Weaning from Ventilation in ARDS Patients: Key Insights

Q: Weaning from Ventilation in ARDS Patients: Key Insights

Hello： Based on your description, following pneumonia, there has been the development of pulmonary fibrosis and respiratory failure. <br>Currently, the Respiratory Care Center (RCC) training typically lasts for six weeks, and respiratory therapy will regularly (usually once a wee

Please continue to inquire about extubation after ARDS?

Hello! I apologize for the intrusion, and I appreciate your previous professional and selfless responses.
My father, who was previously consulted regarding pneumonia complicated by ARDS, has been transferred from the ICU to the RCC, and he has been on the ventilator for 37 days.
His consciousness is clear.
Yesterday, the doctor informed us that we could attempt to wean him off the ventilator.
Unfortunately, he struggled to breathe after less than 20 minutes and was immediately reconnected to the ventilator.
Before the attempt to wean, the ventilator settings were: pressure support of 10, PEEP of 8, and FiO2 of 30.
Due to the failed attempt, the settings were adjusted to: pressure support of 20, PEEP of 8, and FiO2 of 40.
Today, the doctor expressed that the chances of weaning are very low due to severe pulmonary fibrosis seen on the X-ray.
I have the following questions, and I would greatly appreciate your insights:
1.
Does a single failed weaning attempt hold any significance? Why was the doctor optimistic before the attempt, stating there had been significant improvement and that we could try weaning, yet after the failure, they advised us to prepare for the possibility that the chances of weaning are less than 10%?

2.
The above information comes from the RCC's vital signs, while the ICU's vital signs were still being monitored.
The ICU doctor had a different perspective, indicating that although the X-ray shows severe pulmonary fibrosis, my father was cooperating well with the ventilator and his breathing was stable, suggesting there might still be a chance to wean.
What is your opinion on this?
3.
Are there specific indicators for weaning? What conditions would be favorable for my father to be weaned off the ventilator? Previously, he was very agitated and wanted to be discharged, but the doctors indicated that training was not possible.
He has only calmed down in the last couple of days.
Is there a significant impact from psychological factors?
I sincerely request your clarification on these matters.
Thank you very much! Wishing you all the best.

NURSE, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2009/04/18

Dr. Ke Zhengchang reply Pulmonology

Hello: Based on your description, following pneumonia, there has been the development of pulmonary fibrosis and respiratory failure.
Currently, the Respiratory Care Center (RCC) training typically lasts for six weeks, and respiratory therapy will regularly (usually once a week) assess weaning criteria.
If there is progress, there may be a chance to wean off the ventilator; however, if there is no improvement, after six weeks, the patient must be transferred to a step-down respiratory care unit.
It is recommended to prepare for a tracheostomy for long-term dependence on mechanical ventilation, as the weaning rate may only be 3% to 5%.
Psychological support and rehabilitation training are crucial, and it is necessary to consult with a psychiatrist and involve a rehabilitation therapist for bedside rehabilitation.

Reply Date: 2009/04/18

More Info

Weaning from mechanical ventilation, especially in patients with Acute Respiratory Distress Syndrome (ARDS), is a complex and nuanced process that requires careful consideration of various clinical factors. Your father's situation, having been on a ventilator for 37 days, presents both challenges and opportunities for recovery. Let's address your questions systematically.

1. Significance of a Failed Weaning Attempt: A failed attempt to wean from the ventilator can provide valuable information about the patient's current respiratory status. It does not necessarily indicate a permanent inability to wean; rather, it may reflect the patient's condition at that specific moment. The medical team may have been optimistic prior to the attempt based on improvements in other clinical parameters, but the reality of respiratory function can fluctuate. Factors such as fatigue, anxiety, or even minor infections can impact a patient's ability to breathe independently. Therefore, while a failed attempt can be disheartening, it is not uncommon in the weaning process, especially in ARDS patients.

