Do You Really Need Antibiotics for Your Symptoms? - Internal Medicine

Share to:

Do I need to take antibiotics?


I have a headache and a fever of 37.8°C.
My throat is slightly swollen (day one).
I saw a doctor who prescribed antibiotics.
Should I take the antibiotics? I have a sensitive stomach, and every time I take medication, my stomach hurts the next day and I experience acid reflux.
The antibiotic course is for 7 days, and I'm concerned my stomach won't tolerate it.
The doctor didn't mention anything about this, and I'm unsure what to do.

Quan Quan, 40~49 year old female. Ask Date: 2007/06/23

Dr. Hong Hongchang reply Internal Medicine


Hello: Thank you for your question.
In response to your inquiry, I would like to provide the following advice: Most respiratory infections do not require antibiotics.
If you have any further questions, please feel free to ask.

Reply Date: 2007/06/23

More Info


When it comes to the use of antibiotics, it's essential to understand that they are specifically designed to combat bacterial infections, not viral infections, which are often the cause of symptoms like headaches, fever, and sore throats. In your case, with symptoms such as a headache, mild fever (37.8°C), and slight throat swelling, it’s crucial to determine the underlying cause before deciding on antibiotic treatment.

Antibiotics are effective against bacterial infections, such as strep throat, bacterial pneumonia, or urinary tract infections. However, if your symptoms are due to a viral infection, such as the common cold or influenza, antibiotics will not be effective and could contribute to antibiotic resistance, a growing public health concern. Therefore, it is vital to have a thorough evaluation by your healthcare provider to ascertain whether your symptoms are indicative of a bacterial infection that warrants antibiotic treatment.

If your doctor has prescribed antibiotics, it is likely because they suspect a bacterial infection. However, if you have concerns about the necessity of the antibiotics, especially considering your history of gastrointestinal issues, it is important to communicate these concerns with your doctor. You might want to ask the following questions:
1. Is there a specific bacterial infection that you are treating with antibiotics? Understanding the rationale behind the prescription can help you feel more comfortable with the treatment plan.

2. Are there alternative treatments available? If the infection is not severe, your doctor might suggest symptomatic treatment instead of antibiotics.

3. What are the potential side effects of the antibiotic, especially concerning my gastrointestinal health? Given your history of stomach issues, it’s crucial to discuss how the antibiotic might affect your stomach and if there are alternatives that are gentler on the gastrointestinal tract.

4. Can we monitor the symptoms before starting antibiotics? Sometimes, a “watchful waiting” approach can be appropriate, especially if the symptoms are mild and there is no immediate danger.

If you decide to take the antibiotics, consider discussing with your doctor the possibility of taking them with food or using probiotics to help mitigate gastrointestinal side effects. Probiotics can help maintain gut flora balance, which might be disrupted by antibiotic use.

In summary, while antibiotics can be necessary and life-saving in certain situations, they are not always the answer for every illness. It’s essential to have an open dialogue with your healthcare provider about your symptoms, the necessity of antibiotics, and any concerns you have regarding their impact on your health, particularly your gastrointestinal well-being. Always prioritize informed consent and shared decision-making in your healthcare journey.

Similar Q&A

Do You Really Need Antibiotics for Tonsillitis? Expert Insights

I previously took antibiotic capsules for tonsillitis, but I had difficulty swallowing them, which led to esophageal ulcers. This has left me feeling very anxious about taking antibiotics again. Over the past two days, I have started experiencing a sore throat again. Currently, m...


Dr. Zheng Jueyi reply Otolaryngology
Hello, whether antibiotics are needed for tonsillitis should be determined by a clinician based on the possibility of a bacterial infection. If there is no significant improvement in symptoms after using anti-inflammatory and pain relief medications, it is advisable to seek medic...

[Read More] Do You Really Need Antibiotics for Tonsillitis? Expert Insights


Do You Really Need Antibiotics for Cough and Green Phlegm?

Hello, Doctor. I have respiratory issues (holding a disability certificate), so I am prone to catching colds with significant weather changes. However, when I visit the hospital, the doctor prescribes antibiotics upon hearing that my cough produces yellow-green phlegm. I am aller...


Dr. Huang Yiwen reply Pulmonology
Dear Mr. Lin: Regarding your respiratory issues, which specific aspect are you referring to? This is related to subsequent management. Antibiotics are not always necessary; the physician will make a comprehensive judgment. It is not always possible to distinguish between viral an...

[Read More] Do You Really Need Antibiotics for Cough and Green Phlegm?


Why Do Doctors Prescribe Antibiotics for Tonsillitis Without Testing?

The information available online clearly states that when a patient has tonsillitis, doctors need to perform tests to differentiate between viral (which does not require antibiotics) and bacterial infections (which do require antibiotics), and then prescribe medication accordingl...


Dr. Zheng Jueyi reply Otolaryngology
Hello, the specimen collection for tonsillitis testing may take 5-7 days for a complete report to be confirmed. Whether antibiotics are needed for treatment will be determined by the clinical physician based on a comprehensive assessment of the clinical examination and symptoms. ...

[Read More] Why Do Doctors Prescribe Antibiotics for Tonsillitis Without Testing?


Should You Continue Pain Relief Medication with Antibiotics?

Hello Director Liao: I am currently taking Ketorolac and antibiotics for a urinary tract infection. I would like to ask if I can stop taking the anti-inflammatory pain reliever (Ketorolac) if the pain decreases, or is it necessary to complete the entire course of both the anti-in...


Dr. Liao Yaopan reply Family Medicine
Hello, the treatment of infectious diseases primarily relies on antibiotics. As for the prescription of Ketorolac given by the original physician, the indication or purpose is unclear. The best approach would be to discuss this with the prescribing physician. Please note: online ...

[Read More] Should You Continue Pain Relief Medication with Antibiotics?


Related FAQ

Antibiotics

(Internal Medicine)

Infection Inquiry

(Internal Medicine)

Fever

(Internal Medicine)

Antibiotics

(Family Medicine)

Health Check-Up

(Internal Medicine)

Cough

(Internal Medicine)

Medication Consultation

(Internal Medicine)

Antibiotics

(Pediatrics)

Antibiotic

(Otolaryngology)

Pancreatitis

(Internal Medicine)