After a car accident, if your calf is still swollen, which specialist should you see?
On the afternoon of May 6th, I was involved in a car accident in Nankan and was sent to the emergency department at Taoyuan Hospital, where I saw a doctor.
On May 7th, I returned to Taipei and went to the emergency department at National Taiwan University Hospital, where the doctor advised me to monitor for 5P symptoms.
On May 8th, after experiencing pain for a while and worrying about changes in my condition, I went to the emergency department at Shin Kong Hospital.
The doctor there was concerned about the possibility of compartment syndrome and advised me to undergo surgery immediately.
What should I do? One doctor said to apply ice, while another said not to.
Who should I listen to? The only common advice from all the doctors is to return for outpatient follow-up and treatment, but none of them specified which specialty I should consult.
I have no external injuries, just swelling in my calf, and my bones have been X-rayed without any abnormalities detected.
Ya Ya, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2010/05/10
Dr. Huang Junxiong reply Surgery
Hello: Your condition may be due to an external impact on the calf, which, although there is no superficial skin damage, may have caused tearing in the subcutaneous layer or even the muscle layer, resulting in a hematoma and bruising.
In mild cases, it may heal on its own, but in more severe cases, drainage of the hematoma or even surgery may be necessary.
It is recommended that you seek treatment from a trauma surgery or plastic surgery specialist.
Reply Date: 2010/05/10
More Info
In the aftermath of a car accident, persistent leg swelling can be a concerning symptom that warrants careful evaluation. Given your situation, where you've already consulted multiple emergency departments and received differing opinions on treatment, it's crucial to approach this systematically.
Firstly, it's important to understand that leg swelling can arise from various causes, especially following trauma. Common reasons include soft tissue injury, deep vein thrombosis (DVT), compartment syndrome, or even lymphatic issues. Since you mentioned that you have no visible external injuries and your X-rays did not reveal any fractures, the swelling could be due to soft tissue damage or fluid accumulation.
Which Specialist to Consult?
1. Orthopedic Specialist: Since you have already undergone X-rays, an orthopedic doctor can evaluate any potential musculoskeletal injuries that may not be visible on standard imaging. They can assess for any soft tissue injuries, such as ligament or tendon damage, that could contribute to swelling.
2. Vascular Surgeon: Given your concern about compartment syndrome and the risk of DVT, consulting a vascular surgeon may be beneficial. They can perform Doppler ultrasound studies to check for blood clots in the veins of your leg, which can cause swelling and pain.
3. Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation (PM&R) Specialist: Also known as physiatrists, these specialists focus on rehabilitation and can help manage pain and swelling through non-surgical methods. They can provide a comprehensive rehabilitation plan that may include physical therapy, medication management, and other modalities.
4. General Practitioner (GP): If you're unsure where to start, your GP can provide a referral to the appropriate specialist based on your symptoms and medical history. They can also help coordinate your care and ensure that all aspects of your health are considered.
Treatment Considerations
- Ice Therapy: While one doctor advised against ice, it is generally accepted that ice can help reduce swelling and pain in the acute phase of an injury. Applying ice for 15-20 minutes every hour can be beneficial, but make sure to wrap the ice pack in a cloth to prevent frostbite.
- Elevation: Keeping your leg elevated can help reduce swelling. Try to elevate your leg above the level of your heart when resting.
- Compression: Using compression stockings or wraps can help manage swelling. However, be cautious not to wrap too tightly, as this could exacerbate swelling or lead to complications.
- Monitoring Symptoms: Keep track of any changes in your symptoms, such as increased pain, changes in color or temperature of the leg, or any new symptoms like shortness of breath, which could indicate a more serious condition like DVT.
Follow-Up Care
It’s essential to follow up with the recommended specialists for ongoing evaluation and treatment. They may suggest further imaging studies, such as an MRI or ultrasound, to get a clearer picture of the underlying issues. Additionally, they can provide guidance on physical therapy to strengthen the affected area and improve mobility.
In summary, while it can be frustrating to navigate differing medical opinions, focusing on consulting the right specialists—orthopedic, vascular, or rehabilitation—will help you get the appropriate care for your persistent leg swelling. Always prioritize your health and seek immediate care if your symptoms worsen or if you experience new concerning signs.
Similar Q&A
Persistent Swelling After Car Accident: When to Seek Medical Advice
Today, during a car accident in February, I may have been startled and briefly lost consciousness. When I was called back, my leg was pinned under a motorcycle, and it took a moment to move. Fortunately, I was wearing long pants, and I only had a small abrasion on the inner side ...
Dr. Li Zhonghuai reply Surgery
Hello! It is recommended to directly perform a CT scan of the lower leg, as chronic deep tissue infection needs to be considered. Take care! Changhua Hospital is concerned about you![Read More] Persistent Swelling After Car Accident: When to Seek Medical Advice
Managing Persistent Swelling After a Motorcycle Accident: Expert Advice
Hello Doctor, I was involved in a motorcycle accident where my entire right calf was compressed, resulting in a deep wound on the outer side of my right ankle. The wound has not yet healed. I have bruising from my knee down to my ankle and foot. Four days after the injury, my ank...
Dr. Xu Kaixi reply Surgery
Based on your description, if you have been taking medication and paying attention to your daily activities, it seems that you are lacking in rest. Additionally, you may want to consider an evaluation and treatment from a rehabilitation specialist.[Read More] Managing Persistent Swelling After a Motorcycle Accident: Expert Advice
Managing Swelling After a Car Accident: When to Seek Medical Help
Hello doctor, I would like to ask about my condition after a car accident. The hospital diagnosed me with an open wound on my calf that required two stitches and a contusion, but no bone injury. However, it has been two months, and my calf is still swollen. I would like to know w...
Dr. Li Qinglong reply Surgery
Mr. Li: Hello, I am unable to provide an online response as I have not seen the condition of your calf. I recommend that you consult the physician who initially treated you for the best advice. The Hualien Hospital of the Ministry of Health and Welfare cares about your health.[Read More] Managing Swelling After a Car Accident: When to Seek Medical Help
Persistent Swelling in One Leg: What Specialist to Consult?
Hello Doctor: My father has diabetes and has recently experienced swelling in his foot, which extends beyond the sole to the ankle, but it is only affecting one foot. He has seen a metabolic specialist who found no issues. Which department should he consult?
Dr. Xiao Yongxun reply Internal Medicine
Dear Ms. Emily: 1. There are many causes of lower extremity edema. Generally speaking, if the edema is bilateral, one should consider heart failure, nephrotic syndrome, hypoalbuminemia, cirrhosis, medication side effects, pregnancy, hypothyroidism, and other potential causes. I...[Read More] Persistent Swelling in One Leg: What Specialist to Consult?
Related FAQ
(Surgery)
Car Accident Injury(Orthopedics)
Wounds From Car Accident(Surgery)
Leg(Surgery)
Leg(Neurology)
Car Accident Injury(Neurology)
Post-Tibial Fracture Surgery(Orthopedics)
Leg(Internal Medicine)
Ankle Ligament Injury(Orthopedics)
Car Accident(Family Medicine)