2. Differing Opinions on Weaning Potential: The discrepancy between the views of the ICU and RCC teams may stem from different assessments of your father's overall condition. While the presence of significant lung fibrosis can complicate weaning, it does not entirely preclude the possibility. The fact that your father was able to tolerate the ventilator settings without significant distress is a positive sign. The ability to maintain stable breathing patterns and oxygenation levels while on the ventilator is crucial. Continuous monitoring and reassessment are essential, as the clinical picture can change rapidly.

3. Weaning Indicators: There are several clinical indicators that can suggest a patient is ready for weaning from mechanical ventilation. These include:
- Respiratory Rate and Pattern: A stable respiratory rate and a pattern that does not show signs of distress (e.g., no use of accessory muscles) are positive signs.

- Oxygenation: Adequate oxygen saturation levels (usually above 90%) on minimal support can indicate readiness.

- Ventilator Settings: Lower settings on the ventilator (such as lower PEEP and pressure support) can suggest that the patient is managing well.

- Patient's Mental Status: A calm and cooperative patient is more likely to succeed in weaning.

- Absence of Significant Comorbidities: Other health issues can complicate weaning, so their management is crucial.

Psychological factors play a significant role in the weaning process. Anxiety and agitation can hinder a patient's ability to breathe independently. It is essential to address these psychological aspects, potentially with the help of mental health professionals. Techniques such as relaxation exercises, reassurance, and gradual exposure to breathing trials can help ease anxiety.

In conclusion, weaning from mechanical ventilation in ARDS patients is a multifaceted process that requires ongoing assessment and a tailored approach. While a failed attempt can be discouraging, it is part of the journey toward recovery. Continuous monitoring, psychological support, and a collaborative approach between the healthcare team and family members are vital in navigating this challenging phase. Your father's progress should be viewed holistically, considering both physical and psychological factors, to optimize his chances of successful weaning in the future.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Weaning from Ventilation: A Guide for Families

Hello, my father was sent to Chung Shan Hospital for emergency treatment after collapsing at home. After a period of treatment in the intensive care unit, his heart rate and blood pressure stabilized, but he remains in a coma with weak spontaneous breathing and still requires int...

Dr. Yang Wenda reply Pulmonology
Hello: The condition of your father and the ability to remove the tube (typically, for patients who are unconscious and unable to effectively cough up secretions, it is not recommended to remove the tube, as they are more likely to experience hypoxia due to ineffective clearance ...

Understanding PEEP Adjustments and Patient Management in ARDS

Dear Dr. Ke, I have heard that you are not only an excellent physician but also possess great medical ethics. Thank you very much! I would like to ask you again: The patient has been hospitalized for 14 days, with PEEP adjusted to 12. They have been on tracheostomy for 2 days,...

Dr. Ke Zhengchang reply Pulmonology
Hello: Based on your description, the patient's critical period has passed, but the decrease in lung capacity and fibrosis following lung injury may take several months to recover. The use of corticosteroids has some therapeutic effect, but the dosage and duration should sti...

Managing Carbon Dioxide Retention in Advanced Cancer Patients

Hello Doctor, my mother is a breast cancer patient, and the cancer cells have metastasized to various organs for several years. Recently, she has been hospitalized due to excessive carbon dioxide accumulation and currently requires a bi-level positive airway pressure (BiPAP) mach...

Dr. Guo Hongyi reply Pulmonology
Hello, It is a normal physiological phenomenon for the body to produce carbon dioxide; however, certain factors can disrupt the balance between production and elimination, necessitating external medical intervention. Generally, the body expels carbon dioxide primarily through r...

Managing Respiratory Challenges in Elderly Patients: A Case Study

Grandma is already 82 years old and is currently in the hospital due to unexplained swelling of the esophagus, which is compressing her airway and causing difficulty in breathing. She has been placed on a ventilator and has received antibiotics, staying in the hospital for two to...

Dr. Liang Yinpan reply Geriatrics
Grandma is currently relying on a ventilator to maintain her breathing. If she cannot be weaned off in the short term, the general physician would recommend a tracheostomy. However, even after the tracheostomy, it does not guarantee that she will be able to be weaned off the vent...