sputum smear, their infectiousness is higher, and there is a possibility of transmission if sleeping in the same room as a tuberculosis patient. As long as your family member adheres to their medication regimen, their ...[Read More] Understanding Tuberculosis Risk and Screening After Exposure
Related FAQ
(Pulmonology)
Mycobacterium Tuberculosis(Pulmonology)
Computed Tomography(Pulmonology)
Ct Report(Pulmonology)
Breathing(Pulmonology)
Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease(Pulmonology)
Tuberculosis(Internal Medicine)
Bronchiectasis(Pulmonology)
Lung Nodule(Pulmonology)
Chest Pain(Pulmonology)