Potential Tuberculosis Diagnosis: Key Questions and Next Steps

Diagnosis of pulmonary tuberculosis?

Hello Doctor,
In June, during a medical examination for studying abroad, a chest X-ray revealed a fibrotic calcified nodule in the upper lobe of my right lung.
The examining physician suggested that it might be a scar from a past tuberculosis infection (there is no record of this in my medical history; I rarely cough or produce sputum, but I was prone to high fevers as a child).
I later consulted two pulmonologists, both of whom indicated that it is very likely tuberculosis, and there is a suspicion of cavitation, possibly indicating active disease.
The X-ray images were taken on June 11, June 15, and July 5, and the doctors noted no significant changes during this period.
I have submitted three sputum samples for testing.
The last chest X-ray I had was six years ago, which showed my lungs to be normal and clear.
A month before my examination, I traveled abroad for two weeks, and after the examination, I experienced cold symptoms for a few days, including a cough without sputum, which did not last long.

The doctors recommended that I start treatment immediately without waiting for the sputum culture results, but both physicians mentioned that they could not be 100% certain it is tuberculosis.
I am unsure whether I should start the medication now, especially since it requires a six-month course.
What if it is not tuberculosis? I researched tuberculosis and asked the doctors if a CT scan could be performed; they scheduled it for tomorrow.
However, I discovered that CT scans involve high radiation exposure and require contrast agents.
Can I opt for a low-radiation CT scan? Would it still be helpful for tuberculosis evaluation? Or is MRI a viable alternative? Besides sputum tests and imaging, are there faster methods to confirm tuberculosis? Is PCR testing useful? If the sputum results are negative, can tuberculosis be ruled out? Would I still need to undergo treatment?
I am preparing to study abroad for four years, and I am currently uncertain about whether I am infected, whether I can travel, or if I need to postpone my departure for treatment.
I am very worried and would appreciate your advice and answers.
Thank you.

Ms. Chen, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2010/07/06

Dr. Zhou Ziguang reply Pulmonology

Hello,
1.
If there were no abnormalities in the chest X-ray six years ago and there are now significant lesions, the likelihood of an active lesion is greater (unless there has been a history of other lung diseases in the past six years).

2.
If there is a lesion in the right upper lobe with cavitation, pulmonary tuberculosis should be the primary consideration.
However, to confirm the diagnosis, it is necessary to detect Mycobacterium tuberculosis in sputum, obtain tissue biopsy/culture, and observe improvement after treatment with anti-tuberculosis medications.
Therefore, if Mycobacterium tuberculosis has not been detected at this stage, it remains a suspected case (negative results do not rule out pulmonary tuberculosis).
Further examinations that can be performed include bronchoscopy with PCR testing, chest computed tomography (CT scan, not MRI), and tuberculin skin testing.
The final step would be surgical lung biopsy/culture.
3.
Therefore, before a definitive diagnosis is established, it is common for clinicians to initiate a course of anti-tuberculosis treatment (6-9 months) after discussion with the patient, while closely monitoring the situation.
If there are suspicions of other diagnoses, further examinations can be conducted.
4.
Please discuss this further with your physician.
If there are still concerns, surgical lung biopsy may be necessary for diagnosis.
Thank you.

Sincerely,
Dr.
Chou Tzu-Kuang, Director of Pulmonary Medicine

Reply Date: 2010/07/06

More Info

When it comes to diagnosing and treating tuberculosis (TB), especially in the context of your situation, there are several important factors to consider. Based on your description, it seems that you have undergone various tests and consultations regarding a potential TB infection, particularly in light of your recent chest X-ray findings.

Understanding Your Situation
1. Previous X-ray Findings: The presence of fibrotic and calcified lesions in your right lung could indeed suggest a past TB infection. These findings are often remnants of healed TB, but they can also indicate active disease, especially if there are signs of cavitation (the formation of cavities in the lung tissue).

2. Symptoms and History: Your history of occasional cough and the recent cold symptoms could be relevant. While a cough is a common symptom of active TB, it is not definitive on its own, especially if it is not persistent or accompanied by other symptoms like fever, night sweats, or significant weight loss.

3. Diagnostic Tests: You mentioned having sputum tests and the possibility of further imaging. Sputum tests are crucial as they can directly identify the presence of Mycobacterium tuberculosis. However, it is important to note that a negative sputum test does not completely rule out TB, especially if the disease is in an early stage or if the bacteria are not being expelled in the sputum.

