Fluctuations in ANA Antibody Test Results: A Patient's Dilemma

excuse me?

Hello, I received different results for the ANA (antinuclear antibody) test from Renai Hospital and National Taiwan University Hospital within the same week.
One result was 1:320+ and the other was 1:40+.
Three years ago, my result was also 1:320+.
I consulted Dr.
Wu You from the Infectious Disease Department at NTU, who mentioned that there might be an issue with the test result but he wasn't sure.
He also said that ANA values could fluctuate over a few days??!! Is this possible, doctor? (The doctor at Renai said it’s not possible.) Then the doctor at NTU changed his stance and said he didn't know, advising me to see another physician, which was very disappointing! Now, there is a significant discrepancy between the test results from the two clinics, and I'm unsure what to do (the doctor at Renai has retested me).
I just want to know if it is possible for the ANA levels to change from 320+ to 40+ and then back to 320+ within a week, as Dr.
Wu suggested? Isn’t that quite alarming?

te, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2010/09/22

Dr. Gao Jiankai reply Internal Medicine

Hello, thank you for your question.
ANA (Antinuclear Antibody) results can vary between different laboratories, which is related to the testing methods and the experience of the laboratory personnel.
Generally, manual testing methods are considered the most accurate, but this also depends on the technician's expertise.
Another important point is that if you confirm that the testing hospital uses manual methods and maintains good quality, it is advisable to continue monitoring at the same facility, as this helps in better tracking of data fluctuations.
However, ANA is merely a preliminary screening tool to assess whether the individual has immune-related issues.
Even if the value is 320, we will still analyze potential causes based on the patient's symptoms, as some individuals may naturally have higher values.
If there are no symptoms, treatment will not be initiated; we will only recommend continued monitoring.
Additionally, certain immune issues may cause fluctuations in ANA results, so it is essential to consider the patient's overall condition.
The Allergy, Immunology, and Rheumatology department is here to assist you.

Reply Date: 2010/09/22

More Info

The fluctuations in ANA (Antinuclear Antibody) test results can indeed be perplexing and concerning for patients. Your experience of receiving different ANA titers from two hospitals within the same week raises several important points regarding the nature of ANA testing, its interpretation, and the underlying health implications.

1. Understanding ANA Testing: ANA tests are used primarily to screen for autoimmune disorders, including systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE), rheumatoid arthritis, and other connective tissue diseases. The ANA test measures the presence of antibodies that target the nucleus of cells. A positive result indicates that these antibodies are present, but it does not confirm a specific disease. The titer (e.g., 1:320 or 1:40) indicates the dilution at which the antibodies can still be detected, with higher numbers suggesting a greater concentration of antibodies.

2. Variability in Results: It is not uncommon for ANA test results to vary between different laboratories or even between tests conducted at the same facility. This variability can be attributed to several factors:
- Testing Methods: Different laboratories may use different testing methodologies or reagents, which can lead to discrepancies in results.

- Biological Variability: ANA levels can fluctuate due to various factors, including stress, infections, hormonal changes, or even the time of day when the blood is drawn. While significant changes in ANA levels over a short period (like a week) are less common, they are not impossible.

- Interpretation of Results: The interpretation of ANA patterns (such as homogeneous or speckled) can also vary among clinicians, which may contribute to differing opinions on the significance of the results.

3. Clinical Context: The presence of ANA alone is not diagnostic of any specific condition. It is essential to consider the clinical context, including symptoms and other laboratory findings. If you are asymptomatic and have no other indicators of autoimmune disease, a lower titer may not be clinically significant. Conversely, if you have symptoms suggestive of an autoimmune disorder, further evaluation may be warranted regardless of the ANA titer.

4. Next Steps: Given the discrepancies in your ANA results and the varying opinions from different healthcare providers, it may be beneficial to:
- Consult a Rheumatologist: A specialist in autoimmune diseases can provide a more comprehensive evaluation, considering your symptoms, medical history, and laboratory results.

- Repeat Testing: If there is uncertainty about the results, repeating the ANA test at a reliable laboratory may help clarify the situation. Ensure that the same testing method is used for consistency.

- Monitor Symptoms: Keep track of any new or worsening symptoms, as this information can be crucial for your healthcare provider in determining the next steps.

In conclusion, while fluctuations in ANA results can be concerning, they are not uncommon and can be influenced by various factors. It is essential to interpret these results in the context of your overall health and any symptoms you may be experiencing. Engaging with a specialist and considering further testing can help provide clarity and guide appropriate management.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Fluctuating ANA Results: Immune Issues Explained

Doctor, you mentioned that "some immune issues may cause fluctuations in ANA results." What specific immune problems are you referring to? I have lost about 9 kilograms in the past nine months, and my temperature has been consistently between 37.4 and 37.7 degrees Celsi...

Dr. Gao Jiankai reply Internal Medicine
Hello, thank you for your inquiry. Autoimmune diseases that can cause fluctuations in ANA levels include conditions such as Sjögren's syndrome. However, further diagnostic details must be evaluated and arranged by the attending clinician. For unexplained fevers, after being ...

Understanding Positive ANA Test Results: What You Need to Know

Hello, the results of your immunological tests show a positive ANA (antinuclear antibody) with a titer of 1:40 and a pattern described as dense fine speckled. This indicates the presence of antinuclear antibodies, which can be associated with autoimmune diseases. The specific pat...

Dr. Gao Jiankai reply Internal Medicine
Hello, thank you for your inquiry. This is considered normal, and you can follow up in six months or more. If any new rheumatic symptoms arise during this period, please return for an earlier consultation. The Allergy, Immunology, and Rheumatology Department of Changhua Hospital,...

Understanding ANA Test Results: Normal vs. Abnormal Findings Explained

Doctor, could you please tell me if these test results are normal or abnormal? ANA: 1:40 (-) (1:40 (-)) ANA Pattern: - ANA ≥ 1:160 (+) suggestive of clinical significance.

Dr. Lin Sixie reply Rare Disease
Hello: A positive test result requires further diagnosis by a clinical physician.

Understanding ANA 1:160 Homogeneous Pattern and Its Implications

Hello, Doctor Gao. My mother has a family history of immune dysfunction, and she herself has experienced immune system irregularities. Eight years ago, she began to notice unexplained joint pain, primarily affecting her right ankle and the joints of her hands (fingers and wrists)...

Dr. Gao Jiankai reply Internal Medicine
Hello, Xiao Yuan. The ANA value of 160 is slightly elevated, which requires further examination. Additionally, since you are experiencing some joint pain symptoms and lymphadenopathy, it is indeed advisable to conduct further tests on your immune function. Please prepare your lab...