Hemorrhoids: Treatment Options and When to Seek a Second Opinion - Surgery

Share to:

Hemorrhoid inquiry?


Hello, the situation is as follows: From September 1 to September 5, I experienced pain from an external anal mass and sought medical attention on September 6.
The physician diagnosed it as a thrombosed external hemorrhoid and prescribed a suppository, noting that it did not affect the internal hemorrhoid, which was larger.
The doctor mentioned that it could be treated or left untreated.
Ultimately, I underwent rubber band ligation on September 7, but the rubber band fell off during a bowel movement, and I am unsure of the reason.

My concerns are: I usually do not have blood in my stool and do not feel that the internal hemorrhoid has any significant impact.
Additionally, I felt that the physician did not appear very professional or thorough.
I would like to know if the failed treatment of the internal hemorrhoid poses any risks.
Should I return for a follow-up examination after a week, or can I seek a second opinion from another physician, or should I just ignore it?

A-Zhi, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2010/09/07

Dr. Ke Fangxu reply Surgery


Hello: In response to your question, external hemorrhoid thrombosis is generally recommended to be treated with thrombectomy.
If surgery is not preferred, topical ointments can be used, although the recovery time may be longer.
For internal hemorrhoids, there are several treatment options available.
Rubber band ligation is one of the treatment methods, and the band typically falls off within 5-7 days.
If it falls off earlier, it is usually not a concern as long as there is no pain or bleeding.
It is important to reiterate that if hemorrhoids are not accompanied by bleeding, prolapse, or pain, treatment may not be necessary.
If you have any questions, it is advisable to consult a colorectal surgeon for assistance.

Reply Date: 2010/09/07

More Info


Hemorrhoids, commonly known as piles, are swollen veins in the lower rectum and anus that can cause discomfort, pain, and bleeding. They can be classified as either internal or external, depending on their location. Internal hemorrhoids are located inside the rectum and are usually painless, while external hemorrhoids are found under the skin around the anus and can be painful, especially if a blood clot forms (thrombosed hemorrhoid).

In your case, it appears that you have been diagnosed with a thrombosed external hemorrhoid, which can be quite painful. The treatment options for hemorrhoids vary based on their severity and the symptoms they cause. For thrombosed external hemorrhoids, treatments may include:
1. Conservative Management: This includes warm sitz baths, over-the-counter pain relievers (like ibuprofen or acetaminophen), and topical treatments to relieve discomfort.

2. Minimally Invasive Procedures: If the pain is severe or if the hemorrhoid does not improve with conservative measures, procedures such as rubber band ligation, sclerotherapy, or infrared coagulation may be recommended. Rubber band ligation involves placing a small band around the base of the hemorrhoid to cut off its blood supply, causing it to shrink and fall off.

3. Surgical Options: In cases where other treatments fail or if there are complications, surgical removal of the hemorrhoids (hemorrhoidectomy) may be necessary.

Regarding your specific situation, it seems that you underwent rubber band ligation for your internal hemorrhoid, but you are concerned about the effectiveness of the treatment and the potential for complications. It is important to note that while rubber band ligation is generally effective, there can be complications, such as pain, bleeding, or infection. If the rubber band fell off prematurely, it may not have had the intended effect, and you should monitor your symptoms closely.


When to Seek a Second Opinion
If you feel that your current physician is not addressing your concerns adequately or if you are unsure about the treatment plan, seeking a second opinion is a reasonable course of action. Here are some indicators that you might want to consult another physician:
- Persistent Symptoms: If you continue to experience significant pain, bleeding, or discomfort after treatment, it may be time to consult another specialist.

- Lack of Improvement: If your symptoms do not improve or worsen after the initial treatment, a second opinion can provide new insights or alternative treatment options.

- Dissatisfaction with Care: If you feel that your physician is not taking your concerns seriously or if you feel rushed during appointments, it may be beneficial to seek care from another provider who can offer a more thorough evaluation.


Follow-Up Care
As for follow-up care, it is generally advisable to have a follow-up appointment after any procedure to assess healing and address any ongoing symptoms. If you have not been scheduled for a follow-up, consider reaching out to your physician's office to discuss your symptoms and the need for a re-evaluation.
In summary, while hemorrhoids can often be managed effectively with conservative measures and minimally invasive procedures, it is crucial to monitor your symptoms and seek further evaluation if necessary. If you feel uncertain about your current treatment plan or the professionalism of your healthcare provider, do not hesitate to seek a second opinion. Your health and comfort are paramount, and you deserve to have your concerns addressed thoroughly.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Hemorrhoids: Treatment Options, Risks, and Benefits

Hello, Doctor. I have had hemorrhoids for several years. Previously, I visited a gastroenterologist due to rectal bleeding, and the doctor advised me to see a colorectal surgeon to consider treatment for my hemorrhoids. The colorectal surgeon initially prescribed an ointment for ...


Dr. Ke Fangxu reply Surgery
The management of hemorrhoids varies depending on the severity of symptoms. For mild cases, topical medications and improvement of bowel habits may suffice. If there is persistent bleeding, rubber band ligation can be performed. In cases of severe prolapse or recurrent bleeding, ...

[Read More] Understanding Hemorrhoids: Treatment Options, Risks, and Benefits


Non-Surgical Solutions for Severe Hemorrhoids: What You Need to Know

Hello, Doctor: Thank you for your response. I lack the courage to seek medical treatment, even though I know in my heart that my hemorrhoids are likely at stage three or four. I understand that surgery may be necessary, which makes me even more reluctant to go. Moreover, I don&#x...


Dr. Ke Fangxu reply Surgery
Hello: The treatment for hemorrhoids is not limited to surgery; there are many other options available between surgical and medical treatments. The key issues are the effectiveness of these treatments and their suitability for you. These local treatment methods include infrared t...

[Read More] Non-Surgical Solutions for Severe Hemorrhoids: What You Need to Know


Managing Hemorrhoids: When to Seek Further Treatment

Hello, doctor. One day while taking a shower, I discovered a protrusion around my anus. I went to see a doctor, and it has been almost a month since then. The doctor said my condition is very mild and only prescribed me suppositories and ointment. However, recently, I don't ...


Dr. Ke Fangxu reply Surgery
If hemorrhoids are not accompanied by bleeding or pain, surgical treatment is generally not recommended. If one truly wishes for external hemorrhoids to disappear, the only method is surgical excision. However, if the condition is very mild, there is really no need for surgery.

[Read More] Managing Hemorrhoids: When to Seek Further Treatment


Managing Internal Hemorrhoids: When to Seek Medical Attention

Hello, Doctor: I apologize for the interruption. I have done some online research and self-assessed my condition, which I believe is stage 1 or 2 internal hemorrhoids. I first discovered them about six years ago and treated them with a ligation method. Recently, it seems to have ...


Dr. Ke Fangxu reply Surgery
To manage hemorrhoidal bleeding, it is important to avoid constipation and prolonged straining during bowel movements. If the bleeding is severe, using rectal suppositories may be more effective. If self-treatment does not lead to improvement after one week, it is advisable to co...

[Read More] Managing Internal Hemorrhoids: When to Seek Medical Attention


Related FAQ