HIV Transmission Risks: Common Myths and Facts - Urology

Share to:

HIV Prevention


Thank you for the doctor's response.
I have some more questions that I would like to clarify.
Once I understand these, I should be fine.
First, thank you for the doctor's answers; I really appreciate it.
I heard that HIV survives better in warm and humid environments.
Does the survival rate of the virus in water generally exceed that in air, or is it extremely low? Does it need to be in bodily fluids to survive better (is it due to the warmth of the body fluids)? Also, does a larger and deeper wound have a higher risk of infection? Can a scabbed wound still get infected? If so, is the infection risk significantly lower than that of an unhealed wound?
In a public restroom, if the toilet is not flushed properly and someone who is HIV positive has just used it, and while having a bowel movement, water from the unclean toilet splashes onto the anus or genital area (are the anus and genital area potential transmission routes for HIV regardless of the presence of visible wounds, or could there be unnoticed small cuts?).
However, since the toilet water is diluted with other substances not related to HIV, and the splashed water would only be a few drops, even if it reaches an infectious area, the concentration should be extremely low, making the risk of transmission very low, right?
I've heard that there are many unnoticed small cuts in a person's mouth or on their tongue.
Is that true? If so, does sharing a cup or straw with someone who is HIV positive pose a risk of transmission? Is the risk so low that it is almost impossible? (I recall seeing information stating that it is not a risk.) Is it due to the dilution of the beverage? What about accidentally French kissing someone who is HIV positive? Is the risk of infection higher than that of sharing a drink, or is it almost impossible? How high is the risk?
What about accidentally performing oral sex on someone who is HIV positive? Is the risk of infection higher than that of sharing a drink, or is it almost impossible? How high is the risk? The risk of infection from oral sex, French kissing, and the examples mentioned should be much lower than the risk of being accidentally pricked by a needle used on an HIV patient (which would have a high concentration and deep penetration, right?), with an infection chance of about 1-2%, much lower, right? How does the risk of genital contact compare to this serious accidental scenario? What is the estimated risk of infection from genital contact?

Niming, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2008/07/26

Dr. Xu Weikai reply Urology


Anonymous: Hello, let me give you a general understanding: the HIV virus can only survive inside cells.
It is difficult for it to survive outside the body in the natural environment.
In a dry environment, it can only live for about 2-3 hours, and in a humid environment, it may last a bit longer, but generally, it does not exceed 4-6 hours.
In adverse conditions, such as in soap water or bleach, the HIV virus can be killed.
Oral sex, vaginal intercourse, and deep kissing can all pose a risk due to the contact with bodily fluids (saliva, semen, vaginal secretions, etc.), especially if there are open wounds.
The probability of transmission is not meaningful to me because even if the chance is 1 in 1000, if it happens to be you, does that matter? Just because the previous 999 times were negative does not guarantee the next time will be as well.
Of course, it is also possible to contract the virus in just one encounter.
Therefore, for individuals, the difference is only between 100% and 0%.
Probability is only applicable for physicians to conduct statistics or large-scale analyses.
Sharing drinks poses a very low risk of transmission because the virus cannot survive long in that environment.
However, it cannot be completely ruled out.
Discussing probabilities in the context of a single case, which is a one-time event, is not meaningful.
I want to emphasize that for individuals, it is simply "either there or not," with no middle ground.
If there are any unclear points, feel free to ask again, and we can further discuss and research this together.
Department of Urology, Taitung Hospital, Ministry of Health and Welfare, Dr.
Hsu Wei-Kai.

Reply Date: 2008/07/26

More Info


Understanding HIV transmission risks is crucial in dispelling common myths and ensuring that individuals are informed about their health. Let's address the various aspects of HIV transmission, including environmental factors, wound characteristics, and different modes of contact.

1. HIV Survival in Different Environments:
HIV is a fragile virus that does not survive long outside the human body. In general, it is more stable in warm, moist environments, such as within bodily fluids. However, when exposed to air, the virus quickly becomes inactive. In water, the survival rate of HIV is extremely low, as the virus does not thrive in such conditions. Therefore, the risk of transmission through water, even if contaminated, is negligible compared to direct contact with infected bodily fluids.

2. Wound Characteristics and Infection Risk:
The size and depth of a wound can influence the risk of infection. Larger and deeper wounds may provide a more significant entry point for pathogens, including HIV. However, even small, unnoticed cuts can serve as potential entry points for the virus. When a wound has scabbed over, the risk of infection is considerably lower, but it is not entirely absent. If the scab is intact and there is no direct contact with infected fluids, the likelihood of transmission is minimal.