Next Steps in Diagnosis
1. Starting Treatment: Given that two chest specialists have suggested the possibility of active TB and considering the potential risks of delaying treatment, starting anti-TB medication may be advisable. This is particularly true if there is a high suspicion of active disease, even if the diagnosis is not confirmed. The standard treatment regimen typically lasts for six months, and it is crucial to adhere to this to ensure the infection is fully eradicated.

2. Further Imaging: Regarding your concerns about radiation exposure from a CT scan, it is true that CT scans involve higher radiation doses compared to standard X-rays. However, they provide more detailed images that can help in assessing the lung's condition more accurately. If you are concerned about radiation, you can discuss with your physician the possibility of a low-dose CT scan, which is designed to minimize radiation exposure while still providing useful diagnostic information.

3. Alternative Diagnostic Methods: PCR testing can be a rapid and effective method for diagnosing TB. It detects the genetic material of the bacteria and can provide results faster than traditional culture methods. If you have not yet undergone PCR testing, it may be worth discussing with your healthcare provider.

4. Travel Considerations: Your plans to study abroad are understandably a source of anxiety given the uncertainty surrounding your health. If you begin treatment for TB, many institutions will require documentation of your treatment and may have specific guidelines regarding your ability to travel. It is essential to communicate with your healthcare provider about your travel plans so they can help you navigate any necessary precautions or documentation.

Conclusion
In summary, while the diagnosis of TB can be complex, it is crucial to act on the recommendations of your healthcare providers. Starting treatment based on clinical suspicion, even in the absence of definitive test results, is a common practice in managing TB. Additionally, pursuing further diagnostic imaging and tests like PCR can provide more clarity. Always keep an open line of communication with your healthcare team, especially regarding your treatment and travel plans. Your health and safety should always come first, and they can help guide you through this process.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Tuberculosis: Diagnosis, Transmission, and Symptoms Explained

Hello, doctor: 1. Can an X-ray definitively determine if someone has tuberculosis (TB) of the lungs? 2. A few months ago, my family member was diagnosed with mild open pulmonary tuberculosis and was hospitalized for treatment. They have now been discharged and are continuing m...

Dr. Jiang Zhenyuan reply Pulmonology
Hello, Xiao Xiang: I am glad to receive your letter. 1. X-rays are an important tool for diagnosing tuberculosis (TB). Although X-rays have some limitations, most lesions can be visualized. However, to confirm the diagnosis, sputum tests are still necessary. 2. After treatmen...

Understanding Tuberculosis: Diagnosis and Next Steps for Patients

Hello Doctor: I went to Mackay Memorial Hospital for an examination in early November, and the X-ray showed abnormalities. The doctor prescribed a week of antibiotics for me, and after a week, the X-ray showed no changes (the findings were the same as the X-ray taken in September...

Dr. Zhou Ziguang reply Pulmonology
Hello: A positive sputum culture is mostly indicative of Mycobacterium tuberculosis, which would suggest open pulmonary tuberculosis. However, a portion may be non-tuberculous mycobacteria, which requires further identification of the species. Traditional methods take about a mon...

Understanding Tuberculosis: Common Questions and Testing Options

I have a few questions to ask the doctor: 1. I have had a sensation of a foreign body in my throat, located at the bottom of my neck, for a long time. However, I underwent a skin test on August 1, and the final result was 5mm. Does this mean I am not infected with tuberculosis? 2...

Dr. Huang Yiwen reply Pulmonology
DEAR Ruru: A TT of 5 mm generally does not require further testing. If you want to check for latent infection, there are two blood tests available: 1. QUANTIFERON, and 2. T-SPOT, which are based on the antigen-antibody principle. These tests are only available at Chang Gung Memor...

Essential Tests for Tuberculosis: What You Need to Know

Hello, someone in my family has tuberculosis. The doctor previously said it was not open (infectious), so we have been in close contact with the patient for many days. However, during today's outpatient check-up, we were informed that it is open tuberculosis. Our family is c...

Dr. Yang Wenda reply Pulmonology
Hello Peii: Exposure does not necessarily lead to infection (family members have about a one in four chance of becoming infected). Among those infected, there is only a one in ten chance of developing the disease over a lifetime (90% can be detected through a chest X-ray), and ni...