3. Public Restroom Concerns:
Using a public restroom poses a very low risk for HIV transmission. If contaminated water splashes onto the skin, the risk remains extremely low, especially if there are no open wounds. HIV requires direct access to the bloodstream or mucous membranes to establish an infection. The dilution effect of water and the presence of other substances in the toilet further reduce the risk.

4. Oral Contact and Shared Items:
The mouth does contain small, often unnoticed cuts or abrasions, which can theoretically allow for HIV transmission. However, the risk associated with sharing utensils, cups, or engaging in activities like kissing or oral sex is significantly lower than that of direct sexual contact. The presence of saliva, which contains enzymes that inhibit HIV, further decreases the risk. Studies indicate that the risk of transmission through oral sex is much lower than through vaginal or anal intercourse.

5. Comparing Risks:
When comparing the risks of various activities, direct sexual contact (especially unprotected) presents the highest risk for HIV transmission. The likelihood of contracting HIV from a needle stick injury involving a contaminated needle is also high, often cited at around 1-2% per exposure. In contrast, the risk from oral sex, sharing drinks, or kissing is considerably lower, often described as negligible or almost impossible in the absence of other risk factors.

In summary, while HIV can be transmitted through various routes, the actual risk varies significantly based on the mode of contact, the presence of open wounds, and environmental factors. Understanding these nuances is essential for making informed decisions about health and safety. If you have concerns about potential exposure to HIV, it is advisable to consult a healthcare professional for personalized advice and testing options. Regular testing and open communication with partners about sexual health can also help mitigate risks associated with HIV transmission.

Similar Q&A

Understanding HIV Transmission Risks: Safe Practices and Myths

If condoms are used consistently and correctly throughout the sexual encounter, and there are no open wounds, the risk of contracting HIV from sexual intercourse, kissing, or oral sex with an HIV-positive individual is significantly reduced. However, while the risk is low, it is ...


Dr. Du Shixi reply Urology
Hello: Yes, it is. The HIV virus has three main routes of transmission: 1. Sexual transmission: There is a risk of infection during sexual intercourse or other fluid exchanges involving oral, anal, or vaginal contact with an HIV-infected individual. 2. Blood transmission: (1) Rec...

[Read More] Understanding HIV Transmission Risks: Safe Practices and Myths


Understanding HIV Transmission: Myths and Facts in Urology

1. HIV is a virus that must be transmitted from an infected individual to another person, correct? 2. Can it arise spontaneously? 3. If three men perform oral sex on the same man, but none of the four have HIV, can transmission occur? 4. Why is the number of HIV-positive in...


Dr. Sun Hongshun reply Urology
Hello: The transmission of diseases requires a route of infection, such as through blood or sexual contact. Whether a disease is present or not can only be determined through testing. As for why certain populations are more susceptible to sexually transmitted infections, it is be...

[Read More] Understanding HIV Transmission: Myths and Facts in Urology


Understanding HIV Transmission Risks: Myths and Facts Explained

HIV is primarily transmitted through blood and sexual intercourse. Using a DIY soft, transparent, pinkish artificial vagina without a condom, even if it is only for personal use and cleaned before and after, can still pose some risks. If it is stored while still damp in a plastic...


Dr. Li Yilun reply Urology
HIV is transmitted through bodily fluids, so it requires contact with the blood of an HIV-positive individual (such as sharing needles for drug use) or contact with bodily fluids (such as engaging in unprotected sexual intercourse). Therefore, if you have not had sexual contact w...

[Read More] Understanding HIV Transmission Risks: Myths and Facts Explained


Understanding HIV Transmission Risks and Skin Care for Psoriasis

Dear Dr. Liao, I do not engage in any high-risk behaviors, but I have psoriasis that causes redness and peeling of the skin on my limbs (sometimes I scratch until I break the skin or cause cracks due to itching). Does this condition increase my risk of indirectly contracting HIV...


Dr. Liao Zhongxin reply Internal Medicine
According to the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) in Taiwan, the transmission routes of the Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV) are as follows: 1. Sexual Transmission: Engaging in oral, anal, or vaginal intercourse with an HIV-infected individual or exchanging other bodily fluid...

[Read More] Understanding HIV Transmission Risks and Skin Care for Psoriasis


Related FAQ